|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on May 15, 2020 11:01:26 GMT -5
The rating is for the longevity of their career - the good, the bad, the ugly, the Heathen Chemistry.
They get a 5/5 in my book. Sure, they needed to vary the set list, Liam’s voice struggled in the mid to late ‘00s, and the occasional walk offs and the ultimate end were unfortunate but Oasis remained untouchable throughout. Absolutely a phenomenal live act.
And as much as we like to call Noel lazy, it was he who instilled an insanely strong and rigid work ethic within the band which ultimately made them what they ended up becoming.
And any one who gives them below a 4.5 needs to go support West Ham and get the fuck out of this forum and go and be a football hooligan, right? Cos we're fans, right...
|
|
|
Post by shamumaybard on May 15, 2020 13:49:50 GMT -5
Very hard to be unbiased and give a fair score but 5/5 😂 always had a couple of oasis songs floating in my playlist but what got me really into it was LG's comeback in 2017 and my interest just grew from there.
|
|
|
Post by madferitusa2025 on May 15, 2020 15:59:11 GMT -5
4.5 Can't call em the best live band but certainly up there for the emotional ride. Had Morning Glory around the beginning of 1998. Really liked it. Every time they came around, I always was out of town, up north boating, or had something going on. So I obviously missed the heyday. Ended up getting a used copy of FTM in 2001 and practically wore it out. Started getting the rest of the catalog and said come hell or high water, next time I'm in. Finally made it, Aug 2002. Thought they were quite amazing, but I believe what really got me was the crowd reaction, singalongs, camaraderie and the fact it felt like the balcony was going to collapse from the stomping and hell raising. I had been to some lively gigs, but... mind blown. Since then, kinda like a drug I can't do without
|
|
|
Post by freddy838 on May 15, 2020 16:46:15 GMT -5
Could've just done 1-10 rather than go up in halves
|
|
|
Post by The Crimson Rambler on May 15, 2020 19:05:11 GMT -5
Unlike some elements of the band I don't think their live performances are much to shout about. Outside of the Oasis fanbase I doubt the band gets any real props. What Oasis have going for them are the scores of sing-a-long anthems at their disposal, the enormous fanbase to create a sense of scale (no different than any huge band/pop act) and Liam Gallagher (a mixed blessing of course). Despite not being at all dynamic from a vocal stand point when Liam was on form he was a noted highlight however he's put in his fair share of subpar vocal performances. The setlists were largely very fixed, so there was never ever much sense of surprise and spontaneity. No one in the band was an exceptionally strong musician. The band are notedly static and have been compared to shoegaze acts. There's never been any attempt at any kind of creative use of the stage (BHN tour objectively exempt) or how the band interact with the crowd. No exciting guest performances, no exciting covers... You get the picture. The songs did the heavy lifting and I think people conflate that with the band's live performance. They were average.
|
|
|
Post by beentherenow on May 16, 2020 1:26:03 GMT -5
Yeah I’d agree with the above,
I saw them 7 times, all in the MK2 era, and whilst of course they were really good (Finsbury and v2005 especially), I never left wowed. They were good but not amazing. Whereas when I’ve been to see some live acts (Muse, Nine Inch Nails, Prodigy) I’ve just left speechless at the sound and spectacle.
|
|
|
Post by LlAM on May 16, 2020 1:42:07 GMT -5
What defines a great live act? Pure subjective fantasy? Great musicians can be boring as fook while a sloppy band can have energy that draws a crowd in - and vice versa of course!
What made Oasis appeal to me was that they were average blokes turned into rock stars. Their live sound always sounded huge as fuck and the songs were great to sing a long to and Liam's vocals (untill the latter years) was huge too and full of attitude, especially with Noel's backing vocals sprinkled on top. Maybe it's because I'm a fan anyway or because the crowd generally consists of proper fans, but I've always sensed a special atmosphere/tension in the air before they came out on stage that I haven't experienced with other acts. I also admire the fact that they were "static" on stage, I hate going to concerts where things turn gimmicky and forced (Coldplay?)
For me, Oasis concerts at their best are the benchmark and if we can have an acoustic Noel set in the middle, it doesn't get better.
5/5
|
|