Noel likes him too

I loved Why Me Why Not? (album) and still play it regularly (not all songs, but plenty). In fact in general I listen to Liam (and Noel's) solo stuff much more than anything post 1997 of Oasis. I liked As You Were (except Chinatown) but found WMWN to be a much more bold and confident album.

And as far as Wyatt's writing goes, he wrote one of the most brilliant and exceptionally "Liam-esque" songs on that album, "The River". An absolute BELTER of a tune which makes its way into my playlists every week. Probably one of my favourite Liam-sung songs since the 90s. The more of these songs the better in my opinion.

Noel Gallagher clearly just took the Beatles back catalogue and ran away with it, doesn't take any talent to conceive What's The Story Morning Glory

It is not just a simple ingredient. Oasis was not Beethoven. a few borrowed notes are enough to create a melody from it. Noel had the good intuition of knowing well which ones to take and was able to use them to the fullest. Oasis weren't made of infinite notes. The melody always rested on the same ones, and very often those "key" notes were borrowed from other songs already published by other authors. I say this not to criticize Oasis' Noel, but to make you understand that here you always make controversy if something "authentic" is not born in a pure way by someone. Well, neither Oasis nor solo Noel nor solo Liam have invented anything new. They have only been able to create great melodies with a few "stolen" chords, making some much better than the originals. Their attitude and Liam's voice did the rest. They had nothing truly authentic in their music, just as many other great bands have nothing authentic. "Pure" and unconditional music ended centuries ago. Today they are just a mix of melodies borrowed here and there. And I don't mind at all as long as Liam is behind that microphone. I don't care if Liam put 2 notes he thought about 7… or AW put 5 or it's a fucking cover. The important thing is that it is good music and that it makes you feel a strong thrill when you listen to it. So stop examining how many notes Liam writes and how many not. Today's music (by anyone - Oasis and many other bands included) is just a mix of what has already been invented by someone. All that matters is that that mix has to be done right and convey something.

I remember my adolescence going crazy for the effectiveness of Hello's refrain only to discover that it was not invented by Noel at all. Once as a kid on a survey of the best riff in Rock I proudly and naively entered "Cigarettes & Alchool by Oasis", they laughed at me and made fun of me because it was not invented by Noel at all. And there are so many of these stories. So to me personally that Liam gets help writing songs, or that he sings about New York, Bethlehem, or the Manchester synagogue I don't care. the thing that makes me delirious is the melody with his voice on it, and the way he pronounces the words. It makes me travel, excites me and rages me like no other. So personally if he only wrote a note and a half word it doesn't bother me at all. We are in 2021 it's all about borrowing, it's all about "co-writing" with someone. For me it could also make an album of all covers. If he can sing them as God commands, in his own way, that's all that really matters.

Ha, can't agree here

If you read the liner notes it's clearly mentionned. Same for Rockin Chair. Some other songs deserved that co-credits though i'll give you that.

We're not saying no co-write. We're saying, the product needs to be more Liam. Feels like it's just 1%. at best.

There shouldn't be just those but many others. Columbia for example was written by Liam and Chris Griffiths borrowing part of a melody from a House music. They inserted the guitars and wrote 2 stanzas each ... Noel is the only "author". They have not included neither Liam, nor Griffiths, nor the author of the original part. But only Noel who has almost nothing to do with the song. An ignorant user would believe that that song was written by Noel, but there are more than 3 people on it. And there are tons of similar stories. So we should stop complaining about Liam's co-writers once and for all.

I haven’t listened to the Podcast, is it worth listening to or is it just Wyatt bumping his gums? I’m surprised to hear that he said he’s written all the songs on the album as I’m sure there were some from a different writer recorded in early spring 2020, the same sessions as All You’re Dreaming Of.
I didn’t think they’d decided on the final cut yet.

Yeah but aside all the weird assumptions you didn't get my point
I'm not complaining because he's co writing, I'm complaining because he's not really co-writing

95% of it is AW and the other dude talking shite about random stuff. Its not really a structured piece, more a stream of consciousness late night chat. All the liam stuff is at the start when he is asked what he is up to at moment. He doesn't say most of the stuff that's been mentioned on here, that's just people reading between the lines and hearing what they want to hear. All he basically says is that Liam has limited influences and he has tried to push him into more modern territory, and most of his work has been in editing the album to bring the two together into a coherent whole and he is pleased with the final results as it is nearly finished. Says they have aimed to create something that is a bit different but also sits comfortably next to oasis songs.