|
Post by The Invisible Sun on Oct 26, 2014 13:31:12 GMT -5
Beady, Beady, Beady Fucking Eye! here here brother, here here!! I just can't not enjoy that.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 26, 2014 13:43:24 GMT -5
here here brother, here here!! such an amazing gig i stayed up to watch the live stream, then they repeated it straight away after so stayed up longer and watched it again there was a random american women on the chat bar thing on the side who didn't even know oasis and she loved it, but she kept saying i love it but i just want to cut his hair haha without a doubt one of their finest moments.
|
|
|
Post by The Invisible Sun on Oct 26, 2014 13:46:00 GMT -5
without a doubt one of their finest moments. Yep, I saw the whole thing on stream live too. I remember I was smiling the whole time. Vocals a little spotty, but he really nailed Wigwam, especially at the end. He did very well on The Morning Son too. Good night as a whole. Wish the crowd were a little more excited though.
|
|
|
Post by mkoasis on Oct 26, 2014 13:48:02 GMT -5
I certainly expected a hiatus, not a split.
My top 10 Beady Eye tunes:
World Outside my Room Flick of the Finger Soon Come Tomorrow Ballroom Figured Millionaire Girls in Uniform Off at the Next Exit Morning Son For Anyone Iz Rite
Wanted to do 5 but simply couldn't. Even with these 10, I feel like I'm missing a few essentials like Wigwam and I'm Just Saying. Back After the Break really should be in there too. I'm glad Beady Eye happened and we got these great tunes and gigs with renewed passion. I hope they do come together again when they're ready and up to it to make another album.
|
|
|
Post by jaq515 on Oct 26, 2014 13:53:19 GMT -5
without a doubt one of their finest moments. Yep, I saw the whole thing on stream live too. I remember I was smiling the whole time. Vocals a little spotty, but he really nailed Wigwam, especially at the end. He did very well on The Morning Son too. Good night as a whole. Wish the crowd were a little more excited though. exactly i think that sums them up, the crowd weren't great, the vocals weren't always great either, even some of the songs aren't great but it had that 'thing' that made it fantastic to watch.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Oct 26, 2014 13:56:42 GMT -5
?!?!?! Just another day in the life for LIB. crazy shit... God bless. Holy crap, is that for real? 'Blew up', I thought maybe the roof had partially blown off due to some gas leak, looks serious. Hope nobody was injured.
|
|
|
Post by Mr. Bigglesworth on Oct 26, 2014 13:59:54 GMT -5
Its really weird, but I want a Beady Eye reunion more than an Oasis reunion^^
|
|
|
Post by Let It Bleed on Oct 26, 2014 14:03:00 GMT -5
crazy shit... God bless. Holy crap, is that for real? 'Blew up', I thought maybe the roof had partially blown off due to some gas leak, looks serious. Hope nobody was injured. that's for real.... firefighters are still working on completely containing it. it was probably the work of hardcore BDi fans looking to blow up my house because i only like a few BDi songs and want Liam to go solo/Elvis style, but they accidentally blew up my neighbor's house instead. God bless.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Oct 26, 2014 14:05:13 GMT -5
Holy crap, is that for real? 'Blew up', I thought maybe the roof had partially blown off due to some gas leak, looks serious. Hope nobody was injured. that's for real.... firefighters are still working on completely containing it. it was probably the work of hardcore BDi fans looking to blow up my house because i only like a few BDi songs and want Liam to go solo/Elvis style, but they accidentally blew up my neighbor's house instead. God bless. A terrorist attack from Liam fans? What do they call themselves O-ISIS? I'll get my coat....
|
|
|
Post by mememe26 on Oct 26, 2014 14:05:20 GMT -5
also i know this may not be the popular opinion on here, but i truly believe that beady eye jumped the shark when they started performing oasis tunes live. right then and there, i knew they had had it. Was a stupid thing to do, they should have been tryin' to create an identity of there own. They became a bit of a joke to people when they started doin' that.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 26, 2014 14:20:36 GMT -5
without a doubt one of their finest moments. See this is what I will miss until liam returns to a stage , Look at the audience , he. Commanded the stage , a true front man , he has the" it " factor , love the tunes or not liam brings the swagger , the look of a rock star tjat noel doesn't carry on a stage ( admittedly so ) why they needed each other back in day , liam oozes the Rock persona , seeing that you know he's a rock star even if you were just flipping the Chanells
|
|
|
Post by cigsandalc on Oct 26, 2014 14:29:11 GMT -5
A terrorist attack from Liam fans? What do they call themselves O-ISIS? I'll get my coat....
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Oct 26, 2014 14:32:39 GMT -5
It's amazing how the legions of Oasis fans didn't buy into Beady Eye. Liam Gallagher is a brand. Brand names usually sell. At the same time, a lot of Oasis fans are serious music fans - the majority of us are not, as stereotypically thought, parka wearing, mod haircut, shades wearing teens who are 'mad fer it'. We'll buy music on its own merits, rather than image. You're getting boring matt to be honest. Yeah, you didn't like them, we know. Yeah, you thought most of there fans were Liam clones, we know. Derivative, 60's/70's throwbacks, simple songsunderdevelopedstructuresbadliamattitude..........we know. I've never met someone on a forum with such a talent for sweeping statements, generalisations and musical pretentiousness. I mean for fucks sake I've been to 14 Oasis gigs and a few Beady Eye ones and never heard anyone say 'mad fer it'. Yes some people imitate Liam but that doesn't mean they aren't 'serious music fans'. Actually, please explain to me what in the hell a serious music fan is? You talk of stereotypes while pigeon holing a group of fans of a band that you don't even like. Oh and for all the people who keep asking why they played Oasis songs that weren't written by them. Watch the reaction to them at the gigs they played and remember that not everyone takes these things as seriously or treats them as protectively as us lot on here.
|
|
|
Post by Regi on Oct 26, 2014 14:44:53 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by jaq515 on Oct 26, 2014 14:47:55 GMT -5
amazing picture. In 10-15 years times that will become an iconic pic in gallagher/bdi/oasis history
|
|
squire
Oasis Roadie
This old town don't smell too pretty
Posts: 348
|
Post by squire on Oct 26, 2014 14:56:40 GMT -5
LG will return!
|
|
|
Post by matt on Oct 26, 2014 15:09:28 GMT -5
At the same time, a lot of Oasis fans are serious music fans - the majority of us are not, as stereotypically thought, parka wearing, mod haircut, shades wearing teens who are 'mad fer it'. We'll buy music on its own merits, rather than image. You're getting boring matt to be honest. Yeah, you didn't like them, we know. Yeah, you thought most of there fans were Liam clones, we know. Derivative, 60's/70's throwbacks, simple songsunderdevelopedstructuresbadliamattitude..........we know. I've never met someone on a forum with such a talent for sweeping statements, generalisations and musical pretentiousness. I mean for fucks sake I've been to 14 Oasis gigs and a few Beady Eye ones and never heard anyone say 'mad fer it'. Yes some people imitate Liam but that doesn't mean they aren't 'serious music fans'. Actually, please explain to me what in the hell a serious music fan is? You talk of stereotypes while pigeon holing a group of fans of a band that you don't even like. Oh and for all the people who keep asking why they played Oasis songs that weren't written by them. Watch the reaction to them at the gigs they played and remember that not everyone takes these things as seriously or treats them as protectively as us lot on here. God's sake, I didn't say EVERY Beady Eye fan is a Liam clone. But undoubtedly, if it wasn't Liam Gallagher, nobody would give a toss and 99% of the people on this forum would have no idea who they are or have any remote interest in them. I don't doubt your love for the music, but there are some fans that can't look beyond the image which distorts their view of the music. I mean come on, if Coldplay had written The Beat Goes On, some Beady Eye fans would undoubtedly think it's 'so gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay' or whatever insult they can come up with, yet if Yellow was written by Beady Eye, it would be the greatest thing since sliced bread. In my personal opinion, Beady Eye are pretty guilty of writing soft, sappy songs. I don't like their music for the majority, although I think they have a couple of crackers. That's my personal opinion. Don't pretend those deluded fans are not out there - we've seen it with Oasis. We all love Oasis, hence why we're all on this forum - but there's no doubt that they attracted some of the most stupid people in the world. All that piss throwing and fisticuffs at Oasis gigs? Not really the act of anyone with an ounce of intelligence. Many of those fans will have transferred over to Beady Eye. My argument is Beady Eye only lasted as long as they were, or were as popular as they were, because of the image and those who are attracted by such superficial qualities.
|
|
|
Post by saruzzu on Oct 26, 2014 15:17:07 GMT -5
I think the band has done some good things but many negative, liam has the largest part of the blame for this failure, too many personal problems and a voice that is now unrecoverable. the initial error of not wanting to play the songs of Oasis was great because if instead of bad songs like "Beatles and Stones", "for anyone", "standing on the edge of the noize", "Man of Misery" "wind up dreams" and "three ring circus" were played "turn up the sun", "i'm outta time", "Born on a different cloud" and "thank you for the goodtimes" maybe now we were talking about other things . in this period are sold few records and the success of the band is almost always decreed by concerts and tours, Noel was clever to put 9-10 pieces of the early Oasis, not songs from DBTT and DOYS because people want to listen the great classics and the results were there I liked beady eye a bit, I've seen them 11 times in total(even if I have seen them more for liam that for the real value of the band), but the end was the only possible solution because they have not been able to demonstrate that they are serious musicians and have often been too quick to make a record or go on stage.
however songs like "four letter word", "The Beat Goes On," soon comes tomorrow, "flick of the finger", "back after the break", "off at the next exit," "evil eye" and "in the bubble with a bullet "are great pieces that made us understand that if they want can write good pieces, unfortunately, the rest is all stuff to discard
|
|
|
Post by jaq515 on Oct 26, 2014 15:23:38 GMT -5
You're getting boring matt to be honest. Yeah, you didn't like them, we know. Yeah, you thought most of there fans were Liam clones, we know. Derivative, 60's/70's throwbacks, simple songsunderdevelopedstructuresbadliamattitude..........we know. I've never met someone on a forum with such a talent for sweeping statements, generalisations and musical pretentiousness. I mean for fucks sake I've been to 14 Oasis gigs and a few Beady Eye ones and never heard anyone say 'mad fer it'. Yes some people imitate Liam but that doesn't mean they aren't 'serious music fans'. Actually, please explain to me what in the hell a serious music fan is? You talk of stereotypes while pigeon holing a group of fans of a band that you don't even like. Oh and for all the people who keep asking why they played Oasis songs that weren't written by them. Watch the reaction to them at the gigs they played and remember that not everyone takes these things as seriously or treats them as protectively as us lot on here. God's sake, I didn't say EVERY Beady Eye fan is a Liam clone. But undoubtedly, if it wasn't Liam Gallagher, nobody would give a toss and 99% of the people on this forum would have no idea who they are or have any remote interest in them. I don't doubt your love for the music, but there are some fans that can't look beyond the image which distorts their view of the music. I mean come on, if Coldplay had written The Beat Goes On, some Beady Eye fans would undoubtedly think it's 'so gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay' or whatever insult they can come up with, yet if Yellow was written by Beady Eye, it would be the greatest thing since sliced bread. In my personal opinion, Beady Eye are pretty guilty of writing soft, sappy songs. I don't like their music for the majority, although I think they have a couple of crackers. That's my personal opinion. Don't pretend those deluded fans are not out there - we've seen it with Oasis. We all love Oasis, hence why we're all on this forum - but there's no doubt that they attracted some of the most stupid people in the world. All that piss throwing and fisticuffs at Oasis gigs? Not really the act of anyone with an ounce of intelligence. Many of those fans will have transferred over to Beady Eye. My argument is Beady Eye only lasted as long as they were, or were as popular as they were, because of the image and those who are attracted by such superficial qualities. I went to 11 beady eye gigs and never saw any of the piss throwing / fisticuffs (that happens at a lot of stadium gigs not just oasis) .. Where did YOU see those fans that transferred over to BDI gigs as "many of those fans will have transferred over to Beady Eye" (Also your coldplay comment i think start anew (for me personally) is as near to a coldplay song a gallagher song sounded and all fans love it) but the if this band made this song argument is all conjecture no actual facts..
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 26, 2014 15:34:45 GMT -5
Well this is just shit news! I loved Beady Eye, ffs! Wouldn't it be funny though if Liam was being dead serious all these years when he said he'd give up when he starts going bald? Maybe he just looked in the mirror a few days ago, sighed, then called an emergency meeting for the band declaring his career over
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Oct 26, 2014 15:44:53 GMT -5
You're getting boring matt to be honest. Yeah, you didn't like them, we know. Yeah, you thought most of there fans were Liam clones, we know. Derivative, 60's/70's throwbacks, simple songsunderdevelopedstructuresbadliamattitude..........we know. I've never met someone on a forum with such a talent for sweeping statements, generalisations and musical pretentiousness. I mean for fucks sake I've been to 14 Oasis gigs and a few Beady Eye ones and never heard anyone say 'mad fer it'. Yes some people imitate Liam but that doesn't mean they aren't 'serious music fans'. Actually, please explain to me what in the hell a serious music fan is? You talk of stereotypes while pigeon holing a group of fans of a band that you don't even like. Oh and for all the people who keep asking why they played Oasis songs that weren't written by them. Watch the reaction to them at the gigs they played and remember that not everyone takes these things as seriously or treats them as protectively as us lot on here. God's sake, I didn't say EVERY Beady Eye fan is a Liam clone. But undoubtedly, if it wasn't Liam Gallagher, nobody would give a toss and 99% of the people on this forum would have no idea who they are or have any remote interest in them. I don't doubt your love for the music, but there are some fans that can't look beyond the image which distorts their view of the music. I mean come on, if Coldplay had written The Beat Goes On, some Beady Eye fans would undoubtedly think it's 'so gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay' or whatever insult they can come up with, yet if Yellow was written by Beady Eye, it would be the greatest thing since sliced bread. In my personal opinion, Beady Eye are pretty guilty of writing soft, sappy songs. I don't like their music for the majority, although I think they have a couple of crackers. That's my personal opinion. Don't pretend those deluded fans are not out there - we've seen it with Oasis. We all love Oasis, hence why we're all on this forum - but there's no doubt that they attracted some of the most stupid people in the world. All that piss throwing and fisticuffs at Oasis gigs? Not really the act of anyone with an ounce of intelligence. Many of those fans will have transferred over to Beady Eye. My argument is Beady Eye only lasted as long as they were, or were as popular as they were, because of the image and those who are attracted by such superficial qualities. I didn't even say you said 'every'. You can say that about a lot of solo projects. If a new artist had released Thom Yorke's latest bleep bleep project do you think they would be making another album? A fraction of the people would have listened to it. Would the Johnny Marr's albums (and I like both) under an unknown banner do much? Again, what if this band wrote that or they wrote this. How is that relevant? You can turn that around with any band. A lot of music listeners might love flick of the finger if it was written by there favourite band but because Beady Eye wrote it and it involves Liam Gallagher they aint interested. There are deluded fans for all bands, it seems to me matt that you deem someone deluded if they don't share your opinion on Beady Eye as a third rate band. I've seen your posts about U2 and Coldplay and you defend them whatever the argument. Some might call you deluded. I wouldn't personally because you just seem to be a fan passionate about there music. Your last statement is quite clearly wrong. That implies it has nothing to do with music. Did you go see them? Meet and chat to the people going to the gigs? If you had you would realise what an incredibly silly thing it is to say.
|
|
|
Post by theyknowwhatimean on Oct 26, 2014 15:46:52 GMT -5
LG will return! I can't see it myself, but christ, I do hope so!... That picture pretty much sums up Liam's irreplaceable position in rock/guitar music. Like him or not, whether he's making good music or shit music, whether his voice is on fire or completely shot, he's such a huge personality and incites such varying opinions, music will surely become even duller than it already is without him
|
|
|
Post by derektrotter on Oct 26, 2014 15:48:15 GMT -5
BE was a great album but had shit promotion, stupid track selection and the gigs were nothing special, management ruined them...sad...
|
|
|
Post by The Invisible Sun on Oct 26, 2014 15:48:54 GMT -5
I blame Liam's silly haircut in 2011 for the failure of Beady Eye.
|
|
|
Post by The Invisible Sun on Oct 26, 2014 15:49:52 GMT -5
Will Noel be able to fill the gap in our hearts?
|
|