|
|
Post by marqueemoon on Oct 10, 2024 18:22:18 GMT -5
As amazing it is that Oasis are back, Liam’s comeback felt like an absolute miracle at the time. Still does in some ways at least to me. Really the start of the road to the reunion.
|
|
|
|
Post by glider on Oct 10, 2024 18:44:33 GMT -5
I’m still surprised this reunion thread didn’t break the record of most users online, still currently held by Liam’s comeback in 2017. Damn. Really?!? Most registered users online in a single day. If you combine the guests, the August announcement eclipses it easily. |
|
|
|
Post by NicOasis on Oct 10, 2024 20:23:17 GMT -5
Most registered users online in a single day. If you combine the guests, the August announcement eclipses it easily. I think a lot of would be log ons likely converted to some Facebook page or reddit after lockdown. |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 11, 2024 2:11:27 GMT -5
Fully agree; that and the bsides noel sung on the record that will be sung by Liam, like Step Out. I doubt there will be much material from post 00s records SOTSOG : go let it out maybe Gas Panic if they are feeling adventurous HC : SCYHO, LBL DBTT: Lyla (maybe they will try Let There Be love for "new" content). DOYS : Outta Time or Falling Down. That's it. The set will be 2 hrs max. The majority of it will be MG and DM . There will be no liam tunes. Mostly first two albums with possible Stand by Me, Go Let It Out, Lyla , Importance of being Idle with a few bsides such as Masterplan, Talk Tonight, Acquiisce, half the world away (def)If they play anything off DOYS it will be Shock of The Lightening but I would think they won’t play anything off that album.Failing Down killed the atmosphere when they played it liive last tour. Put simply it will be the best of oasis and classic bsides the last Oasis tour killed the atmosphere as a whole, not just Falling down; Importance of being Idle was as much liked as falling Down really; so maybe none of them. But noel will want to throw a few of his sung tunes. At least 5 : DLBIA, LbL, Half the world away, the masterplan are sure to be there; That leaves one or two. i dont think Shock of The Lightening will be played because they have a lot and better rock songs from the first 3 records so there is not need for this one, which people were bored with at tours in 2009 too. So my guess is it wont be there. |
|
|
|
Post by headshrank on Oct 11, 2024 3:07:30 GMT -5
The set will be 2 hrs max. The majority of it will be MG and DM . There will be no liam tunes. Mostly first two albums with possible Stand by Me, Go Let It Out, Lyla , Importance of being Idle with a few bsides such as Masterplan, Talk Tonight, Acquiisce, half the world away (def)If they play anything off DOYS it will be Shock of The Lightening but I would think they won’t play anything off that album.Failing Down killed the atmosphere when they played it liive last tour. Put simply it will be the best of oasis and classic bsides the last Oasis tour killed the atmosphere as a whole, not just Falling down; Importance of being Idle was as much liked as falling Down really; so maybe none of them. But noel will want to throw a few of his sung tunes. At least 5 : DLBIA, LbL, Half the world away, the masterplan are sure to be there; That leaves one or two. i dont think Shock of The Lightening will be played because they have a lot and better rock songs from the first 3 records so there is not need for this one, which people were bored with at tours in 2009 too. So my guess is it wont be there. i’m not sure how they’ll do it, but i think potentially there could be a few traditional noel songs, sung by liam. sad song for example. or could we even see bonehead make his vocal debut and do a rendition of boneheads bank holiday, if it’s going to be a heavy wtsmg setlist? |
|
|
|
Post by yeayeayeah on Oct 11, 2024 3:59:23 GMT -5
I hope they do the acoustic set in the middle like they did in 96, cast no shadow, whatever, masterplan etc... gives variety to the show. They should just do the Maine Rd set TBH
|
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 11, 2024 5:49:38 GMT -5
the last Oasis tour killed the atmosphere as a whole, not just Falling down; Importance of being Idle was as much liked as falling Down really; so maybe none of them. But noel will want to throw a few of his sung tunes. At least 5 : DLBIA, LbL, Half the world away, the masterplan are sure to be there; That leaves one or two. i dont think Shock of The Lightening will be played because they have a lot and better rock songs from the first 3 records so there is not need for this one, which people were bored with at tours in 2009 too. So my guess is it wont be there. i’m not sure how they’ll do it, but i think potentially there could be a few traditional noel songs, sung by liam. sad song for example. or could we even see bonehead make his vocal debut and do a rendition of boneheads bank holiday, if it’s going to be a heavy wtsmg setlist? Yeah sad song and step out sung by Liam, i'd say its gonna happen. Half the world Away will stay will Noel As much as id love to hear boneheads bank holiday played, i doubt it will happen; Its very "obscure" and I dont see Noel greenlighting Bonehead singing; |
|
|
|
Post by headshrank on Oct 11, 2024 6:04:02 GMT -5
i’m not sure how they’ll do it, but i think potentially there could be a few traditional noel songs, sung by liam. sad song for example. or could we even see bonehead make his vocal debut and do a rendition of boneheads bank holiday, if it’s going to be a heavy wtsmg setlist? Yeah sad song and step out sung by Liam, i'd say its gonna happen. Half the world Away will stay will Noel As much as id love to hear boneheads bank holiday played, i doubt it will happen; Its very "obscure" and I dont see Noel greenlighting Bonehead singing; maybe they only reformed on the basis that bonehead gets to sing one song? 😂 |
|
notsally
Oasis Roadie
I'm not electric but I'm in a family full of eccentrics nevertheless
Posts: 120
Member is Online
|
Post by notsally on Oct 11, 2024 6:15:42 GMT -5
i’m not sure how they’ll do it, but i think potentially there could be a few traditional noel songs, sung by liam. sad song for example. or could we even see bonehead make his vocal debut and do a rendition of boneheads bank holiday, if it’s going to be a heavy wtsmg setlist? Yeah sad song and step out sung by Liam, i'd say its gonna happen. Half the world Away will stay will Noel As much as id love to hear boneheads bank holiday played, i doubt it will happen; Its very "obscure" and I dont see Noel greenlighting Bonehead singing; it's funny because for a long time bonehead's bank holiday was my husband's favourite oasis song and before he met me he pretty much stopped on BHN and preferred blur edit: given this context, how he got to know bonehead's bank holiday is unclear to me and by now i think i'd rather not ask |
|
|
|
Post by His Royal Noelness on Oct 11, 2024 6:20:23 GMT -5
See Noel has finally spoken... but just shite about Man City, spewing a paranoid victimisation complex because the authorities are trying to clamp down on their corruption. Quit the divorced dad energy and chat about the music please. Typical man of the people, he's obviously been hanging around tin foil hat wearing serial sex offender Russell Brand too much. The Premier League’s APT rules were brought in to protect a very small minority of clubs. Clubs which were involved in Project Big Picture and the Super League. Fuck Man City but the Premier League isn’t fit to govern itself. It needs to have an independent regulator. Fuck Richard Masters. He’s only there to do the bidding of a few select clubs. |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 11, 2024 8:14:03 GMT -5
Yeah sad song and step out sung by Liam, i'd say its gonna happen. Half the world Away will stay will Noel As much as id love to hear boneheads bank holiday played, i doubt it will happen; Its very "obscure" and I dont see Noel greenlighting Bonehead singing; it's funny because for a long time bonehead's bank holiday was my husband's favourite oasis song and before he met me he pretty much stopped on BHN and preferred blur edit: given this context, how he got to know bonehead's bank holiday is unclear to me and by now i think i'd rather not ask Well its a mythical song for oasis fans pre-BHN (eg, the olds). It was a song only available on vinyl and it was a real treasure hunt to get it in 1996, coz first - the vinyl was hard to find (way harder than singles) and 2-You had to have a turntable to play. Same for Sad Song. I also love it, it was one of my favorite song by Oasis, too bad they never made a "lighter" album with songs like that. Its also not a coincidence that your husband liked Blur better, coz to me that song if the most "blur" song Oasis has ever done. It could fit on The great escape, easily; I suppose then he heard it during a drinking party at friend's who had a vinyl player. and by the time the song got played (end of disc one), pretty good chances he was drunk already  |
|
notsally
Oasis Roadie
I'm not electric but I'm in a family full of eccentrics nevertheless
Posts: 120
Member is Online
|
Post by notsally on Oct 11, 2024 8:38:11 GMT -5
it's funny because for a long time bonehead's bank holiday was my husband's favourite oasis song and before he met me he pretty much stopped on BHN and preferred blur edit: given this context, how he got to know bonehead's bank holiday is unclear to me and by now i think i'd rather not ask Well its a mythical song for oasis fans pre-BHN (eg, the olds). It was a song only available on vinyl and it was a real treasure hunt to get it in 1996, coz first - the vinyl was hard to find (way harder than singles) and 2-You had to have a turntable to play. Same for Sad Song. I also love it, it was one of my favorite song by Oasis, too bad they never made a "lighter" album with songs like that. Its also not a coincidence that your husband liked Blur better, coz to me that song if the most "blur" song Oasis has ever done. It could fit on The great escape, easily; I suppose then he heard it during a drinking party at friend's who had a vinyl player. and by the time the song got played (end of disc one), pretty good chances he was drunk already i don't really think this is how he met bonehead's bank holiday because we are brazilians! singles of international acts were actually unusual here my husband was basically a mtv 90s kid and he says he did used to have a school friend whose father was a musician and the guy showed them lots of things when they were like 8. i guess this is the whole napster/internet thing! but even then you'd have to search to get to bonehead's bank holiday! i used to download a lot when i was a teen and basically you'd have to know what you were searching edit: what amazes me most is that he managed to find bonehead's bank holiday BUT NOT DBTT for example. he thought lyla was a tune from the 90s even though he saw the videoclip on mtv!! |
|
|
|
Post by GlastoEls on Oct 11, 2024 10:14:18 GMT -5
it's funny because for a long time bonehead's bank holiday was my husband's favourite oasis song and before he met me he pretty much stopped on BHN and preferred blur edit: given this context, how he got to know bonehead's bank holiday is unclear to me and by now i think i'd rather not ask Well its a mythical song for oasis fans pre-BHN (eg, the olds). It was a song only available on vinyl and it was a real treasure hunt to get it in 1996, coz first - the vinyl was hard to find (way harder than singles) and 2-You had to have a turntable to play. Same for Sad Song.) Ha! This is exactly correct. And you triggered a memory - I remember my then best mate sitting me down one night on the walk back from the pub and saying “sit down… Bonehead’s Bank Holiday.. I’ve got it.. I found the vinyl today and used Dad’s record player to tape it!” Was a holy grail in the era before YouTube! |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 11, 2024 10:33:04 GMT -5
Well its a mythical song for oasis fans pre-BHN (eg, the olds). It was a song only available on vinyl and it was a real treasure hunt to get it in 1996, coz first - the vinyl was hard to find (way harder than singles) and 2-You had to have a turntable to play. Same for Sad Song.) Ha! This is exactly correct. And you triggered a memory - I remember my then best mate sitting me down one night on the walk back from the pub and saying “sit down… Bonehead’s Bank Holiday.. I’ve got it.. I found the vinyl today and used Dad’s record player to tape it!” Was a holy grail in the era before YouTube! Yeah, it was really an honour to have that song (and Sad Song); Luckily i had a turntable at home but i remember being really frustrated not to be able to play it on CD with my greeaaat 90s all in on cassette/CD and radio speakers ( ), or my DISCman on the go. Good times, exciting times indeed. the whole period between late 94 and mid 98 when there was new bsides every three months, that was the stuff. Saving money for the single, Going to the shop, (or shopS because they didn't have the single)... etc Too bad the new generation cant experience that. It was really special; |
|
|
|
Post by standonit on Oct 11, 2024 11:31:57 GMT -5
Sad Song appeared on a free compilation CD given away with The Big Issue magazine one week (Creation supplied a couple of free compilations for that magazine in the 90s I think). That might have been its first widespread availability on CD in the UK, I know it was on the Japanese Definitely Maybe too.
|
|
|
|
Post by jt79 on Oct 12, 2024 2:55:49 GMT -5
Yeah sad song and step out sung by Liam, i'd say its gonna happen. Half the world Away will stay will Noel As much as id love to hear boneheads bank holiday played, i doubt it will happen; Its very "obscure" and I dont see Noel greenlighting Bonehead singing; it's funny because for a long time bonehead's bank holiday was my husband's favourite oasis song and before he met me he pretty much stopped on BHN and preferred blur edit: given this context, how he got to know bonehead's bank holiday is unclear to me and by now i think i'd rather not ask I had it off one of those ‘given away with the NME’ free tapes - eil.com/shop/moreinfo.asp?catalogid=275715 Mad to think how difficult it was to get hold of certain tracks then. |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 12, 2024 3:48:57 GMT -5
Sad Song appeared on a free compilation CD given away with The Big Issue magazine one week (Creation supplied a couple of free compilations for that magazine in the 90s I think). That might have been its first widespread availability on CD in the UK, I know it was on the Japanese Definitely Maybe too. Totally, i have the japanese CD. Think it might even be signed by Noel Gallagher himself. |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 12, 2024 3:51:21 GMT -5
it's funny because for a long time bonehead's bank holiday was my husband's favourite oasis song and before he met me he pretty much stopped on BHN and preferred blur edit: given this context, how he got to know bonehead's bank holiday is unclear to me and by now i think i'd rather not ask I had it off one of those ‘given away with the NME’ free tapes - eil.com/shop/moreinfo.asp?catalogid=275715 Mad to think how difficult it was to get hold of certain tracks then. yeah this one was a hard one. I remember having a hard time finding Dont Go AWay japanese version to get Some Might Say demo. But we had more time on our hands, didnt we ?  (Barely) no internet, no smartphone... I could spend hours in Virgin megastore and shops like that. Just looking at album covers and wondering if its good, if i should buy it... |
|
|
|
Post by racingman11 on Oct 12, 2024 4:18:57 GMT -5
Mad to think this (stellar) demo is still unreleased except on this japanese single.
|
|
|
|
Post by sheisloved on Oct 12, 2024 11:52:11 GMT -5
As amazing it is that Oasis are back, Liam’s comeback felt like an absolute miracle at the time. Still does in some ways at least to me. Really the start of the road to the reunion. Debbie is the catalyst. She deserves all the flowers. She saved LG. |
|
|
|
Post by GIMH on Oct 12, 2024 14:21:13 GMT -5
yeah this one was a hard one. I remember having a hard time finding Dont Go AWay japanese version to get Some Might Say demo. But we had more time on our hands, didnt we ? (Barely) no internet, no smartphone... I could spend hours in Virgin megastore and shops like that. Just looking at album covers and wondering if its good, if i should buy it... I bought the don’t go away Japan single for about £25 in 2003, which was a lot for a single! It was annoying though because sad Song had the fade from the previous track, I think that was Cigs & Alcohol live at the G Mex. from memory the fourth track was the acoustic Fade Away which was also not something I had on CD until then. But I was never satisfied Re Sad Song until I got my hands on a Japanese definitely Maybe. The one I got also has Cloudburst on - not sure if that was standard or this was special edition |
|
|
|
Post by marqueemoon on Oct 12, 2024 17:41:28 GMT -5
As amazing it is that Oasis are back, Liam’s comeback felt like an absolute miracle at the time. Still does in some ways at least to me. Really the start of the road to the reunion. Debbie is the catalyst. She deserves all the flowers. She saved LG. Absolutely. And I hope she’s playing a large role in the reunion as well. At the very least I have confidence Liam will deliver his best with her keeping him on track. |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Oct 13, 2024 2:35:23 GMT -5
yeah this one was a hard one. I remember having a hard time finding Dont Go AWay japanese version to get Some Might Say demo. But we had more time on our hands, didnt we ? (Barely) no internet, no smartphone... I could spend hours in Virgin megastore and shops like that. Just looking at album covers and wondering if its good, if i should buy it... I bought the don’t go away Japan single for about £25 in 2003, which was a lot for a single! It was annoying though because sad Song had the fade from the previous track, I think that was Cigs & Alcohol live at the G Mex. from memory the fourth track was the acoustic Fade Away which was also not something I had on CD until then. But I was never satisfied Re Sad Song until I got my hands on a Japanese definitely Maybe. The one I got also has Cloudburst on - not sure if that was standard or this was special edition Well you are right i got that mixed up ! of course it was fade Away War child version. One of my favorite Oasis song ever too. Dont be hard on yourself, i probably paid as much when i bought it in 1998, japanese import have always been very expensive. Some Might Say demo and You've Got to Hide Your Love Away are on the SMS japanese single, which i also bought. but i dont remember buying it I agree the fade is annoying, but if you buy the DM CD Sad song is well alone and no fade in or out. |
|
|
|
Post by The Chief on Oct 13, 2024 7:42:13 GMT -5
I'm not convinced this is actually true. They could do separate interviews for example and tell interviewers that any questions about the relationship between them is off limits. I would love to see Liam walk out insulting the interviewer for not respecting that This just seems like a throwaway answer, like Liam does sometimes, that the media is going with as fact, like the media does sometimes... |
|
notsally
Oasis Roadie
I'm not electric but I'm in a family full of eccentrics nevertheless
Posts: 120
Member is Online
|
Post by notsally on Oct 13, 2024 7:50:19 GMT -5
I'm not convinced this is actually true. They could do separate interviews for example and tell interviewers that any questions about the relationship between them is off limits. I would love to see Liam walk out insulting the interviewer for not respecting that This just seems like a throwaway answer, like Liam does sometimes, that the media is going with as fact, like the media does sometimes... They have spent the past 30 years saying whatever they wanted in interviews and now they are scared of journalists lol I think it's pretty funny how press took that as a fact |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5