Bring the light was maybe a misguided introduction to beady eye music.. but as a whole is a ok, enjoyable as catchy pop tune, great tune live.

Seems the roses gone that way with all for one, is undoubtedly a worse tune maybe playing up to squires guitar was their point which it does well, will sound great live..like bring the light, digsy diner etc.

As a come back tune after 5 or 20 years not a great tho

I still think they picked BTL as the first single cause they were trying to point out this isnt oasis anymore whereas four letter word is still DOYS styled etc, problem was BTL was just too retro sounding and too far removed from oasis without being interesting (its not what a life different) had they blended that sound with the spacey dve sitek sound on BE then it mightve been a bold move but people arnt into that 50s rock and jive stuff.

I expect that song alone pushed away a lot of potential fans out the gate.

Bring the light by a pretty good distance. All for One is a turd. Shouldn't be a single, and unlike bring the light, shouldn't be an album track either.

There are probably a couple thousand bands out there who are making better music than All for One.

I don't really get the comparison myself but I prefer Bring The Light. Great live.