It'd be nice if you engaged with my actual argument, which has some nuance, instead of pulling out of context. I think Oasis was an unbelievable live band IF YOU WERE THERE. The feeling of community, Liam's awesome stage presence, hearing those great songs one after another at top volume--the whole package was transcendant.

But sitting at home it's a lot easier to hear the real drawbacks of Oasis live--the awful pacing of some of the songs, the lack of musicianship, the poor mixes, the (at times) substandard vocals--all of the things that don't matter when you're screaming along to your favorite songs with 20 or 40,000 people. With a few exceptions--most of them acoustic, the studio versions of all of these songs are far superior.