I say Yes, it is



and I mean both...the album and the song

i concur with brumo...

noel is deep .... sigh..... ahhhh

It's an amazing song.

great song

It's good. I think Noel should have saved it for Be Here Now, rather than put it out as a b-side.

i think so dix ..both the song and the lp are pure quality....you know its interseting the songs in the masterplan were written eary in there carear and they didnt make the first 2 or 3lps ..look how many great tunes are on there ..i would be curious to see if the stones zep u2 coldplay ever released a lp of b sides and songs not good enough to make the cut so early in there career how strong there work would have sounded next to this??.....this is not comparing bands and saying whos bigger ..its more of a testasment to how brilliant noels early work was ..his outakes and b sides were fuckin mega...and i dont think mick chris bono plant could have wrote a b sided lp so strong after releasing only 3 lps...thats class

The Masterplan may not fit BHN or WTSMG, but I wouldn't complain if it was there.

Great song, great lyrics.

But its not one of my faves....