A Quick Peep
Force of Nature
Probably All in the Mind
Hung in a Bad Place
She is Love

Wtf is that shit? You think that’s acceptable for Oasis? No.

HC is the worst Oasis album. DBTT just simply hasn’t aged well.

Overrated? I think it was a bit overrated during the release, but the general opinion about the album isn't really great. I'd even say it is underrated.

That's probably thanks to the way it was portrayed in the media at the time. Like you said, Oasis never really went away, but DBTT was very much played as a "comeback" for the band. The main difference seems to have been that Oasis were considered cool again. Possibly because of all the bands around at that time who cited Oasis as an influence? Or maybe it was that the people who were 16 when MG came out were now writing for the music mags.

Around here, and not necessarily in the mainstream where it gets unnecessarily shit on, that title should go to BHN. 

You think MG being number 4 is the most objectionable thing about that list?

I like BHN, but I just find it to be overrated among many people here, especially with how some rate it as the best Oasis album of all. Fat chance. BHN is good and is solidly the third or fourth best Oasis album, but the production, repetition, and inclusion of Magic Pie drag the album down to not being quite like MG or DM.

The songs on the album would've been better had the production not been so damn bloated and compressed, and just been as evenly balanced as their live sound, with some of those non-core band bits added in (keyboards, strings, brass section, slide guitar, etc.). Not to mention, less repetition and nonsense vocables (e.g. the "Na na na"s scattered throughout All Around the World over top of some really good instrumentation) would've helped a lot too.

The live performances of songs like AATW and It's Getting Better Man!! really highlight what these songs really had to offer and do the songs justice. That's why I think the album's underrated in the mainstream, where the album gets shit on for the songs themselves,but overrated around here, where the album gets praised for its excess that just doesn't sound good at certain parts, like the outro of IGBM!!!. 

And regarding Magic Pie, its placement at track three lets it settle in too soon. Stay Young being on there instead of it, or even My Big Mouth going into Stand By Me, would've carried the energy and excitement of the first two tracks into the rest of the album much better and not made the album seem as bloated. Magic Pie would've been a gem of a B-side, however, much like The Fame and Going Nowhere are.

Had they made those changes, I'd put BHN up there near MG and DM. 

Pretty stable with this ranking now:

1. Definitely Maybe
2. What’s the Story Morning Glory
3. Be Here Now
4. Dig Out Your Soul
5. Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
6. Don’t Believe the Truth
7. Heathen Chemistry

In recent years, DOYS and SOTSOG have both risen, while DBTT has fallen. HC has been ranked last ever since it was released in 2002 - fuck that album.

01. Definitely Maybe
02. (What's The Story) Morning Glory ?
03. SOTSOG
04. Be Here now
05. Dig Out Your Soul
06. Don't Believe The Truth
07. Heathen Chemistry

Many DBTT songs sounded really fresh at the time: MF, TUTS, POTQ, TIOBI sounded unlike anything they did before, LLAB and GGTIA were very refreshing tunes too, even Lyla and LTBL which recalls some their past songs (RWI and SCYHO respectively) sounded brand new.

Definitely the most reasonable ranking I've seen on this forum.

I assume you're being sarcastic. Not gonna apologise for having my own taste in what Oasis music I prefer, and not creating a generic list like everyone else.