|
|
Post by nolandergallagher on Dec 20, 2006 8:29:29 GMT -5
New fan here, i use to love Liam's singing but i only had one of their dvds from 1996 or something, at manchester, I heard a recent clip on youtube.... of liam singing and it was like shocking.... raises the question what happen? and who do you personally prefer singing? i like both but not liam lately  |
|
|
|
Post by listenup07 on Dec 20, 2006 9:19:46 GMT -5
if you dont like his voice now dont listen to it
|
|
|
|
Post by nolandergallagher on Dec 21, 2006 0:35:33 GMT -5
yeh.... ive got no choice but too
|
|
|
|
Post by caro on Dec 23, 2006 3:21:32 GMT -5
yeh.... ive got no choice but too last tour was ok IMO of course his voice has changed and is not what it used to be, but it's still decent the worse gigs are the ones in glastonbury and the pre-glastonbury in 2004 just dont listen to SCYHO   as for you question, i love both  |
|
|
|
Post by Rebel of the Underground on Dec 24, 2006 16:00:16 GMT -5
both are good singers cant choose 1 without the other
|
|
|
|
Post by Iliad ♣ on Dec 24, 2006 16:15:48 GMT -5
New fan here, i use to love Liam's singing but i only had one of their dvds from 1996 or something, at manchester, I heard a recent clip on youtube.... of liam singing and it was like shocking.... raises the question what happen? and who do you personally prefer singing? i like both but not liam lately It's because Liam was so foolish to ever start smoking and drinking. His singing pose hasn't had a positive influence on his voice as well. However, I believe he has been taking voice lessons ever since his horrible performance at Glastonbury 2004. His voice doesn't sound as nasal anymore as it was back in 2002-2003, which is of course a good thing. He also reduced smoking. I'm really looking forward to february 2007 when they'll play live at the Brit Awards. I'm curious to see how Liams voice has devloped since the DBTT tour ^_^ |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 25, 2006 11:59:37 GMT -5
noels voice has got better with time  |
|
|
|
Post by songbird11 on Dec 25, 2006 19:53:54 GMT -5
i prefer liams voice slightly better but noel's great aswel
|
|
|
|
Post by miekevandenberg on Dec 28, 2006 18:35:10 GMT -5
I love to hear noel singing the more balladslike songs and liam the rock and roll songs
|
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Dec 29, 2006 10:48:34 GMT -5
Noel is a better singer for me, technically anyway. However, I much prefer Liam's voice. The snare gives an edge to the songs.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 29, 2006 22:41:59 GMT -5
ZAK Starkey has the rock attitude!  Meanwhile, in my opinion, Liam is dreadful. Using excuses of how his voice changes over time, take a look at (I know i always use PJ) Eddie Vedder from Pearl Jam. He's been around since the 90s and his voice is even better now. Let alone he doesn't have another member of the band to take over singing for him nor the fact that PJ setlists are known for breaking the 30's each night (oh don't get start on that). As well as the fact, that theres songs where his voice varies, while most of Oasis' are vocally wise; equal. Liam just could careless if his voice is good or bad it seems. Liam's got the better voice for singer (studio you can easily see it DBTT esp) but Noel's the best singer live for them. If having a rock attitude means they could careless how they perform live for their fans then Liam's got it. I'm just comparing them to other bands i've seen is all. |
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Dec 30, 2006 10:55:51 GMT -5
both are good singers cant choose 1 without the other Agreed. However, they both have something what other doens't have. For example, the songs like DLBIA and TIOBI are made by and made FOR Noel. Without Noel, Oasis wouldn't be exist after 12 years and there's no singer in the world who can sing "Tonight I'm a Rock'n'Roll Star" like Liam does. |
|
|
|
Post by bwilder on Dec 30, 2006 11:40:27 GMT -5
Everyone's entitled to their opinion, that's what a forum is for. My opinion is that Pearl Jam is a dreadfully boring band and Eddie Vedder's voice is monotonous and annoying. Oasis blows them out of the water with regards to singing, songwriting, stage presence, and attitude. Just my opinion...
As far as Liam vs Noel- I agree with whoever said each has a good voice for certain songs. But for the rockier songs, def. Liam. His voice sounds like no other in the business- strident and full of swagger.
|
|
|
|
Post by His Royal Majesty Revolver on Dec 30, 2006 13:06:10 GMT -5
At the present?
Live - Noel
Albums - Liam
Not to say it's unbearable, but definitely not up to par
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 30, 2006 14:04:19 GMT -5
At the present? Live - Noel Albums - Liam Not to say it's unbearable, but definitely not up to par Exactly. well said. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 30, 2006 14:08:50 GMT -5
Everyone's entitled to their opinion, that's what a forum is for. My opinion is that Pearl Jam is a dreadfully boring band and Eddie Vedder's voice is monotonous and annoying. Oasis blows them out of the water with regards to singing, songwriting, stage presence, and attitude. Just my opinion... As far as Liam vs Noel- I agree with whoever said each has a good voice for certain songs. But for the rockier songs, def. Liam. His voice sounds like no other in the business- strident and full of swagger. I'm not trying to be rude. Don't take it the wrong way. But have you seen both bands live? |
|
|
|
Post by nyr401994 on Dec 31, 2006 14:03:37 GMT -5
to be honest, liam's voice has deteriorated really quickly over the past few years. his singing started to fade about 5 years ago. it's a shame, because on the records he sounds fine, but think about how many times he had to get that right.
|
|
|
|
Post by nyr401994 on Dec 31, 2006 14:07:39 GMT -5
ZAK Starkey has the rock attitude! Meanwhile, in my opinion, Liam is dreadful. Using excuses of how his voice changes over time, take a look at (I know i always use PJ) Eddie Vedder from Pearl Jam. He's been around since the 90s and his voice is even better now. Let alone he doesn't have another member of the band to take over singing for him nor the fact that PJ setlists are known for breaking the 30's each night (oh don't get start on that). As well as the fact, that theres songs where his voice varies, while most of Oasis' are vocally wise; equal. Liam just could careless if his voice is good or bad it seems. Liam's got the better voice for singer (studio you can easily see it DBTT esp) but Noel's the best singer live for them. If having a rock attitude means they could careless how they perform live for their fans then Liam's got it. I'm just comparing them to other bands i've seen is all. you're absolutely right on that one. i saw pearl jam in new jersey this past year and they blew me away. they were beyond incredible. it could have been the best show i've ever been to. eddie and liam are the best singers of our generation i think. but, i would like to hear liam sing "alive" or "betterman" and hear eddie sing "listen up" or "morning glory" and see who comes out on top. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 31, 2006 17:30:54 GMT -5
ZAK Starkey has the rock attitude! Meanwhile, in my opinion, Liam is dreadful. Using excuses of how his voice changes over time, take a look at (I know i always use PJ) Eddie Vedder from Pearl Jam. He's been around since the 90s and his voice is even better now. Let alone he doesn't have another member of the band to take over singing for him nor the fact that PJ setlists are known for breaking the 30's each night (oh don't get start on that). As well as the fact, that theres songs where his voice varies, while most of Oasis' are vocally wise; equal. Liam just could careless if his voice is good or bad it seems. Liam's got the better voice for singer (studio you can easily see it DBTT esp) but Noel's the best singer live for them. If having a rock attitude means they could careless how they perform live for their fans then Liam's got it. I'm just comparing them to other bands i've seen is all. you're absolutely right on that one. i saw pearl jam in new jersey this past year and they blew me away. they were beyond incredible. it could have been the best show i've ever been to. eddie and liam are the best singers of our generation i think. but, i would like to hear liam sing "alive" or "betterman" and hear eddie sing "listen up" or "morning glory" and see who comes out on top. What show in New Jersey!? Camden 5/27-28?! I was there! Anyway, Eddie singing Listen Up or Morning Glory, man oh man. Wouldn't mind betterman with Liam either! |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5