Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 20:42:51 GMT -5
alot of u really mistook my review..i hold OASIS to a standard higher than any other band not named led zep- the stones -beatles-....it was a great gig..... BUT they could have did a bit more..both in length and in diversity.... FACE FACTS PEOPLE NYC IS DIFFERENT .... its the mecca of publicity and to play the same gig here is a bit sad...i am not comparibg them( as kings of leon said ) to the stones i dont want balloons...i just wanted a longer, more unrehearsed type show... those are shows that are legendary folks , not the same old same old  ..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY LED ZEP MSG 75 STONES 77 WHO 79 BRUCE 81 those were 3 plus hours of legend ..this was 95 minutes that i could havew heard on a cd...sorry guys its the truth |
|
|
|
Post by sisao9389 on Jun 23, 2005 20:51:17 GMT -5
alot of u really mistook my review..i hold OASIS to a standard higher than any other band not named led zep- the stones -beatles-....it was a great gig..... BUT they could have did a bit more..both in length and in diversity.... FACE FACTS PEOPLE NYC IS DIFFERENT .... its the mecca of publicity and to play the same gig here is a bit sad...i am not comparibg them( as kings of leon said ) to the stones i dont want balloons...i just wanted a longer, more unrehearsed type show... those are shows that are legendary folks , not the same old same old ..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY LED ZEP MSG 75 STONES 77 WHO 79 BRUCE 81 those were 3 plus hours of legend ..this was 95 minutes that i could havew heard on a cd...sorry guys its the truth i think kalas is really hitting it on the head. i was there, they sounded great, the crowd was great, in all accounts it was a great show but if they would of just put a lil more effort into this show it could of been legendary.. they were on point and the crowd wanted it, why not throw in a few extra songs at the very least and create a buzz.. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 20:55:21 GMT -5
alot of u really mistook my review..i hold OASIS to a standard higher than any other band not named led zep- the stones -beatles-....it was a great gig..... BUT they could have did a bit more..both in length and in diversity.... FACE FACTS PEOPLE NYC IS DIFFERENT .... its the mecca of publicity and to play the same gig here is a bit sad...i am not comparibg them( as kings of leon said ) to the stones i dont want balloons...i just wanted a longer, more unrehearsed type show... those are shows that are legendary folks , not the same old same old ..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY LED ZEP MSG 75 STONES 77 WHO 79 BRUCE 81 those were 3 plus hours of legend ..this was 95 minutes that i could havew heard on a cd...sorry guys its the truth i think kalas is really hitting it on the head. i was there, they sounded great, the crowd was great, in all accounts it was a great show but if they would of just put a lil more effort into this show it could of been legendary.. they were on point and the crowd wanted it, why not throw in a few extra songs at the very least and create a buzz.. thank u..thats my point,,,i am not hating ..but they were so close to being legend last night and they stuck to script..thats the point..yes they were great sounding,,but they weren legendary live wise |
|
|
|
Post by rockandroll on Jun 23, 2005 22:17:28 GMT -5
alot of u really mistook my review..i hold OASIS to a standard higher than any other band not named led zep- the stones -beatles-....it was a great gig..... BUT they could have did a bit more..both in length and in diversity.... FACE FACTS PEOPLE NYC IS DIFFERENT .... its the mecca of publicity and to play the same gig here is a bit sad...i am not comparibg them( as kings of leon said ) to the stones i dont want balloons...i just wanted a longer, more unrehearsed type show... those are shows that are legendary folks , not the same old same old ..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY LED ZEP MSG 75 STONES 77 WHO 79 BRUCE 81 those were 3 plus hours of legend ..this was 95 minutes that i could havew heard on a cd...sorry guys its the truth Well, Oasis are that way. They won't spread their ass just because they play at the MSG. I see your point, they could've done an epic show if they wanted to, but that's the way they are, they do what everyone else should do: Treat everyone the same way. Just because a place gives you more hype and press you shouldn't be any different, that's pretentious. BTW, I'm the kind of person who would prefer a different setlist every night, but if they decided to play all gigs with the same set they should stick to it and that's what they did. |
|
|
|
Post by StepOut on Jun 23, 2005 22:23:38 GMT -5
alot of u really mistook my review..i hold OASIS to a standard higher than any other band not named led zep- the stones -beatles-....it was a great gig..... BUT they could have did a bit more..both in length and in diversity.... FACE FACTS PEOPLE NYC IS DIFFERENT .... its the mecca of publicity and to play the same gig here is a bit sad...i am not comparibg them( as kings of leon said ) to the stones i dont want balloons...i just wanted a longer, more unrehearsed type show... those are shows that are legendary folks , not the same old same old ..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY LED ZEP MSG 75 STONES 77 WHO 79 BRUCE 81 those were 3 plus hours of legend ..this was 95 minutes that i could havew heard on a cd...sorry guys its the truth I completely understand what you're saying Kalas, but Noel has stated many times that he's not one to change the setlist for a particular town, he wants every Oasis fan to see the same show, so that no fan feels ripped off by the band. They've been using the same formula for years. Personally, I think the band need to break from their norm and change up the setlist every night. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 22:39:32 GMT -5
alot of u really mistook my review..i hold OASIS to a standard higher than any other band not named led zep- the stones -beatles-....it was a great gig..... BUT they could have did a bit more..both in length and in diversity.... FACE FACTS PEOPLE NYC IS DIFFERENT .... its the mecca of publicity and to play the same gig here is a bit sad...i am not comparibg them( as kings of leon said ) to the stones i dont want balloons...i just wanted a longer, more unrehearsed type show... those are shows that are legendary folks , not the same old same old ..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY LED ZEP MSG 75 STONES 77 WHO 79 BRUCE 81 those were 3 plus hours of legend ..this was 95 minutes that i could havew heard on a cd...sorry guys its the truth I completely understand what you're saying Kalas, but Noel has stated many times that he's not one to change the setlist for a particular town, he wants every Oasis fan to see the same show, so that no fan feels ripped off by the band. They've been using the same formula for years. Personally, I think the band need to break from their norm and change up the setlist every night. and i agree with everyone thats posted...i loved the show..i dont want them to "spread there ass"..as idler suggested(and i dont mean that bad idler i respect your view)..i just think THERE ARE TIMES TO PULL UP YOUR BOOTS AND SAY OK THIS GOTTA BE SPECIAL...AS ZEP DID, THE STONES EVEN U2 IN 87...THEY DIDNT THATS WHY THEY WILL NEVER BE CONSIDERED A GREAT LIVE ACT...SORRY I HAVE WITNESSED LITERALLY HUNDREDS OF SHOWS I CANNOT SAY THIS WAS REMOTLEY SPECIAL OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD I WILL GIVE U 20 GIGS THAT WERE NOT ONLY MORE INTENSE . BUT LONGER AND PLAYED WITH MORE PASSION WHO 81-SHEA STADIUM VAN HALEN-83 MSG BRUCE 84 BYRNE ARENA U2-87 BYRNE STONES 82 - MSG I COULD KEEP GOIN BUT U GET THE DRIFT ..THESE BANDS TO ME ARE NOT AS GOOD AS OASIS ( NOT EVEN THE STONES) BUT THEY SURE AS HELL EARNED THERE MONEY WAY MORE THAN OASIS " LIVE WISE" |
|
|
|
Post by rockandroll on Jun 23, 2005 22:47:32 GMT -5
i dont want them to "spread there ass"..as idler suggested(and i dont mean that bad idler i respect your view) No need to explain yourself to me mate  I'm not like the others  |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 22:53:41 GMT -5
i dont want them to "spread there ass"..as idler suggested(and i dont mean that bad idler i respect your view) No need to explain yourself to me mate I'm not like the others cool  ..cause i did not intend that as slur,,u make a good point |
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Jun 23, 2005 22:56:58 GMT -5
i think kalas and idler both hit it on the head. from what i heard it was a great show, thats all it had to be. i dont think anyone in their right mind was expecting them to play fuckin boneheads bankholiday or anything they havent done before. they've never looked for public or financial gain by doing that and thats why i fuckin love them. leave all that smart marketing to bands like coldplay or the fu fighters. i would have been disapointed with oasis if they would have done that.
and kalas, shut the fuck up already. led zeppelin, the who, the beatles all sold out for what was wanted back then. the jam was a different story going back to 68 and reinventing what was happening then, but the other bands pah..fuckin bandwagon jumpers. get me those fuckin bellbottoms so i can be a fuckin hippy. bollocks
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:02:19 GMT -5
i think kalas and idler both hit it on the head. from what i heard it was a great show, thats all it had to be. i dont think anyone in their right mind was expecting them to play fuckin boneheads bankholiday or anything they havent done before. they've never looked for public or financial gain by doing that and thats why i fuckin love them. leave all that smart marketing to bands like coldplay or the fu fighters. i would have been disapointed with oasis if they would have done that. and kalas, shut the fuck up already. led zeppelin, the who, the beatles all sold out for what was wanted back then. the jam was a different story going back to 68 and reinventing what was happening then, but the other bands pah..fuckin bandwagon jumpers. get me those fuckin bellbottoms so i can be a fuckin hippy. bollocks fuck u shaker ..u truly must be not reading my thread....SOLD OUT  i was talkin live gigs man..zep played for hours as did the who....being a sellin out is not a issue givin people a concert over 90 minutes is what i am annoyed at.. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:03:49 GMT -5
and i say the fuck u to shaker in a funny way , please dont think it was a dig..u know better |
|
|
|
Post by thebluesgnr on Jun 23, 2005 23:06:03 GMT -5
Let's be more pratical... what did you want them to do? 1) play for longer... well, they have another gig tomorrow. Liam can't kill his voice, it would be unprofessional. 2) play a new song (LTBL for example)... how do you think the fans from Detroit, Toronto and Chicago would feel? I don't think it would be worth it, "cheating" on the thousands of other fans to make the people who went to MSG feel more special. Any more suggestions? |
|
|
|
Post by rockandroll on Jun 23, 2005 23:10:34 GMT -5
Well, about Led Zeppelin playing over 3 hours....and believe me I'm a harcore Zep-fan....consider this...Moby Dick is a 15-20 minute DRUM solo; Whole Lotta Love usually included some Medley and tons of improv; and Dazed And Confused has that guitar bow thing for like 15 minutes!!!....the setlist wasn't THAT long... Would I like to see Oasis play for 3 hours?? Of course  , but it will never happen...Liam and Liam's voice are the main reasons I think |
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Jun 23, 2005 23:11:00 GMT -5
i think kalas and idler both hit it on the head. from what i heard it was a great show, thats all it had to be. i dont think anyone in their right mind was expecting them to play fuckin boneheads bankholiday or anything they havent done before. they've never looked for public or financial gain by doing that and thats why i fuckin love them. leave all that smart marketing to bands like coldplay or the fu fighters. i would have been disapointed with oasis if they would have done that. and kalas, shut the fuck up already. led zeppelin, the who, the beatles all sold out for what was wanted back then. the jam was a different story going back to 68 and reinventing what was happening then, but the other bands pah..fuckin bandwagon jumpers. get me those fuckin bellbottoms so i can be a fuckin hippy. bollocks fuck u shaker ..u truly must be not reading my thread....SOLD OUT i was talkin live gigs man..zep played for hours as did the who....being a sellin out is not a issue givin people a concert over 90 minutes is what i am annoyed at.. look at those bands. they did whatever was good for their career. its a fuckin fact. i wish oasis would play longer toobut they dont. and in a way i respect them for that. if they would have played longer it would be better for them fuck i'm drunk and i cant be arse. fuck off kalas you whiney vagina. and i mean this in a joking way too and btw. tou can fuck with me without explain it i dont take it to heart |
|
|
|
Post by mape on Jun 23, 2005 23:11:48 GMT -5
What Kalas is trying to say is that he wants to see Liam jump around in spandex like Robert Plant !  but anyway i don't think Oasis really distinguish New York from any other North American gig. They are probably all the same to them. Maybe if they did a one off show then they'd be more enthusiastic. I guess the only time they will really get into it is when they play manchester and you're going to that so don't be too sad. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:12:13 GMT -5
Let's be more pratical... what did you want them to do? 1) play for longer... well, they have another gig tomorrow. Liam can't kill his voice, it would be unprofessional. 2) play a new song (LTBL for example)... how do you think the fans from Detroit, Toronto and Chicago would feel? I don't think it would be worth it, "cheating" on the thousands of other fans to make the people who went to MSG feel more special. Any more suggestions? yes how about a noel 30 minute accoustic set? that now puts the gig at over 2 hours? ? what does that have to do with liam? |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:15:10 GMT -5
What Kalas is trying to say is that he wants to see Liam jump around in spandex like Robert Plant ! but anyway i don't think Oasis really distinguish New York from any other North American gig. They are probably all the same to them. Maybe if they did a one off show then they'd be more enthusiastic. I guess the only time they will really get into it is when they play manchester and you're going to that so don't be too sad. u see i guess i have 2 much passion for the band...i dont want them to run around in spandex  .....i want them to play a live musical set over 2 hours..thats all |
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Jun 23, 2005 23:15:30 GMT -5
What Kalas is trying to say is that he wants to see Liam jump around in spandex like Robert Plant ! but anyway i don't think Oasis really distinguish New York from any other North American gig. They are probably all the same to them. Maybe if they did a one off show then they'd be more enthusiastic. I guess the only time they will really get into it is when they play manchester and you're going to that so don't be too sad. you got it all wrong mate. kalas wanted liam to wear a warap around big momma ass that he could have taken pictures of and posted in the the lounge |
|
|
|
Post by thebluesgnr on Jun 23, 2005 23:17:10 GMT -5
So they should play the 19 songs and then an acoustic set? I think it would be weird.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:17:44 GMT -5
What Kalas is trying to say is that he wants to see Liam jump around in spandex like Robert Plant ! but anyway i don't think Oasis really distinguish New York from any other North American gig. They are probably all the same to them. Maybe if they did a one off show then they'd be more enthusiastic. I guess the only time they will really get into it is when they play manchester and you're going to that so don't be too sad. and mape ..seriously no wiseass crack please..have u seen FTM ??THE INTERVIEW at the end,,if u dont think NOEL distguinshes nyc (MSG) FROM ANY OTHER AMERICAN CITY YOUR MISTAKING |
|
|
|
Post by mape on Jun 23, 2005 23:18:41 GMT -5
you got it all wrong mate. kalas wanted liam to wear a warap around big momma ass that he could have taken pictures of and posted in the the lounge would there be spandex over the big ass? and would Andy walk over and slap it after every song? ;D |
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Jun 23, 2005 23:19:41 GMT -5
kalas you fuckin vagina.
i was bbquing steaks and this fuckin thread made me burn the fuckers
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:20:11 GMT -5
U KNOW WHAT GUYS FUCK IT IM OFF TO BED.. i try to bring a serious issue up here and u wanna fuck around ,,i cant be arsed..whatever..i know this i seen more shows than most of u and this show was nothing "special" later
|
|
|
|
Post by StepOut on Jun 23, 2005 23:21:31 GMT -5
Let's be more pratical... what did you want them to do? 1) play for longer... well, they have another gig tomorrow. Liam can't kill his voice, it would be unprofessional. 2) play a new song (LTBL for example)... how do you think the fans from Detroit, Toronto and Chicago would feel? I don't think it would be worth it, "cheating" on the thousands of other fans to make the people who went to MSG feel more special. Any more suggestions? I don't think they can do a longer set, Liam's voice just can't handle it anymore. I would like to see the setlist changed every couple of nights and Noel's acoustic set brought back. I think the band should perform Wonderwall acoustically again, when I saw them last week I didn't understand why the played the electric version when they just played Songbird acoustically. Didn't make any sense to me. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 23, 2005 23:22:50 GMT -5
kalas you fuckin vagina. i was bbquing steaks and this fuckin thread made me burn the fuckers lol ..make mine rare please |
|
..people that post they cant believe i say this are not gettin it,,the concert was GREAT...IT SHOULDA BEEN LEGENDARY
..cause i did not intend that as slur,,u make a good point 
i was talkin live gigs man..zep played for hours as did the who....being a sellin out is not a issue givin people a concert over 90 minutes is what i am annoyed at..
.....i want them to play a live musical set over 2 hours..thats all
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5