I pretty much love most things oasis related and been a huge fan for most my life. To me it's a religion in a way. Looking as objectively as possible I have been through each studio album of oasis and noel related and identified what songs really would be keepers and what you would throw away:

I think things are generally on the up for NG. We will never see the impact of the first 2/3 albums but hey times change and relevance is relavent to the time and context. But here to me is what songs would remain after the test of time

DM:
Rock n roll star
Shakermaker (not a fan but definitive)
Live forever
Columbia
Supersonic
Cigarettes & alcohol
Slide away

WTSMG:
Roll with it. (Not a fan. But got to keep
Wonderwall
DLBIA
some might say
Cast no shadow
Morning glory
Champagne supernova

BHN:
DKYWIM
Stand by me
Don't go away
Be here now (ok could loose it)
All around the world

I would keep my big mouth, IHITIK AND the girl with the dirty shirt

Think some songs are better live from BHN era

SOTSOG:

Fucking In the bushes
GLIO
gas panic!

Heathen chemistry:
The Hindu time
SCYHO
Little by little
Songbird


DBtT:
Turn up the sun (it's a good opener)
TIOBI (not a huge fan but it's first sign of noel break away)

DOYS:
TSOTL
I'm outta time
Falling down


HFB:
Every body's on the run
If I had a gun
Aka what a life
Aka broken arrow
JBAJF
Stranded on the wrong beach

CY:
Riverman
Lock all the doors
Dying of the light
While the song remains the same
In the heat of the moment
BOTMI


I like The girl with the X-ray eyes and you know we can't go back and the right stuff...just not sure on the legacy. Too early to tell