Anyone who rates a song like this from 0 to 6 is not an Oasis fan. In this song there are all the elements that made us fall in love with Oasis. Even Noel would know in his heart that it's a Top song.

Has this leaked then?

Oasis and Stone Roses used to shit on people like Tina Turner, Phil Collins... old farts that occupied all charts and tv shows doing the same shit for decades.

Being fan of Oasis for me doesn't mean to be fan of the Beatles nostalgia kind of music.

Oasis was an exciting band with great vibes, great energy and with also much better songwriting and more inspired songwriting and much better vocals.

Imagine living in the 90s and hearing band from the 60s doing exactly the same thing that they were doing in the 60s but just worse. But with completely same style, production...

I would say that people who just love everything that Gallaghers do are not real fans of what Oasis really was.

They are fans of that stereotypical view of Oasis - that they were Beatles tribute band that only knows 3 chords.

Also, we should redefine what it means to be a good guitarist. Playing the same shit for 4 decades doesn't make you good and it doesn't mean that you still got it, it just mean that you stucked, and if you're stuck, then you're not good.

I agree with all that

With that said, I don't anticipate any Gallagher release these days with any great expectations of anything expect fairly middle the road stuff that's really not much better than mediocre. That's simply because that's how it's been for years now.

I find Noel's solo career to be lacking in all departments. His last album is no better than your average local singer songwriter who puts an album on Spotify, only with a bigger production budget but its still boring as fuck. He's truly become a middle aged man that's pretty much lost the gift. But he is middle aged so maybe it just accepted that's where he's at now.

As for Liam, his solo career sounds like a guy singing songs that barely suit him just because he has to release albums to maintain a career. I'm not even convinced he thinks his solo albums are any good.

As for this Liam and Squire thing, I'm OK with it. It is what it sounds like, geezers age 61 and 51 trying to recapture sounds from their heyday. Its not like Squire has really been that cutting edge, by the time the Roses were on a second album, he had become a Jimmy Page wannabe, so I don't think there was ever that much going on in his brain about being progressive musically. And Liam just seems happy singing songs that are kind of a bit like the music he likes.

But I think when you look at it for what it is, then I don't mind the new song, it's an inoffensive little tune and it doesn't sound like they're going through the motions, it sounds like it's something they're enjoying.

If I'm looking for progressive musicians, then I won't be looking for it in two guys weren't even progressive 30 years ago. That's why I'm not really going to judge their music with that mindset or expectation.

I mean what he is doing with Liam sounds like what he was doing with Stone Roses.

I agree.

It also all good and I don't mind it really.

It is music, I like Supersonic and feel I it from it start. It doesn't make much sense really, you hear most basic drums and you are loving it and feeling already.

Some people hear something in Mars to Liverpool, I don't. It doesn't do anything for me. If you ask me why is that, the answer is in probably in my last post.

But I don't think that people who like it are idiots and stupid for falling in love with this kind of things.

They just feel something that I don't.

I am totally fine with them thinking that this song is great but it is stupid to say that you are not an Oasis fan if you think that this song 6/10 and that is the reason why I wrote that post.

Well Liam has done that before and The Stone Roses we’re pretty good and only released two albums. I’d also argue those two albums aren’t that similar.

You can’t describe someone as stuck if they’re exactly where they want to be.

In fact Liam cannot and must not sound like something from today. It must rather sound like himself. It is today's young musicians who have to talk about the contemporary era. Today there is reggaeton, commercial pop (the one for make-up shops) and Trap music (a phenomenon that has dominated the Italian charts for many years) which tells us what we are today. Liam doesn't have to tell anything about today. That's not what he's supposed to do.

Dude I disagree. Finally on a Gallagher album the vocals sound great at the same time as the guitars finally sound like they should. From the latter days of Oasis to both Gallagher brothers' solo albums the sound was so compressed that the song sounded like it had been recorded from inside a plastic tube. Finally with this new project the sounds of the instruments and the voice sound so free and open that I would go to church to thank Jesus for it. As for the song Diamond in The Dark, I love it, it's a great classic pop-rock song, but I don't want the whole album to have to sound like it. Liam comes from Oasis and I loved those sounds otherwise I would never have become a fan (I don't give a damn about the Beatles or Stone Roses and their influences on Oasis) and Liam grew up and grew old with Oasis in his soul and it's always a pleasure hearing him sing songs that reflect him, regardless of the fashions of the era in which we live. Whether it's classic rock or 90's rock doesn't matter to me. The important thing is that Liam sounds compatible with himself and that the mix of sounds is done in an excellent way.

This is what I think. But I accept that you may think differently.

Yes, it is actually what Sgt.Pepper was in 1967.

Everyone outside this forum are crazy about it, rave reviews everywhere, whole world is talking about inspired songwriting, revolutionary production and guitar technique that was never heard before.