|
Post by tiger40 on Jun 5, 2021 12:49:33 GMT -5
It depends on what is meant by overrated. In my opinion, a song needs to be played live for a tour or on the radio before it can be deemed overrated. That in itself means the song is 'rated' by the band and/or the public. On an Oasis forum there are going to be many songs that we as fans rate that others fans won't, for example, I think it can depend on something like seeing it live at a great concert and experiencing the song or not. In light of this my 5 are: Cigarettes & Alcohol Shakermaker It's Getting Better, Man (album should have finished with All Around The World) Shock of the Lightning (never saw them live when this was released, hence me not experiencing it) Roll With It (awful, awful song) Roll With It isn't my favourite Oasis song and it's certainly not in my top 20 favourites but I don't think that it's an awful song but overrated yes I agree with you.
|
|
|
Post by thepaperboy on Jun 5, 2021 15:59:18 GMT -5
It depends on what is meant by overrated. In my opinion, a song needs to be played live for a tour or on the radio before it can be deemed overrated. That in itself means the song is 'rated' by the band and/or the public. On an Oasis forum there are going to be many songs that we as fans rate that others fans won't, for example, I think it can depend on something like seeing it live at a great concert and experiencing the song or not. In light of this my 5 are: Cigarettes & Alcohol Shakermaker It's Getting Better, Man (album should have finished with All Around The World) Shock of the Lightning (never saw them live when this was released, hence me not experiencing it) Roll With It (awful, awful song) Roll With It isn't my favourite Oasis song and it's certainly not in my top 20 favourites but I don't think that it's an awful song but overrated yes I agree with you. Ok, maybe awful is a strong word (and I used it twice!). I can't deny that when it is played live the fans go mental for it at times. I just feel it could be the weakest song on the album.
|
|
|
Post by thepaperboy on Jun 5, 2021 16:04:50 GMT -5
Stay Young Stand By Me Stop Crying Your Heart Out Let's All Make Believe The Masterplan Four Letter Word Back After the Break Off at the Next Exit Girls in Uniform The Beat Goes On We're On Our Way Now The Dying of the Light Freaky Teeth Wandering Star A Dream Is All I Need To Get By Once For What It's Worth All You're Dreaming Of Shockwave I Never Wanna Be Like You You're a bit late for the Top 100 songs thread
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Jun 5, 2021 18:08:03 GMT -5
Wall of Glass Stop the Clocks Record Machine Roll It Over (I like the song but its made out to be a pure masterpiece) Step Out
|
|
|
Post by tiger40 on Jun 6, 2021 12:18:25 GMT -5
Roll With It isn't my favourite Oasis song and it's certainly not in my top 20 favourites but I don't think that it's an awful song but overrated yes I agree with you. Ok, maybe awful is a strong word (and I used it twice!). I can't deny that when it is played live the fans go mental for it at times. I just feel it could be the weakest song on the album. Yeah, you're probably right that it's the weakest song on the album. It's certainly the weakest single released from the album compared to the other three songs.
|
|