Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 13, 2014 9:31:54 GMT -5
I just don't get why thread was resurrected ?? From 3 years ago , to take a shot at gd ? It's Ol good bring up whatever you like from past ....but didn't get that one unless I missed something ....oh well Me and gd disagree and all. But she's a fan. Usually when a thread is brought back. You comment , not just bring it up with. No contribution ya know ?? Not knocking person who did it ,.there entitled. But strange. At least say something don't just bring up and leave it at that After 3 years. seems like a lot of digging. For what ? A shot ?
|
|
|
Post by eva on Mar 13, 2014 9:47:25 GMT -5
I just don't get why thread was resurrected ?? From 3 years ago , to take a shot at gd ? It's Ol good bring up whatever you like from past ....but didn't get that one unless I missed something ....oh well Me and gd disagree and all. But she's a fan. Usually when a thread is brought back. You comment , not just bring it up with. No contribution ya know ?? Not knocking person who did it ,.there entitled. But strange. At least say something don't just bring up and leave it at that some people like to drag their fights from other places and bring them here. And then they complain how this place is shit and always filled with fights. Go figure. There was no point in bringing back a post from OVER 3 YEARS AGO to just quote it. Childish
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 13, 2014 9:50:32 GMT -5
I just don't get why thread was resurrected ?? From 3 years ago , to take a shot at gd ? It's Ol good bring up whatever you like from past ....but didn't get that one unless I missed something ....oh well Me and gd disagree and all. But she's a fan. Usually when a thread is brought back. You comment , not just bring it up with. No contribution ya know ?? Not knocking person who did it ,.there entitled. But strange. At least say something don't just bring up and leave it at that some people like to drag their fights from other places and bring them here. And then they complain how this place is shit and always filled with fights. Go figure. There was no point in bringing back a post from OVER 3 YEARS AGO to just quote it. Childish Yep. Lord knows I fought them all ..... But never went back to point out something. That's not even a issue now ya know ? And when Corky Ianucci brings up posts there funny , and when I brought up a post recently it grew legs because it was relevant and I commented on why I was bringing it up ....this though ...pointless totally agree eva , and I'd say it whoever brought it up and just left it there like ave at it ya know ?
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Mar 13, 2014 9:52:38 GMT -5
I just don't get why thread was resurrected ?? From 3 years ago , to take a shot at gd ? It's Ol good bring up whatever you like from past ....but didn't get that one unless I missed something ....oh well Me and gd disagree and all. But she's a fan. Usually when a thread is brought back. You comment , not just bring it up with. No contribution ya know ?? Not knocking person who did it ,.there entitled. But strange. At least say something don't just bring up and leave it at that some people like to drag their fights from other places and bring them here. And then they complain how this place is shit and always filled with fights. Go figure. There was no point in bringing back a post from OVER 3 YEARS AGO to just quote it. Childish Well said, kalas and well said, eva. I completely agree with you both.
|
|
|
Post by theyknowwhatimean on Mar 13, 2014 10:07:22 GMT -5
I just don't get why thread was resurrected ?? From 3 years ago , to take a shot at gd ? It's Ol good bring up whatever you like from past ....but didn't get that one unless I missed something ....oh well Me and gd disagree and all. But she's a fan. Usually when a thread is brought back. You comment , not just bring it up with. No contribution ya know ?? Not knocking person who did it ,.there entitled. But strange. At least say something don't just bring up and leave it at that some people like to drag their fights from other places and bring them here. And then they complain how this place is shit and always filled with fights. Go figure. There was no point in bringing back a post from OVER 3 YEARS AGO to just quote it. Childish That fight didn't "come from other places". Did you not read the read the quote? It was from your very own GDforever. Go figure indeed
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 13, 2014 10:09:50 GMT -5
Go figure , you ressurect it 3 years later ,, and you were not even involved. ........ Good form ? Or axe to grind ... Either way , waste of time to even acknowledge ...later
|
|
|
Post by eva on Mar 13, 2014 10:22:26 GMT -5
some people like to drag their fights from other places and bring them here. And then they complain how this place is shit and always filled with fights. Go figure. There was no point in bringing back a post from OVER 3 YEARS AGO to just quote it. Childish That fight didn't "come from other places". Did you not read the read the quote? It was from your very own GDforever. Go figure indeed the fight I'm refering to is not the one in this thread, it's the one you seem to have against GD. Why else would you quote this after 3 years??
|
|
|
Post by spaneli on Mar 13, 2014 16:59:29 GMT -5
I swore this thread was locked. Pretty amazing it wasn't. This is probably one of the most interesting threads on the forum.
Some people were obviously aggressive (me included), some people were obviously childish in this thread, me (for sure) and BigUn included. This is one of the few threads on the forum that I believe that every truly active member on this forum participated in at the time.
None of us did BigUn any favors...me included. However, nor did BigUn. This thread was a shared disgrace from BigUn treating many fans with contempt, including the fans who backed him up, dangling a demo tape (something he didn't owe fans, but something that he didn't need to mention if he didn't actually have it ), him continually self promoting, to somehow his "daughter" coming on here. He came here as a representative and friend of Tony McCarroll and didn't do much to act like it to the point that even the who supported either childish side saw no point in defending either one. It was shared by members like me being far too aggressive and quickly judgmental. By members like me who were childish and kept the argument going when it should have died long ago (funny that it's happening again).
However, to bring it up three years later. For what reason? And to highlight a post that clearly blasts a member in particular. A member I might add that has clearly not been as active as prior. theyknowwhatimean is usually a very good member who has contributing very well to this forum and I'm pretty sure will continue to do so even with this little episode. However, I do think in a thread that should teach everyone to not prolong fights and be overly judgmental the same should be applied to this very situation. Three years later and it appears we are doomed to repeat, unless grunges are thrown away, grudges held by some who decried this very thread.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 13, 2014 17:32:08 GMT -5
I swore this thread was locked. Pretty amazing it wasn't. This is probably one of the most interesting threads on the forum. Some people were obviously aggressive (me included), some people were obviously childish in this thread, me (for sure) and BigUn included. This is one of the few threads on the forum that I believe that every truly active member on this forum participated in at the time. None of us did BigUn any favors...me included. However, nor did BigUn. This thread was a shared disgrace from BigUn treating many fans with contempt, including the fans who backed him up, dangling a demo tape (something he didn't owe fans, but something that he didn't need to mention if he didn't actually have it ), him continually self promoting, to somehow his "daughter" coming on here. He came here as a representative and friend of Tony McCarroll and didn't do much to act like it to the point that even the who supported either childish side saw no point in defending either one. It was shared by members like me being far too aggressive and quickly judgmental. By members like me who were childish and kept the argument going when it should have died long ago (funny that it's happening again). However, to bring it up three years later. For what reason? And to highlight a post that clearly blasts a member in particular. A member I might add that has clearly not been as active as prior. theyknowwhatimean is usually a very good member who has contributing very well to this forum and I'm pretty sure will continue to do so even with this little episode. However, I do think in a thread that should teach everyone to not prolong fights and be overly judgmental the same should be applied to this very situation. Three years later and it appears we are doomed to repeat, unless grunges are thrown away, grudges held by some who decried this very thread. I agree to a point ..... but when someone brings up a post to just bring it up not contribute anything new ....( and I really don't care i was gd , she pisses me off a lot I just ignore she's cool ) I will call them out ... Nothing against him at all water under bridge is the past so I'm not picking on him but to bring that up HE DESERVED to be called out on it , and I will , the resurrection of it was bad form , and to just bring it up without a post is plain fucking dumb
|
|
|
Post by spaneli on Mar 13, 2014 17:39:50 GMT -5
I swore this thread was locked. Pretty amazing it wasn't. This is probably one of the most interesting threads on the forum. Some people were obviously aggressive (me included), some people were obviously childish in this thread, me (for sure) and BigUn included. This is one of the few threads on the forum that I believe that every truly active member on this forum participated in at the time. None of us did BigUn any favors...me included. However, nor did BigUn. This thread was a shared disgrace from BigUn treating many fans with contempt, including the fans who backed him up, dangling a demo tape (something he didn't owe fans, but something that he didn't need to mention if he didn't actually have it ), him continually self promoting, to somehow his "daughter" coming on here. He came here as a representative and friend of Tony McCarroll and didn't do much to act like it to the point that even the who supported either childish side saw no point in defending either one. It was shared by members like me being far too aggressive and quickly judgmental. By members like me who were childish and kept the argument going when it should have died long ago (funny that it's happening again). However, to bring it up three years later. For what reason? And to highlight a post that clearly blasts a member in particular. A member I might add that has clearly not been as active as prior. theyknowwhatimean is usually a very good member who has contributing very well to this forum and I'm pretty sure will continue to do so even with this little episode. However, I do think in a thread that should teach everyone to not prolong fights and be overly judgmental the same should be applied to this very situation. Three years later and it appears we are doomed to repeat, unless grunges are thrown away, grudges held by some who decried this very thread. I agree to a point ..... but when someone brings up a post to just bring it up not contribute anything new ....( and I really don't care i was gd , she pisses me off a lot I just ignore she's cool ) I will call them out ... Nothing against him at all water under bridge is the past so I'm not picking on him but to bring that up HE DESERVED to be called out on it , and I will , the resurrection of it was bad form , and to just bring it up without a post is playing fucking dumb I am in no way condoning what theyknowwhatimean did. I just pointed out that he has typically been a good member. Though in this situation, grudges (by him......and by me for that matter) should be done away with.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 13, 2014 17:42:55 GMT -5
I agree to a point ..... but when someone brings up a post to just bring it up not contribute anything new ....( and I really don't care i was gd , she pisses me off a lot I just ignore she's cool ) I will call them out ... Nothing against him at all water under bridge is the past so I'm not picking on him but to bring that up HE DESERVED to be called out on it , and I will , the resurrection of it was bad form , and to just bring it up without a post is playing fucking dumb I am in no way condoning what theyknowwhatimean did. I just pointed out that he has typically been a good member. Though in this situation, grudges (by him......and by me for that matter) should be done away with. Oh yea , I agree no doubt ...... it's the rehashing without contributing that got me .....if he was gonna expound on it , I would have read the thread ya know ?? I just got pissed he's like" oh look at this gd got called out ," and just left there like a turd ....,not cool .....and I'm not the biggest gd lover or hater mind you
|
|
|
Post by Rain on Mar 13, 2014 20:44:46 GMT -5
I swore this thread was locked. Pretty amazing it wasn't. This is probably one of the most interesting threads on the forum. Some people were obviously aggressive (me included), some people were obviously childish in this thread, me (for sure) and BigUn included. This is one of the few threads on the forum that I believe that every truly active member on this forum participated in at the time. None of us did BigUn any favors...me included. However, nor did BigUn. This thread was a shared disgrace from BigUn treating many fans with contempt, including the fans who backed him up, dangling a demo tape (something he didn't owe fans, but something that he didn't need to mention if he didn't actually have it ), him continually self promoting, to somehow his "daughter" coming on here. He came here as a representative and friend of Tony McCarroll and didn't do much to act like it to the point that even the who supported either childish side saw no point in defending either one. It was shared by members like me being far too aggressive and quickly judgmental. By members like me who were childish and kept the argument going when it should have died long ago (funny that it's happening again). However, to bring it up three years later. For what reason? And to highlight a post that clearly blasts a member in particular. A member I might add that has clearly not been as active as prior. theyknowwhatimean is usually a very good member who has contributing very well to this forum and I'm pretty sure will continue to do so even with this little episode. However, I do think in a thread that should teach everyone to not prolong fights and be overly judgmental the same should be applied to this very situation. Three years later and it appears we are doomed to repeat, unless grunges are thrown away, grudges held by some who decried this very thread. Some generalization to your statement. Myself, I wasn't active in 2011 and I know many others weren't either. I noticed most the elder members and mods stayed out of it as well. The group who posted mostly in this thread are the ones at fault. There's no justification for the members who acted poorly. Can't give excuses,but be honest now about it. As for "The Other Forum." Let's be honest It's about Live4ever and Supernova Heights. On terms it's like a divorce and everyone has to agree to disagree, then move on. Supernova Heights has their own thing. Live4ever carries itself like it has for I say since 2004-ish to 2005-ish? Before it was a smaller community forum compare to oasisforum or oa515,which it disappeared in late 2004 or early 2005. Rival or disagreement with members of oasis fan sites not new. In 2002 a member Julianne/cuddleykittie, which was a member of oa515 forum. After she was banned to prove her point she started oasis ultimate.
|
|
|
Post by spaneli on Mar 13, 2014 22:06:33 GMT -5
I swore this thread was locked. Pretty amazing it wasn't. This is probably one of the most interesting threads on the forum. Some people were obviously aggressive (me included), some people were obviously childish in this thread, me (for sure) and BigUn included. This is one of the few threads on the forum that I believe that every truly active member on this forum participated in at the time. None of us did BigUn any favors...me included. However, nor did BigUn. This thread was a shared disgrace from BigUn treating many fans with contempt, including the fans who backed him up, dangling a demo tape (something he didn't owe fans, but something that he didn't need to mention if he didn't actually have it ), him continually self promoting, to somehow his "daughter" coming on here. He came here as a representative and friend of Tony McCarroll and didn't do much to act like it to the point that even the who supported either childish side saw no point in defending either one. It was shared by members like me being far too aggressive and quickly judgmental. By members like me who were childish and kept the argument going when it should have died long ago (funny that it's happening again). However, to bring it up three years later. For what reason? And to highlight a post that clearly blasts a member in particular. A member I might add that has clearly not been as active as prior. theyknowwhatimean is usually a very good member who has contributing very well to this forum and I'm pretty sure will continue to do so even with this little episode. However, I do think in a thread that should teach everyone to not prolong fights and be overly judgmental the same should be applied to this very situation. Three years later and it appears we are doomed to repeat, unless grunges are thrown away, grudges held by some who decried this very thread. Some generalization to your statement. Myself, I wasn't active in 2011 and I know many others weren't either. I noticed most the elder members and mods stayed out of it as well. The group who posted mostly in this thread are the ones at fault. There's no justification for the members who acted poorly. Can't give excuses,but be honest now about it. As for "The Other Forum." Let's be honest It's about Live4ever and Supernova Heights. On terms it's like a divorce and everyone has to agree to disagree, then move on. Supernova Heights has their own thing. Live4ever carries itself like it has for I say since 2004-ish to 2005-ish? Before it was a smaller community forum compare to oasisforum or oa515,which it disappeared in late 2004 or early 2005. Rival or disagreement with members of oasis fan sites not new. In 2002 a member Julianne/cuddleykittie, which was a member of oa515 forum. After she was banned to prove her point she started oasis ultimate. Well that's what I meant when I said, "truly active". I meant actively posting. So obviously, any members who weren't actively posting at the time wouldn't be posting in this thread My definition of participated is just the very act of posting in the thread. And I believe just about everyone who was actively posting at the time posted in this thread, including mods (it was impossible not to participate in this thread. It's over 25 pages long). However, saying everyone participation is not an accusation of blame. It's not to say let's spread the blame all around. Merely, an observation. Just because anyone posted in this thread at the time doesn't mean there's an institution of blame. Some only posted once. Obviously I'm not saying they were at fault The mods specifically posted to break up fights. Obviously I'm not saying they were at fault. So I don't see where the generalization is coming from. I was pretty specific in saying I was most definitely in the group who was at fault. In terms of the two forums, I don't pay attention to the split. That's not to say it doesn't exist. It just doesn't enter in the discussion for me. People left for certain reasons which they found and still find valid and I can find no reason to disagree with those reasons. Some are still contributing members on both and good members on both. Which I believe is well welcomed by both forums.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 14, 2014 2:34:05 GMT -5
This thread is a more interesting read than Tony's book, seriously.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 14, 2014 8:12:30 GMT -5
This thread is a more interesting read than Tony's book, seriously. Your actually quite right. ,it shows the forum has had many issues and survived thru the years ......it's a shame to it was brought up in " quote " with nothing to contribute , to show it and make a member look bad who at times is not the most popular here , but she is a great contributor and not a bad person to know actually very intelligent .
|
|
|
Post by His Royal Noelness on Mar 14, 2014 8:27:39 GMT -5
I swore this thread was locked. Pretty amazing it wasn't. This is probably one of the most interesting threads on the forum. Some people were obviously aggressive (me included), some people were obviously childish in this thread, me (for sure) and BigUn included. This is one of the few threads on the forum that I believe that every truly active member on this forum participated in at the time. None of us did BigUn any favors...me included. However, nor did BigUn. This thread was a shared disgrace from BigUn treating many fans with contempt, including the fans who backed him up, dangling a demo tape (something he didn't owe fans, but something that he didn't need to mention if he didn't actually have it ), him continually self promoting, to somehow his "daughter" coming on here. He came here as a representative and friend of Tony McCarroll and didn't do much to act like it to the point that even the who supported either childish side saw no point in defending either one. It was shared by members like me being far too aggressive and quickly judgmental. By members like me who were childish and kept the argument going when it should have died long ago (funny that it's happening again). However, to bring it up three years later. For what reason? And to highlight a post that clearly blasts a member in particular. A member I might add that has clearly not been as active as prior. theyknowwhatimean is usually a very good member who has contributing very well to this forum and I'm pretty sure will continue to do so even with this little episode. However, I do think in a thread that should teach everyone to not prolong fights and be overly judgmental the same should be applied to this very situation. Three years later and it appears we are doomed to repeat, unless grunges are thrown away, grudges held by some who decried this very thread. Yeah, just had a quick read through and I definitely admit that I said some cringe-worthy and overly aggressive stuff and not just here I guess but throughout the forum in general. I guess as Oasis fans a lot of us are hot headed by nature To set the record straight re: Tony and his book. I don't know Tony personally so I don't know and can't comment on him as a person. I've never been a massive fan of his drumming (for me Alan White was the best oasis drummer) but I have to admit that his style was perfect for the DM era. As for the book itself, it is entertaining in many ways and if you're an oasis fan it definitely is worth the read but I doubt its accuracy in places (just as I doubt Noel has been 100% accurate in his retellings down through the years). I guess it is natural to feel defensive when someone challenged a hero of yours and Noel is definitely a hero of mine. In one way I think Tony probably deserved this opportunity to call Noel out as Noel did slag off Tony publicly for years. On a human level I think it's perfectly understandable to do so when Tony hasn't had quite the same platform as Noel down the years. I didn't particularly care for the non-Spartan/Non-gratitude bit at the back but, whatever, it's his book . All this has kind of made me want to re-read it again. Perhaps I could be less pro-Noel this time and try to look at it from a more neutral stance (more easily said than done I guess). tl;dr version: I typed a lot of rubbish on this forum down through the years which I wouldn't necessarily have said in person and regret it now.
|
|
|
Post by shoes222 on Mar 14, 2014 16:56:15 GMT -5
I definitely think this thread is an all-time L4E classic. One of my favorites.
|
|
bigun
Madferrit Fan
Seem to be lots of negativity and untruths flying around this forum. Noel would be proud.
Posts: 52
|
Post by bigun on Mar 16, 2014 8:14:57 GMT -5
Why Always Me?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 16, 2014 8:31:13 GMT -5
Not you mate ...you spoke your mind at the time .more power to you for it Bad form tho and I messaged him to tell him that on the lad who decided to rehash without even a comment ... He just wanted to stir pot sadly he succeded . He must miss eppy .
|
|
|
Post by oasisserbia on Mar 16, 2014 9:51:56 GMT -5
I've never seen more pathetic guy than Bigun. Ha ha what a loser.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 16, 2014 10:04:03 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by His Royal Noelness on Mar 16, 2014 10:27:36 GMT -5
It's already in the playpen Should probably be locked though.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 16, 2014 10:40:39 GMT -5
It's already in the playpen Should probably be locked though. Ah Did not know this well then lock please I mean it's getting absurd .... one moronic reup to slag gdforever ( for know good reason here as of late I may add ) and now it's becoming a moronic joke , the other place prides itself on not having this . So why not practice what you preach in both places ? I left there was not for me I made a error , I have no ill will towards anyone , bruno simply is not my cup of tea nor noeloasis. But I wish them well. , but to come on here bring up a post and then leave it with no comment is just done to stir. Bruno is good at censoring posts he would have deleted it , I'm not for that. But I am for locking its GOIng nowhere .... As was the reason for the reup And gd is a good poster I don't always agree , and have issues with her , but she's cool ......she would never waste her time being so childish I may add
|
|
|
Post by footballdropout on Mar 16, 2014 12:00:39 GMT -5
Thank God it's not locked yet... I still have time to be a part of L4E history!
|
|