|
|
Post by GlastoEls on Nov 25, 2017 10:46:26 GMT -5
I think the most worrying this is the amount of people saying Morning Glory is better than Definitely Maybe! Champagne Supernova, Don’t Look Back In Anger, Some Might Say, Wonderwall, Cast No Shadow and Morning Glory politely disagree with you! |
|
|
|
Post by His Royal Noelness on Nov 25, 2017 10:51:49 GMT -5
I think the most worrying this is the amount of people saying Morning Glory is better than Definitely Maybe! Champagne Supernova, Don’t Look Back In Anger, Some Might Say, Wonderwall, Cast No Shadow and Morning Glory politely disagree with you! Rock and Roll Star, Supersonic, Cigarettes & Alcohol, Live Forever, Slide Away, and Married with Children politely disagree with you! |
|
|
|
Post by spinettaforever on Nov 25, 2017 10:58:05 GMT -5
I think it would be a "DOYS" because of its groovy nature.
|
|
|
|
Post by garys on Nov 25, 2017 12:12:42 GMT -5
1. DM
2. WTSMG
3. BHN
4. DBTT
5. DOYS
6. WBTM
7. HC
8. SOTSOG
|
|
|
|
Post by freddy838 on Nov 25, 2017 12:19:48 GMT -5
Let's say I treat WBTM like a DOYS sister The 2nd half of WBTM and the first half of DOYS together would have been amazing. Bag it up The Turning Waiting For The Rapture The Shock Of The Lightning I'm Outta Time Falling Down She Taught Me How To Fly Black & White Sunshine If Love Is The Law The Man Who Built The Moon Nailed it. It's difficult to rank all the post 90s albums because they're often half good, half bad and I'd lump this album in with them. I prefer Chasing Yesterday and rate it similar to As You Were. |
|
|
|
Post by jeffrey on Nov 25, 2017 12:36:01 GMT -5
Wow, always amazes me how people can have such different opinions on these sort of things. Love how music is so subjective. (Not having a go at you whatsoever, genuinely chuffed for the people who love this album). The only Oasis album I'd say it's better than is HC, the rest I'd take over this. Probably on a level with DOYS, some great songs on both, some stinkers on both. Do you honestly think there's tracks on here on the level of Ain't Got Nothin' and The Nature of Reality? Who Built the Moon pisses all over DOYS for me, and that's the best of the last three Oasis albums. I know you weren’t talking to me, but I think ILITL is in my top 5 most disliked Oasis-related songs. And I think it, HM, and B&WS are far worse than anything on DOYS. Actually only think 4 of the 8 are good (with one being fucking incredible). Although the songs are poorer in my opinion, it does work well as one cohesive piece. In reference to the topic, I think all Oasis albums are superior, but HC and DBTT by just a touch. |
|
|
|
Post by headshrinker84 on Nov 25, 2017 12:56:03 GMT -5
Do you honestly think there's tracks on here on the level of Ain't Got Nothin' and The Nature of Reality? Who Built the Moon pisses all over DOYS for me, and that's the best of the last three Oasis albums. I know you weren’t talking to me, but I think ILITL is in my top 5 most disliked Oasis-related songs. And I think it, HM, and B&WS are far worse than anything on DOYS. Actually only think 4 of the 8 are good (with one being fucking incredible). Although the songs are poorer in my opinion, it does work well as one cohesive piece. In reference to the topic, I think all Oasis albums are superior, but HC and DBTT by just a touch. B&WS is better than NOR and AGN. |
|
|
|
Post by SheSaidHerNameWasDot on Nov 25, 2017 13:02:12 GMT -5
1. What’s the Story (Morning Glory)
2. Definitely Maybe
3. The Masterplan
4. Be Here Now
5. As You Were
6. Don't Believe The Truth
7. Heathen Chemistry
8. Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
9. Chasing Yesterday
10. NGHFB
11. Who Built The Moon
12. DGGS
13. BE
14. Dig Out Your Soul
|
|
|
|
Post by jeffrey on Nov 25, 2017 13:03:15 GMT -5
I know you weren’t talking to me, but I think ILITL is in my top 5 most disliked Oasis-related songs. And I think it, HM, and B&WS are far worse than anything on DOYS. Actually only think 4 of the 8 are good (with one being fucking incredible). Although the songs are poorer in my opinion, it does work well as one cohesive piece. In reference to the topic, I think all Oasis albums are superior, but HC and DBTT by just a touch. B&WS is better than NOR and AGN. In your opinion. Not mine. |
|
|
|
Post by The Escapist on Nov 25, 2017 13:06:51 GMT -5
Do you honestly think there's tracks on here on the level of Ain't Got Nothin' and The Nature of Reality? Who Built the Moon pisses all over DOYS for me, and that's the best of the last three Oasis albums. I know you weren’t talking to me, but I think ILITL is in my top 5 most disliked Oasis-related songs. And I think it, HM, and B&WS are far worse than anything on DOYS. Actually only think 4 of the 8 are good (with one being fucking incredible). Although the songs are poorer in my opinion, it does work well as one cohesive piece. In reference to the topic, I think all Oasis albums are superior, but HC and DBTT by just a touch. Fair enough, but personally I'd rather listen to Holy Mountain than anything on DOYS bar Falling Down. I really like If Love is the Law, too, but B+WS is a song I won't be putting on much outside the album context. I've got an hour to spare before catching up with Detectorists, so I'll add my ratings to the list: 1. (What's the Story) Morning Glory? = 10 2. Definitely Maybe = 10 3. Be Here Now = 9 4. Who Built the Moon? = 8.5 5. Standing on the Shoulders of Giants = 7.5 6. NGHFB / Chasing Yesterday = 7 7. As You Were = 6.5 8. Dig Out Your Soul = 6 9. Don't Believe the Truth = 5 10. Heathen Chemistry = 4 11. BE = 3.5 12. Different Gear, Still Speeding = 3 |
|
|
|
Post by KhanMightSay on Nov 25, 2017 13:12:35 GMT -5
Longevity is always the deciding factor with these things but I never felt with NGHFB or Chasing Yesterday that I would listen to the whole album for very long. Certain tracks yes, but as an album, no. With WBTM I can see myself still listening to the whole record from start to finish many, MANY times.
On par with SOTSOG for me (my 4th favourite Oasis album), maybe slightly better as things stand. But that's probably present time/novelty bias.
|
|
|
|
Post by jeffrey on Nov 25, 2017 13:19:31 GMT -5
I know you weren’t talking to me, but I think ILITL is in my top 5 most disliked Oasis-related songs. And I think it, HM, and B&WS are far worse than anything on DOYS. Actually only think 4 of the 8 are good (with one being fucking incredible). Although the songs are poorer in my opinion, it does work well as one cohesive piece. In reference to the topic, I think all Oasis albums are superior, but HC and DBTT by just a touch. Fair enough, but personally I'd rather listen to Holy Mountain than anything on DOYS bar Falling Down. I really like If Love is the Law, too, but B+WS is a song I won't be putting on much outside the album context. I've got an hour to spare before catching up with Detectorists, so I'll add my ratings to the list: 1. (What's the Story) Morning Glory? = 10 2. Definitely Maybe = 10 3. Be Here Now = 9 4. Who Built the Moon? = 8.5 5. Standing on the Shoulders of Giants = 7.5 6. NGHFB / Chasing Yesterday = 7 7. As You Were = 6.5 8. Dig Out Your Soul = 6 9. Don't Believe the Truth = 5 10. Heathen Chemistry = 4 11. BE = 3.5 12. Different Gear, Still Speeding = 3 Mine: DM = 10 MG = 10 BHN = 8.5 TM = 8.5 SOTSOG = 8 HC = 6.5 DBTT = 6.5 DOYS = 7 NGHFB = 6.5 CY = 7 WBTM = 6.5 DGSS = 6 BE = 6.5 (LOVE it musically, but Liam’s vox are horrific) AYW = 7 |
|
|
|
Post by World71R on Nov 25, 2017 14:19:55 GMT -5
1) (What's the Story) Morning Glory? 2) Be Here Now 3) Definitely Maybe 4) Who Built the Moon?5) Standing on the Shoulders of Giants 6) Chasing Yesterday / NGHFB 7) As You Were 8) Dig Out Your Soul 9) Don't Believe the Truth 10) Heathen Chemistry 11) BE 12) Different Gear, Still Speeding Agreed, but I would put SOTSOG around As You Were and then BHN below DM and close to WBTM. Morning Glory/Definitely Maybe/(The Masterplan)/Be Here Now/WBTM/Chasing Yesterday & NGHFB/SOTSOG/As You Were/DBTT & DOYS/Heathen Chemistry/BE/DGSS Otherwise, it looks good. |
|
|
|
Post by Spaceman on Nov 25, 2017 17:47:02 GMT -5
WBTM might climb a step in time but for now
DM
MG
TM
BHN
DOYS
SOTSOG
AYW/WBTM
BE
HC
DGSS
DBTT/NGHFB/CY
tbh
|
|
|
|
Post by ricardogce on Nov 25, 2017 18:17:41 GMT -5
Same spot I place AYW: Behind the holy trinity, SOTSOG, and HC, but ahead of DBTT and DOYS. The lows in HC are lower than the lows in WBTM, but the highs are much higher, so it just about outpaces WBTM.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mean Mrs. Mustard on Nov 25, 2017 19:15:59 GMT -5
1) (What's the Story) Morning Glory? 2) Be Here Now 3) Definitely Maybe 4) Who Built the Moon?5) Standing on the Shoulders of Giants 6) Chasing Yesterday / NGHFB 7) As You Were 8) Dig Out Your Soul 9) Don't Believe the Truth 10) Heathen Chemistry 11) BE 12) Different Gear, Still Speeding Switch Definitely Maybe with Be Here Now and Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants with Dig Out Your Soul and that's how I'd rank it. |
|
|
|
Post by charlie on Nov 25, 2017 19:22:55 GMT -5
1) (What's The Story) Morning Glory?
2) Definitely Maybe
3) The Masterplan
4) Be Here Now
5) Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
6) Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants
7) Heathen Chemistry
8) Don't Believe The Truth
8) Who Built The Moon?
10) Dig Out Your Soul
Chasing Yesterday
As You Were
Beady Eye's albums (?)
|
|
|
|
Post by Manualex on Nov 25, 2017 19:27:46 GMT -5
The album Dig Out Your Soul should have been. Throw in a couple of the great tracks from that album onto Noel, beef up the dull Sardy splurge with Holmes and you’ve got a third Oasis classic. That said, the worst songs on Moon are way way better than the dad rock shite offered by Andy and Gem on that album (along with Liam’s Ain’t Got Muffins). Merely decent is the worst it gets for Noel on this album, while the worst off Dig Out Your Soul are truly horrendous. Other than Beautiful World and Falling Down, I don't get any similarites between the two. DOYS is a harsh rock album with apocalyptic themes, WBTM is a joyous party album that makes you dance. This album to me is entirely and totally separate to Oasis, can't imagine any of the tunes being anywhere near that band. Be Careful What You wish for could've been done by Noel. But besides that I agree with you. |
|
|
|
Post by Manualex on Nov 25, 2017 19:36:32 GMT -5
The first four are unskippable for me, who built the Moon could be in there or in the tier below that has great tracks and one or two that I don't like. HC/BE have some good songs but most of them arent my cup of tea, and DGSS is by far the worst Gallagher related álbum by either brother
Morning Glory
Definitely Maybe
High Flying Birds
Be Here Now
Who Built The Moon?
As You Were
Chasing Yesterday
Dig Out Your Soul
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
Don't Believe The Truth
Heathen Chemestry
BE
Different Gear, Still Speeding
|
|
|
|
Post by birthdaycakes7 on Nov 25, 2017 20:31:33 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe
Whats the Story Morning Glory
High Flying Birds
Dig Out Your Soul
Be Here Now
Don't Believe the Truth
Who Built the Moon
As You Were
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants
Chasing Yesterday
BE
Different Gear Still Speeding
Heathen Chemistry
|
|
|
|
Post by pliolite on Nov 25, 2017 21:08:03 GMT -5
1) (What's the Story) Morning Glory? 2) Be Here Now 3) Definitely Maybe 4) Who Built the Moon?5) Standing on the Shoulders of Giants 6) Chasing Yesterday / NGHFB 7) As You Were 8) Dig Out Your Soul 9) Don't Believe the Truth 10) Heathen Chemistry 11) BE 12) Different Gear, Still Speeding With the greatest respect, you've lost your entire mind....!!! If only for the Chasing Yesterday positioning.  |
|
|
|
Post by dominik1291 on Nov 26, 2017 15:39:48 GMT -5
It's too difficult to rank it, but I think it works like this for me:
(What's the Story) Morning Glory?
Definitely Maybe
Be Here Now
Dig Out Your Soul
As You Were
Chasing Yesterday
Who Built the Moon?
Don't Believe the Truth
BE
Standing on the Shoulders of Giants
Different Gear, Still Speeding
NGHFB
Heathen Chemistry
|
|
|
|
Post by monkian on Nov 28, 2017 4:47:17 GMT -5
- Definitely Maybe (every song is massive and even the "bad" tunes - Shakermaker and Digsy's Dinner - are still classics) - 9.5
- (What's the Story) Morning Glory (undeniably a classic but Wonderwall and Roll With it annoy me now) - 9
- Be Here Now (like DM, every tune is massive but could it do with fewer guitar solos and repeated choruses) - 8.5
- Who Built The Moon (a complete record from start to finish and a great atmosphere but three instrumentals is too many on an 11 track album from a singer-songwriter) - 8
- Chasing Yesterday (Best variety in a Noel solo record but a couple of average tunes) - 7.7
- Dig Out Your Soul (the best five song run on an Oasis album since Definitely Maybe for me. Poor finish courtesy of LAG though) - 7.5
- As You Were (solid all the way through but no real stand outs for me and fairly Liam-by-numbers. Fresh production and the return of Liam's vocals are the best bits of this) - 7
- Don't Believe the Truth (a few high points but mostly average with some really bad vocals from Liam - it hurts listening to this one on headphones) - 6.5
- Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds (good melodies but let down by samey song structures, bad instrumentation - drums in particular - and poor production) - 6
- Standing on the Shoulder of Giants (only ten tracks long with one instrumental and 3-4 of Oasis's worst ever songs. Gas Panic, Roll it Over and Where Did it All Go Wrong save this from being the worst Oasis album in my opinion) - 5
- BE (cracking production and vibe let down by poor track listing choice and banal lyrics) - 4.5
- Heathen Chemistry (cliched Dad rock - the sound of a band trying to please people and recreate their most formulaic and popular material) - 4
- Different Gear Still Speeding (Grandad rock - the sound of a band trying to recreate Heathen Chemistry without that album's chief songwriter) - 3
|
|
|
|
Post by seanrulesrh on Nov 28, 2017 4:52:31 GMT -5
Is this a rank thread? To be honest,to me it feels like a solo Noel's DOYS in terms of innovation and exploring sounds. But the feeling of the album actually is similar to Definitely Maybe. Don't get me wrong. Is not like the youth and wild days feeling that DM got,but in the spirit somehow I can see it. Joy,happiness and up-tempo songs. So its a Definitely Maybe with Dig Out Your Soul
|
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Nov 28, 2017 4:53:25 GMT -5
Ok here is mine after a week of intense listening
Those 3 are classics, and had a huge impact on my life, can't be touched.
What's the Story) Morning Glory?
Definitely Maybe
Be Here Now
Then all = strong records, with a very distinctive sound.
Who Built the Moon?
Standing on the Shoulders of Giants
NGHFB
Then all = i dig those records even though they are flawed. Especially because they have really good singles
Dig Out Your Soul
Don't Believe the Truth
Heathen Chemistry (yes i like this record thank you)
Then all = not that I dont care, but i can live without those records, but that does not mean i dont like them
As You Were
Chasing Yesterday (worst Noel-related record)
BE
Different Gear, Still Speeding
|
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5