Absolutely, no question about it. At least for the past 10 years he's consistently been a great singer, both in the studio and live. I've always found the tone of his voice very pleasant, even in the early days when he sometimes struggled to hit the correct notes.

If we are to compare the two singers, I think the best thing about Noel is he can be quite dynamic and subtle, unlike Liam who always sings as if his life depended on it. That benefitted all the great, rocking songs, but I think it didn't fit some of the ballads. As a matter of fact, there are a few classic tracks I wish Noel would have sung (Cast No Shadow and Rockin' Chair come to mind). And I realize this is not a popular opinion.

Noel deserves a lot of credit for improving as a singer over the last 15 years, its certainly come a long way. I didn't vote for either though, I by no means dislike Noel's voice but I also find little distinctive about it or engaging enough over a full album.

This will turn into another shitty "Noel vs Liam" thread very soon.

I like it a lot more than I used to. His studio vocals have been on a constant upwards curve and I've grown to appreciate it more and more as the years have gone by. He's been good enough to be a lead vocalist since about 2002 imo.

Yes.

Absolutely love his voice on The Dying of The Light demo.

Although he's admitted himself that he's not the greatest singer, I personally love his voice. Some of the TCT acoustic performances are some of his very best

I've never liked it. Had Liam not been in the band I don't think I would have ever become a fan of Oasis. I've always thought he sounds like an un-knotted balloon on high notes. Don't agree that he's improved either, his best vocal performances for me were Morning Glory at Earls Court in '95 and Morning Glory on MTV Unplugged.

Considering they had one of the best singers in the world in their locker, it's scandalous that Noel sang on any tracks between 1994 and 2002.

Do I like Noel's singing voice?

Erm.... Of course, we are Oasis fans are we not?

What a shoker, thedone hates something...


General question to the many haters in the forum:
People who only moan and complain about Liam's voice, Beady Eye songs, Noel's voice, Noel's lack of frontmanship, or whatever, do you really have so little in your life that you spend it here trolling?

Go troll some Nicki Minaj forum or One Direction videos on youtube
Fucking pain in the ass!

spud= thedon
check his recent posts. Hate this, hate that, I'm not a troll, etc

also, you're the one to talk, bringing up Liam's voice in almost every thread

Where did I criticise Liam's voice in this thread? I merely stated that Noel's voice has improved whilst Liam's has deteriorated over the same period.

The fact that Liam's voice has got worse isn't a criticism. More a statement of fact that he himself wouldn't argue against.