Making the worst Oasis album ever called Dig Out Your Soul their last studio album.

I have to disagree about Dig Out Your Soul. Its become one of my favourite albums. The second half is a bit weak no doubt but a lot of good tunes on there. But each to their own I guess.

Ironic Mimi. I thought the same thing after the split Dig out your soul ? It's so ironic considering that the first thing I thought after playing iit 20 times over and over was where is the soul ? The only oasis album that left me cold ... I re listened when I first got back for Lennon2217 and yea a couple of real good tunes. But still if not there worst effort certainly there least soulless to my ear ...too each his own indeed Bruno that's what makes rock and roll we all could be huge fans yet NOT hear the same thing and have two entirely different views

Had to edit too early , lol

THIS

They could have split in a more epic way than over a fruit dispute

Noel's a real motherfucker!

God bless.

Should have walked away when Guigs and Bonehead left. Once you add others with aspirations of writing tunes, then the overall quality went downhill big time. Not to mention the whole vibe of the band changed forever and not for the better in my opinion.

It's not getting Andy and Gem in the band or let Liam write a few tunes that create atricious Noel's tunes on HC.
Let's not rewrite history once again. Noel was happy to let the others write songs at the time because he had very little inspiration at the time, look at sotsog, look at hc, except for a few brillant tunes like gas panic, it's all bad.

Noel's output during the SOTSOG and HC years might have been less than great, but Liam/Gem/Andy were writing absolute shit and continue to do so for much of their output in recent years. It's not slight to LAG, they just didn't get the great songwriting gene. Not everyone can write Definitely Maybe, and follow it up with Morning Glory, and then in a debut release over a decade later release an album as quality as HGHFB.

My issue falls mostly with the vibe of the band post 2000. Oasis built their careers on being the common mans band, a group of lads having a good time. When Gem and Andy entered the scene it all changed to what many people view as kind of a "holier than thou" persona. It was never the same after that time . . . and the music also suffered as a result.

The dark period: Heathen Chemistry

I'm agree with you about the albums,really like SOTOSG and DOYS not HC (a part for LBL,SCYHO,The hindu times and two b-sides SIOL and Idler's dream) and not DBTT (I love TIOBI and really like Turn up the sun,POTQ,Mucky fingers,but the others...)
I know that if we're all agree the world become a boring place,there are some things that I haven't could done and that Noel has done,but you know,I can't say fuck Noel and I can't criticize Noel for something that he's done cos He can have his reasons,because he can sees the things in a different way and because what's happened is happened,just enjoy what we have,don't think what could have been or could have happened,Don't look back in anger

Same    I don't like to say fuck Noel or fuck Liam or fuck this or that.  As you said, the past is the past.  Whatever decisions were made, were made for a reason.  It's easy for us to judge in hindsight what should have been better, what could have been done, when none of us were in the band and really knew what was going on.  Of course, we'll still discuss these things--we're all fans and it's natural to speculate and debate.  

But I also like to stay positive and just enjoy the music.  Don't look back in anger, truly   Constructive criticism and debate is healthy.  But petty disagreements, unnecessary venom, etc. just bring the board down (this is not an attack on any one person here by the way, just a general observation).