|
|
Post by gdforever on Nov 23, 2011 16:11:20 GMT -5
WTSMG
DM
TM
HFB
SOTSOG
BHN
DOYS
DBTT
DGSS
HC
|
|
|
|
Post by alwaysnow on Nov 23, 2011 16:18:09 GMT -5
So hard. As of today:
1. (What's The Story) Morning Glory?
2. Definitely Maybe
3. Dig Out Your Soul
4. Don't Believe The Truth
5. Be Here Now
6. Different Gear, Still Speeding
7. Standing On The Shoulder of Giants
8. The Masterplan
9. Heathen Chemistry
10. Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
Don't get me wrong, I love them all. That's what's unfair about ranking them.
|
|
|
|
Post by Just Call Me The Roller on Nov 23, 2011 16:31:53 GMT -5
1- WTSMG
2- DM
3- DBTT
(TM)
4- DOYS
5- DGSS
6- NGHFB
7- SOTSOG
8- BHN
9- HC
DGSS is so underrated, the preconceptions are just absurd. DBTT is also very underrated, IMO.
|
|
|
|
Post by shakermaicher on Nov 23, 2011 16:45:19 GMT -5
Def maybe
Whats the story
High flying birds
Master plan
Be here now
Dig out your soul
Don't believe the truth
Heathon chemistry
Diff gear still speeding/Standing on the shoulders
|
|
|
|
Post by oasismuse on Nov 23, 2011 17:16:38 GMT -5
1 Definitely Maybe
2 The Masterplan
3 (What's The Story) Morning Glory?
4 Be Here Now
5 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants
6 Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
7 Don't Believe The Truth
8 Heathen Chemistry
9 Dig Out Your Soul
10 Different Gear, Still Speeding
|
|
|
|
Post by songbirdsally on Nov 23, 2011 17:34:46 GMT -5
DGSS is so underrated, the preconceptions are just absurd. This! I can understand that some people prefer Noel and therefore prefer the NGHFB album, but to say DGSS is the worst album out of the lot is just ridiculous! Even critics claimed it was the best thing Liam was involved in since Morning Glory! |
|
|
|
Post by headshrinker84 on Nov 23, 2011 17:47:15 GMT -5
1 Definitely Maybe
2 The Masterplan
3 (What's The Story) Morning Glory?
4 Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
5 Dig Out Your Soul
6 Be Here now
7 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants
8 Don't Believe The Truth
9 Different Gear, Still Speeding
10 Heathen Chemistry
|
|
|
|
Post by liamgallagher1992 on Nov 23, 2011 18:34:48 GMT -5
1. WTSMG
2. DM
3. BHN
4. DGSS
5. NGHFB
6. DBTT
7. HC
8. DOYS
9. SOTSOG
|
|
|
|
Post by Headmaster on Nov 23, 2011 20:53:50 GMT -5
01. MG - 10/10
02. DM - 10/10
03. TM - 9,5/10
04. NGHFB - 9/10
05. DOYS - 8,5/10
06. DBTT - 8/10
07. BHN - 8/10
08. SOTSOG - 7,5/10
09. DGSS - 7/10
10. HC - 6/10
|
|
|
|
Post by liamandnoel on Nov 23, 2011 21:05:42 GMT -5
1. BHN
2. MG
3. DM
4. TM
5. NGHFB
6. DOYS
7. HC
8. DBTT
9. SOTSOG
10. DGSS
|
|
|
|
Post by Cast on Nov 23, 2011 22:27:52 GMT -5
-Classic-
WTSMG
DM
TM
3 of my all time favorites and I think they will stand the test of time.
-Great album-
NGHFB
If Noel took a couple risks this album could have been up there with the other three but the songwriting is impeccable. His album with the AA has me in high hopes.
-Good Albums-
SOTSOG
DBTT
BHN
DOYS
These four constantly change depending on the what mood I'm in. BHN and SOTSOG are both great mood albums but suffer from either being too long (BHN) or inconsistent (SOTSOG) but in someways (more in BHN's case) the albums imperfection makes the album have a certain charm. DBTT is consistent all the way through but could use a couple left turns. It's like NGHFB's but with less good songs even though is it LAG's strongest batch of tunes. DOYS the first half is up there with the first three albums but then it tails off into good to average to territory.
-Average Albums-
HC
DGSS
I hardly play either of these albums all the way through and they are pretty poor by Oasis standards. I choose HC above DGSS because well the stand out tracks are a bit better than BDI's stand out tracks. DGSS sounds a lot fresher and more inspired but even Noel by number tracks like SCYHO, THT, LBL have their moments and I'd say the only moment on DGSS that comes close is TMS. Beatles And Stones, Kill For A Dream, The Beat Goes On, (Probably) All In The Mind, Better Man, A Quick Peep are all in the category of being pretty shit (all worse than any of "the shit 3" on SOTSOG).
|
|
|
|
Post by spaneli on Nov 23, 2011 22:53:28 GMT -5
This! I can understand that some people prefer Noel and therefore prefer the NGHFB album, but to say DGSS is the worst album out of the lot is just ridiculous! Even critics claimed it was the best thing Liam was involved in since Morning Glory! One person said that. And that is just retarded considering the songs on Be Here Now. Why is it so ridiculous that it's the worst of the lot for me and others? As much as I dislike the second half of DOYS and half of HC, they still have great singles. And being honest, DGSS has plenty of dogs-BAS, SOTEOTN, WUD, FA, 3RC, BTL-as many as the bad Oasis albums, but without the killer singles. LAG have written some nice tunes on DGSS, but none of them make me feel what great Oasis songs made me feel. The difference between a great songwriter (Noel) and good ones (Liam, Andy) is subtle, but immistakeable. Give this man a gold star. I have the exact same problem with DGSS. The lows are just as low as some of the worst stuff on DOYS and highs just aren't high enough for me. For me, it's the least listened to Oasis related album in my collection. I can never seem to get through more than 3 or 4 songs depending on the day. But in the end, this is why it gets touchy when ranking albums. Just because DGSS is at the bottom of the list doesn't necessarily mean anyone thinks it's a bad album. Some may just not think it's as good as the other. It's like ranking The Smiths albums. If I say that Meat is Murder is my least favorite, I'm not saying that it's a bad album. Just that it's my least favorite comparative to the other albums. |
|
|
|
Post by howsoonisnow on Nov 24, 2011 5:15:52 GMT -5
This! I can understand that some people prefer Noel and therefore prefer the NGHFB album, but to say DGSS is the worst album out of the lot is just ridiculous! Even critics claimed it was the best thing Liam was involved in since Morning Glory! One person said that. And that is just retarded considering the songs on Be Here Now. Why is it so ridiculous that it's the worst of the lot for me and others? As much as I dislike the second half of DOYS and half of HC, they still have great singles. And being honest, DGSS has plenty of dogs-BAS, SOTEOTN, WUD, FA, 3RC, BTL-as many as the bad Oasis albums, but without the killer singles. LAG have written some nice tunes on DGSS, but none of them make me feel what great Oasis songs made me feel. The difference between a great songwriter (Noel) and good ones (Liam, Andy) is subtle, but immistakeable. Totally agree. DGSS is ok, I've listened to it a lot when it was released, but it doesn't stand the test of time, Every Oasis album does because they always had some killer tracks. DM, MG and BHN are made of killer tracks and the others 4 have always some to save them. DGSS has just not, it's nice but it's lacks one or two great songs to make it unforgettable. HFB has those killer tracks. |
|
|
|
Post by Just Call Me The Roller on Nov 24, 2011 6:26:10 GMT -5
I understand you, and I get where you're coming from. But for my ears, DGSS just sounds much fresher and makes me feel much happier - even its lows, likes BAS, still please me, and sound great live.
NGHFB, meanwhile, might have a couple of impressive songs - some of the best he's ever written, but the rest of the album just fails to "wow" me (and I'm not the only one, you have experts like Stephen Thomas Erlewine that felt the same. I guess that's why rating music is so hard.
|
|
|
|
Post by superbe on Nov 24, 2011 7:00:44 GMT -5
1. DM
2. MG
3. TM
4. SOTSOG
5. BHN
6. DBTT
7. DOYS
8. HC
9. DGSS
10. NGHFB
|
|
|
|
Post by RocketMan on Nov 24, 2011 7:12:27 GMT -5
But for my ears, DGSS just sounds much fresher no and thats my problem with DGSS. it just doesn't sound fresh at all. it sounds like old songs from an old beatles/stones cover band but with modern equipment. hearing kill for a dream or the beat goes and is kind of embarrassing because of the production. it's nowhere near to a modern rock band. it's not that hard to rip off instant karma and make the roller out of it. i just miss the personality in the songs which made some of noels poor rip offs even better and sounding like it's his own. thats my problem with it and i hope beady eye will find their own direction so the second album could be better |
|
|
|
Post by Just Call Me The Roller on Nov 24, 2011 7:18:18 GMT -5
But for my ears, DGSS just sounds much fresher no and thats my problem with DGSS. it just doesn't sound fresh at all. it sounds like old songs from an old beatles/stones cover band but with modern equipment. hearing kill for a dream or the beat goes and is kind of embarrassing because of the production. it's nowhere near to a modern rock band. it's not that hard to rip off instant karma and make the roller out of it. i just miss the personality in the songs which made some of noels poor rip offs even better and sounding like it's his own. thats my problem with it and i hope beady eye will find their own direction so the second album could be better That's your opinion, not everyone will have the same. |
|
|
|
Post by Sternumman on Nov 24, 2011 7:26:30 GMT -5
WTSMG
DM
MP-it's not an album. its a collection of bsides
BHN
NGHFB
DBTT
SOTSOG
DOYS
HC
DGSS
I cant comprehend how anyone has BHN in their bottom three. Yes it's bloated and never ends but it also might be the best record Noel wrote.
|
|
sbajf
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 69
|
Post by sbajf on Nov 24, 2011 7:29:42 GMT -5
MP is factually still an album, regardless of what you may think in your own head.
|
|
|
|
Post by howsoonisnow on Nov 24, 2011 7:40:35 GMT -5
MP is factually still an album, regardless of what you may think in your own head. No it's not, everysongs were realised before on signles, it's a compilation. |
|
|
|
Post by Sternumman on Nov 24, 2011 7:47:51 GMT -5
MP is factually still an album, regardless of what you may think in your own head. I'd like to see your rankings of the best Beatles albums. Does it go Blue Red White Sgt peppers? |
|
dion
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 362
|
Post by dion on Nov 24, 2011 7:50:42 GMT -5
BHN suffers because it could have been so much more, decent production and holding back the brilliant B-sides from MP could realistically have seen Oasis have 4 9/10+ albums and that is Beatles territory.
I guess thats why I like Oasis, flawed genius is always more interesting.
|
|
|
|
Post by ctmazin on Nov 24, 2011 7:57:30 GMT -5
1. Morning Glory 11/10 (my favourite album of all time)
2. Definitely Maybe 10/10 (probably as good as MG, but does not have the same sentimental value)
3. The Masterplan 9.5/10 (replace The Swamp Song with Step Out and I am The Walrus with Cum On Feel The Noize and this would be #2)
4. High Flying Birds 9/10 (the sort of consistently excellent album we've been waiting for since Be Here Now-3 or 4 stellar tracks and a lot of very good ones with no High Horse Ladies or She Is Loves)
5. Be Here Now 9/10 (bloated, poorly produced, but a mostly killer set of songs-the production/solo in DYKWIM justifies all of the cocaine)
6. Don't Believe The Truth 8.5/10 (Best latter day Oasis album. Noel's songs are all great-too bad there's only 5 of them-and Liam (GGTIA) and Andy (TUTS) each contribute their best Oasis tracks ever. Still, 3-4 duff LAG tracks drag it down a bit)
7. Standing On The Shoulder of Giants 8/10 (I like this album more and more every year. GLIO may be my favourite piece of music that Oasis has released (with some of Noel's stupidest lyrics) and FITB, GP, WDIAGW and RIO all still sound great after 10 plus years. But time will never heal the three completely horrible songs on this album (you know what they are))
8. Heathen Chemistry 7/10 (Little By Little, Stop Crying Your Heart, The Hindu Times, Songbird, and seven other songs that wouldn't have been let within 8 miles of the studio in 1995...to be fair to Gem, I kind of like HIABP)
9. Dig Out Your Soul 7/10 (About the same as HC, in my books, with some terrific tunes and probably 1-2 more worthy tracks. But the bad tracks (HHL, AGN, TNOR, SO) on this album are unlistenable to me, whereas at least I can bear She Is Love and Better Man and A Quick Peep.
10. Different Gear, Still Speeding 6/10 (Not bad, but just does not do it for me. 4LW is Oasis worthy, and would've been a great B-side in 1995, or a great album track in 2002 or 2005. The Morning Son is lovely and almost as good as GGTIA. Wigwam is a interesting detour that Liam should be proud of. The rest is a mix of out and out bowsers (BAS, SOTEOTN, FA, WUD, 3RC) and Andy Bell songs that seem good when you first hear them, but seem to get worse with every listen (KFAD, TBGO, Millionaire).
|
|
doco
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 89
|
Post by doco on Dec 4, 2011 9:26:31 GMT -5
MP is factually still an album, regardless of what you may think in your own head. I'd like to see your rankings of the best Beatles albums. Does it go Blue Red White Sgt peppers? The White album wasn't a compilation!!! For me its: 1) DM 2) WTSMG 3) BHN 4) NGHFB 5) DOYS 6) DBTT 7) SOTSOG 8) HC 9) DGSS |
|
|
|
Post by BlueJay on Dec 4, 2011 10:01:53 GMT -5
1. Definitely Maybe
2. The Masterplan
3. (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
4. Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds
5. Don't Believe the Truth
6. Be Here Now
7. Dig Out Your Soul
8. Standing On the Shoulders of Giants
9. Heathen Chemistry
10. Different Gear, Still Speeding
|
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5