andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:10:10 GMT -5
is it just me that feels let down by beady eyes new songs?
i thought that liam would be desperate to show he was more than just noel's singer and make a great album- how wrong i was!
before anyone starts off- i am the biggest oasis fan there is- that includes noel AND liam! and i also love andy and gem.
however i am not one of those fans who will swallow any old shite- if a song is shit it is shit, no matter who it is by!
i cant believe how many suck ups on here were saying bring the light 9/10 ect ect....
what a load of bollocks!!!!
i love oasis cos they were fucking brilliant!!!
but beady eye are far from it!!
i will still follow them and buy all their stuff but compared to a lot of other bands around they are shite!
when oasis were on form no one could touch them, but beady eye dont cut it- look at kasabian, they piss all over them.
and its not just kasabian- they wouldnt even get a look in if they hadnt been in oasis!
if they were a new unknown band and sent their cd to execs they would never get signed up!
there are loads of unsigned bands that have miles better material!
i was hoping liam was gonna show that he can shine without noel but i havent seen any sign of that. for everyone who said oasis was all noel was absolutely right judging by the output of beady eye we have seen so far.
i mean, with the songs that liam and co had before noel joined oasis, they would have never made it!
instead of always slagging noel off liam should realise he would have been nothing without noel.
again i love liam ( i know it may not seem that way), but that is the way it is!
as for beady eyes new stuff- noels soundchecks sound miles better!
|
|
|
|
Post by danscouse on Feb 3, 2011 19:15:01 GMT -5
Are you Noel?!
|
|
|
|
Post by pixarito on Feb 3, 2011 19:16:30 GMT -5
I understand your point, but these Beady Eye's songs we've heard already are better than or equal to at least 3 songs in each and everyone of oasis albums. Period.
Without mentioning that the best, fresher song on HC(songbird) and DOYS(im outta time) was written by Liam. He IS good with melodies.
|
|
|
|
Post by thedon on Feb 3, 2011 19:18:46 GMT -5
I'd have to agree. More excited about the prospect of those demos BigUn's been on about uploading than the Beady Eye album really. Though I'm not sure if that's gonna come to fruition judging by the length of time it's taking...
Beady Eye's songs are just weak so far.
|
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:19:36 GMT -5
I understand your point, but these Beady Eye's songs we've heard already are better than at least 3 songs in each and everyone of oasis albums. Period. if the whole album is as good as ANY oasis album i will be very very pleasently suprised!! |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 19:20:02 GMT -5
Well I for one love BTL it has energy, its a bit manic and sounds nothing like Oasis to me. Kinda what I was hoping for. FLW would comfortably oust a lot of Oasis songs on the previous 3 albums but it is all opinions.
I don't know why you're buying BE's stuff if you don't like them, seems a bit silly to me. And before you harp on about Liam slagging Noel off I suggest you pay more attention to what Liam has been saying. If what he say's is true then he's entitled to the odd dig imo.
|
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 19:20:51 GMT -5
I understand your point, but these Beady Eye's songs we've heard already are better than at least 3 songs in each and everyone of oasis albums. Period. if the whole album is as good as ANY oasis album i will be very very pleasently suprised!! It can't be worse than HC, its really not possible. |
|
|
|
Post by oasisfanboy on Feb 3, 2011 19:21:44 GMT -5
is it just me that feels let down by beady eyes new songs? i thought that liam would be desperate to show he was more than just noel's singer and make a great album- how wrong i was! before anyone starts off- i am the biggest oasis fan there is- that includes noel AND liam! and i also love andy and gem. however i am not one of those fans who will swallow any old shite- if a song is shit it is shit, no matter who it is by! i cant believe how many suck ups on here were saying bring the light 9/10 ect ect.... what a load of bollocks!!!! i love oasis cos they were fucking brilliant!!! but beady eye are far from it!! i will still follow them and buy all their stuff but compared to a lot of other bands around they are shite! when oasis were on form no one could touch them, but beady eye dont cut it- look at kasabian, they piss all over them. and its not just kasabian- they wouldnt even get a look in if they hadnt been in oasis! if they were a new unknown band and sent their cd to execs they would never get signed up! there are loads of unsigned bands that have miles better material! i was hoping liam was gonna show that he can shine without noel but i havent seen any sign of that. for everyone who said oasis was all noel was absolutely right judging by the output of beady eye we have seen so far. i mean, with the songs that liam and co had before noel joined oasis, they would have never made it! instead of always slagging noel off liam should realise he would have been nothing without noel. again i love liam ( i know it may not seem that way), but that is the way it is! as for beady eyes new stuff- noels soundchecks sound miles better! Oasis 1994-1997 - totally agree. Oasis 1998-2009 - no chance. as much mediocre as there was quality. |
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:21:56 GMT -5
I'd have to agree. More excited about the prospect of those demos BigUn's been on about uploading than the Beady Eye album really. Though I'm not sure if that's gonna come to fruition judging by the length of time it's taking... Beady Eye's songs are just weak so far. glad to here someone agrees with me. i would absolutley LOVE beady eyes new album to be amazing but i am not impressed from what i have heard so far. and it is not cos i want to here an oasis sound- i am happy for a different vibe as long as it sounds good!! |
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:24:07 GMT -5
Well I for one love BTL it has energy, its a bit manic and sounds nothing like Oasis to me. Kinda what I was hoping for. FLW would comfortably oust a lot of Oasis songs on the previous 3 albums but it is all opinions. I don't know why you're buying BE's stuff if you don't like them, seems a bit silly to me. And before you harp on about Liam slagging Noel off I suggest you pay more attention to what Liam has been saying. If what he say's is true then he's entitled to the odd dig imo. are you serious?? nearly every interview liam has he gets a dig in about noel! the little man, boring, blah blah blah well without noel liam would still be living in burnage without a pot to piss in! |
|
|
|
Post by pixarito on Feb 3, 2011 19:24:16 GMT -5
is it just me that feels let down by beady eyes new songs? i thought that liam would be desperate to show he was more than just noel's singer and make a great album- how wrong i was! before anyone starts off- i am the biggest oasis fan there is- that includes noel AND liam! and i also love andy and gem. however i am not one of those fans who will swallow any old shite- if a song is shit it is shit, no matter who it is by! i cant believe how many suck ups on here were saying bring the light 9/10 ect ect.... what a load of bollocks!!!! i love oasis cos they were fucking brilliant!!! but beady eye are far from it!! i will still follow them and buy all their stuff but compared to a lot of other bands around they are shite! when oasis were on form no one could touch them, but beady eye dont cut it- look at kasabian, they piss all over them. and its not just kasabian- they wouldnt even get a look in if they hadnt been in oasis! if they were a new unknown band and sent their cd to execs they would never get signed up! there are loads of unsigned bands that have miles better material! i was hoping liam was gonna show that he can shine without noel but i havent seen any sign of that. for everyone who said oasis was all noel was absolutely right judging by the output of beady eye we have seen so far. i mean, with the songs that liam and co had before noel joined oasis, they would have never made it! instead of always slagging noel off liam should realise he would have been nothing without noel. again i love liam ( i know it may not seem that way), but that is the way it is! as for beady eyes new stuff- noels soundchecks sound miles better! Oasis 1994-1997 - totally agree. Oasis 1998-2009 - no chance. as much mediocre as there was quality. You nailed it. |
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:25:13 GMT -5
if the whole album is as good as ANY oasis album i will be very very pleasently suprised!! It can't be worse than HC, its really not possible. lol. HC had a few crackers on |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 19:29:44 GMT -5
Well I for one love BTL it has energy, its a bit manic and sounds nothing like Oasis to me. Kinda what I was hoping for. FLW would comfortably oust a lot of Oasis songs on the previous 3 albums but it is all opinions. I don't know why you're buying BE's stuff if you don't like them, seems a bit silly to me. And before you harp on about Liam slagging Noel off I suggest you pay more attention to what Liam has been saying. If what he say's is true then he's entitled to the odd dig imo. are you serious?? nearly every interview liam has he gets a dig in about noel! the little man, boring, blah blah blah well without noel liam would still be living in burnage without a pot to piss in! Go back and see what Liam has been talking about concerning the split and then read my post again. Cheers. |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 19:30:30 GMT -5
It can't be worse than HC, its really not possible. lol. HC had a few crackers on 'Few' being the operative word. Its pretty poor. |
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:34:07 GMT -5
are you serious?? nearly every interview liam has he gets a dig in about noel! the little man, boring, blah blah blah well without noel liam would still be living in burnage without a pot to piss in! Go back and see what Liam has been talking about concerning the split and then read my post again. Cheers. i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel! fair enough he said oasis was great- but he still gets digs in about noel. he might moan about noel being this and that- but if it wasnt for noel oasis would never hadve existed!!! |
|
|
|
Post by eva Fawkes on Feb 3, 2011 19:36:15 GMT -5
Go back and see what Liam has been talking about concerning the split and then read my post again. Cheers. i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel! fair enough he said oasis was great- but he still gets digs in about noel. Liam's probably a little jealous of Noel, as it appears he should be. |
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:37:35 GMT -5
i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel! fair enough he said oasis was great- but he still gets digs in about noel. Liam's probably a little jealous of Noel, as it appears he should be. lol. |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 19:42:48 GMT -5
Go back and see what Liam has been talking about concerning the split and then read my post again. Cheers. i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel! fair enough he said oasis was great- but he still gets digs in about noel. he might moan about noel being this and that- but if it wasnt for noel oasis would never hadve existed!!! ffs mate you obviously haven't, as in if what Liam say's is true Noel walked out and put out a statement that was mostly false all because he wanted a way out. Now all i'm saying is that if that is true then he's probably pissed of with him and I wouldn't begrudge him a dig or two. |
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:47:47 GMT -5
i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel! fair enough he said oasis was great- but he still gets digs in about noel. he might moan about noel being this and that- but if it wasnt for noel oasis would never hadve existed!!! ffs mate you obviously haven't, as in if what Liam say's is true Noel walked out and put out a statement that was mostly false all because he wanted a way out. Now all i'm saying is that if that is true then he's probably pissed of with him and I wouldn't begrudge him a dig or two. well if you check my original post i didnt mention the facts of the split- i just said that liam was always slagging noel off! and if liam has his gripes about noel i am sure noel has just as many gripes about liam! ie. him not doing soundchecks ect... and his live performances very suspect whereas the rest of the band were always consistant. |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 19:51:49 GMT -5
'i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel!'
You have referred to the time since the split and I gave you a reason why Liam might have been more vocal about Noel of late which you hav ignored by saying...
'well if you check my original post i didnt mention the facts of the split'
aWhich is irrelevant. You are clearly a Noel fanboy who will swallow anything he puts out. Thus no better.
|
|
|
|
Post by thuperthonic on Feb 3, 2011 19:58:27 GMT -5
Of all the songs released thus far, Four Letter Word is the only genuinely mega tune. It's got a great vibe, great singing, catchy melody, and great guitar work. It's gonna be a monster live.
I'm also excited to hear several of the tunes on the album whose previews sound promising.
|
|
andytr
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 151
|
Post by andytr on Feb 3, 2011 19:59:48 GMT -5
'i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel!' You have referred to the time since the split and I gave you a reason why Liam might have been more vocal about Noel of late which you hav ignored by saying... 'well if you check my original post i didnt mention the facts of the split' aWhich is irrelevant. You are clearly a Noel fanboy who will swallow anything he puts out. Thus no better. fuck off smart arse!! in my ORIGINAL post i said that liam has done nothing but slag noel off. and if you look i said what liam said SINCE the split NOT about the fucking split!! i wasnt on about the reasons why they split but saying liam is always slagging noel off and should he should be grateful for all that noel has done for oasis. as for the noel fanboy shit!! i am an oasis fan!! and a good fucking music fan!!! the stuff we have heard from beady eye so far hasnt been good!!! oasis was good fucking music!!! so in short, fuck off you smart arsed fucking prick!!!! |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Feb 3, 2011 20:14:05 GMT -5
'i have heard nearly everything liam has said since the split and i cant remember anything nice he has had to say about noel!' You have referred to the time since the split and I gave you a reason why Liam might have been more vocal about Noel of late which you hav ignored by saying... 'well if you check my original post i didnt mention the facts of the split' aWhich is irrelevant. You are clearly a Noel fanboy who will swallow anything he puts out. Thus no better. fuck off smart arse!! in my ORIGINAL post i said that liam has done nothing but slag noel off. and if you look i said what liam said SINCE the split NOT about the fucking split!! i wasnt on about the reasons why they split but saying liam is always slagging noel off and should he should be grateful for all that noel has done for oasis. as for the noel fanboy shit!! i am an oasis fan!! and a good fucking music fan!!! the stuff we have heard from beady eye so far hasnt been good!!! oasis was good fucking music!!! so in short, fuck off you smart arsed fucking prick!!!! blah, blah, blah I tried to explain to you why Liam might be slagging off Noel lately, and that if he is being honest then you can understand it. A point you ignored yet again. keep the insults coming mate. |
|
|
|
Post by Silence Dogood on Feb 3, 2011 20:14:33 GMT -5
lol what a laughable post that was...
just because one says "i loved Oasis and that includes both brothers" doesn't mean that you're not biased one way or the other(when it comes to who you prefer Liam or Noel).
anyway, i too love Oasis but i remain objective and if there is something that i agree with you on, is that shit is shit any way you may wanna put it.
Bring the Light is pure crap imo and i have no problem saying that, just as i have no problem saying that what i have heard so far from Beady Eye's album is already better than Dig Out Your Soul.
So, for you to say that "Oasis was all Noel", i mean, that just makes you sound like a retard.
No one will ever say that any member of BDI is on the same level as Noel in terms songwriting skills.
Having said that, Noel himself hasn't been able to duplicate his own work from the early years. Now, am i suppose to believe Noel will suddenly come up with songs that are on par with the stuff on Definitely Maybe or The Masterplan? lol hell no! he hasn't showed in years that he can still write a classic, at least not what i'd consider to be a classic. Has he written good songs? of course he has.
Ask anyone(who isn't biased) and they'll tell you that TSOTL and 4LW are pretty much on the same level.
Again, I'm not saying BDI will be better than Oasis, im not even saying they'll be as good as Oasis, beacause after all, Noel is missing. But to say they are downright bad? now that is ridiculous and makes you sound like a biased Noel dickrider lol.
|
|
B.e.D.e.
Oasis Roadie
Kurwa, gdzie jest moje piwko??
Posts: 433
|
Post by B.e.D.e. on Feb 3, 2011 20:14:53 GMT -5
damn, i can feel the love tonight  |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5