Sorry, but no. EPICALLY no. LAMB is so much better than IOT it isn't even funny. It's a whole league and a hop, skip and jump better. Better lyrics, better melody, better structure, even better production.



And IOT doesn't need more??!? It's two verses, two choruses and a load of lalalalalalalalala!!

Of all the arguments in support of this tune, the fact that other songs "need more" is the dumbest.



No, if Noel wrote it, people would be saying "this is a good tune but a bit half arsed. Where's the second half? This is the sort of thing we'd expect of Liam".

i'm outta time is brilliant. liam sounds great on the track...you can just hear the clarity in his voice. definately on my list of favourites.

Obviously some people don't understand the thread title, so I'll help them out:

appreciation
ap·pre·ci·a·tion [uh-pree-shee-ey-shuhn] Pronunciation Key –noun
1. gratitude; thankful recognition: They showed their appreciation by giving him a gold watch.
2. the act of estimating the qualities of things and giving them their proper value.
3. clear perception or recognition, esp. of aesthetic quality: a course in art appreciation.
4. an increase or rise in the value of property, goods, etc.
5. critical notice; evaluation; opinion, as of a situation, person, etc.
6. a critique or written evaluation, esp. when favorable.

If you don't like it, post in another thread.

I'd put it on par with TIOBI, both are Oasis classics IMO. The others you listed are all very fine songs but I think Outta Time has the edge over them. It is easily one of their best tracks since Morning Glory.

whatever, not gonna argue with you about which song is better, cuz neither of our opinions is gonna change

Facts are

A. I'm Outta Time is Liam's best written song yet.
B. It features Liam's best vocals since BHN.
C. Its produced beautifully
D. Its the only song on DOYS that has a chance in hell at cracking the Billboard top 40/75/or prolly even 200
E. I'd bet all of my money and my left arm that its the most successful single off of DOYS.
F. It'll be a No. 1 hit for sure... unless it defies all odds and "only" goes to no. 2

So far with DOYS, I havent approached it as a hardcore Oasis fan and picked apart every fucking lyric one by one and "divide" the songs based on who wrote them. I just listen to the songs as a MUSIC fan and enjoy the songs because of their melodies, vocals, production, etc. And based on this, I have to say that imo, Im Outta Time is the best song on the album.

I'll take this one for Moorish:

A. IOT may be Liam's best-written song. But is that really saying much?

B. Just because a singer's vocals are good on a song, doesn't really provide an argument. Another words, Liam's vocals are good on TMOS and that's a shit song. Get it?

C. All the songs on DOYS have good production. FD, for example, shits on this song from a 'production' standpoint.

D. Just because it's the only song on DOYS that may crack the Billboard, it doesn't make it good. It just means it's the most radio-friendly song on an otherwise unradio-friendly album. And is the Billboard any indication of a good song? Britney Spears, Gwen Stefani, etc. consistently crack the Billboard top 20. Enough said . . .

E. Once again, just because it's a successful single, doesn't make it better than any other Oasis song. Fallout Boy will have more successful singles than IOT, or any other DOYS song for that matter. But does that make it better?

F. No.1 or No.2 doesn't really mean anything. Roll With It went number 2. But Cast No Shadow shits all over it.

A. Yea. GGTIA was one of the best songs off of DBTT. LLAB was great too. Plus, many people credit Songbird as one of the best off of HC.
B. Never said great vocals made the song great. Just saying that it has Liam's best vocal in prolly a decade. Thats certainly something to be happy/excited about???
C. I do agree, although I think IOT has better production than almost all of the other songs (maybe TBWTL or FD has better)
D. Having an Oasis song be a hit in the USA would definately be something to get excited about. And I never said that cracking the Billboard 200 means its a great song. Im just saying that if Oasis... a band that hasnt had a US hit in years... manages to crack the US charts with this song, than that means its certainly a special tune. I think it has the ability as well.
E. Well... if its a successful single that means that its prolly pretty well liked by the general public. And altho most people are too elite to admit it... the general public has musical opinions equal to anyone elses... regardless of the music they listen to on a regular basis.
F. Thats quite opionated... Cast No Shadow almost didnt make the goddamn album... and very rarely do "shit" songs make it to no. 1 or no. 2 on the UK charts. They may be "shit" in your opinion... but most fans of music will admit that they're catchy, well structured songs.

I'm telling ya... I played the album on the way to a tennis match and the only songs that the other kids in the car really liked were I'm Outta Time (loved it), TSOTL (loved it), Falling Down, Bag It Up, and a couple liked TBWTL and The Turning. They all found Waiting for the Rapture and Soldier On to be boring as shit, and didnt think NoR or Aint Got Nothing were that good either. And Im guessing that casual/non Oasis fans will feel very similarly.

I'm Outta Time is a fucking great tune and I don't fucking care who wrote it. It's an absolutely gorgeous tune.

Hahahahahahahaha indeed. Now we're talking about IOT being in the same league as The Masterplan, are we? THE MASTERPLAN?!?!??! One of - if not possibly THE - best songs Noel has ever written?

Delusional. Utterly.

moorish, wtf is your deal? Not everyone has to think that The Masterplan is better than Im Outta Time. Im Outta Time is in the same league with The Masterplan IMO. Maybe you dont feel the same way, but that doesnt mean im a delusional fan. Get over yourself mate, not everyone should have the same opinions.

Nope, thats still opinion and passing it off as fact is sheer and utter garbage and you my friend seem to have a garbage by the truck load.

heh.. spot on mate.