|
Post by matt on Mar 14, 2016 16:05:20 GMT -5
I don't think so. Soul Love has a similar chilled out ambience to it, and that's one of my favourite Liam efforts in recent years. I'd love to see Liam go full on chilled out. Think a chilled out number would play to Liam's voice more these days, as well. Back After The Break is without doubt my favourite Beady Eye tune, and of all the things I like about it, it's paticularly nice to hear him singing lower down in his range for the verses. I wish he'd carried on with Beady Eye his thing on Dig Out Your Soul of only belting it out when needed, and the rest of the time using his voice more, to try and create a more dreamy, psychedelic atmosphere to the songs. But alas, in the general absence of any really great rockers, he must have felt he had to get all shouty again to inject some life into it. Also, now we mention chilled out tunes, I'm actually a really big fan of Soldier On. It gets an unfair kicking at times but maybe it's just because the preceding few tracks are terrible. That has an eerie, sinister mood to it that I wish they could have used a lot more for that album. The mood of it would have made it perfect for Standing on the Shoulders of Giants. It's understated and more effective for it as it is quite contemplative. I wish Oasis/Noel/Beady Eye would realise the impact of these kind of songs more as opposed to forcibly writing an anthem that turns out to be anything but, usually now ending up terribly cliched and tired sounding. Maybe those bombastic songs could only be written when they were younger and the hedonism and youthful energy drove that creative process, so perhaps in middle age they should be more contemplative and honest. You see it with acts like U2 as well, writing piss poor rocker anthems trying to recapture lost youth, but the only sense I get is it sounds like a mid life crisis being played out in the recording studio.
|
|
|
Post by Mean Mrs. Mustard on Mar 14, 2016 16:22:22 GMT -5
^ Agree with all of the above
Soldier On has always been one of my favourite Liam written tunes.
|
|
|
Post by tiger40 on Sept 27, 2020 13:33:10 GMT -5
A hard one as I love both tracks but I probably would go for While The Song Remains The Same.
|
|