retrolego
Oasis Roadie
Walking to the sound of my favorite tune
Posts: 279
|
Post by retrolego on Oct 27, 2011 11:42:57 GMT -5
^^ Noel is being a little bitch by turning it all back on Liam. Noel has purposely abstained from giving a definitive answer because he is scared of people not liking what he has to say. Liam has been truthful to himself and the fans by saying what he feels at the time, if they had another fallout in some way or another between now and 2015 he would say then that he wouldn't want to reform whilst Noel would still not give people a straight answer.
Liam has changed his mind because the anger has gone since he first gave that quote. This IS making Noel look bad because he can't even be truthful to his fans by giving a proper answer. And you think Noel is saying he's not interested, well you must have listened to lots of interviews that I haven't heard, because I've heard lots of hint towards him missing oasis and wanting to be back in the band instead of being solo
|
|
|
|
Post by howsoonisnow on Oct 27, 2011 11:45:16 GMT -5
He fumed: "Thinking about touring with Oasis again in 10 years makes me vomit. What would a reunion be good for? Why would you break up a band just to come back together and play old songs? Liam February 2011 Amazing how when it's Liam that contradicts himself it's all good. But Noel doesn't even need to contradict himself and people go on how Liam is the only one speaking truth. Liam doesn't spend even a second thinking. He is horribly unreliable and is even less consistent than Noel, which is saying something. Liam is more spontaneaous. He didn't want to reunite the band then, but he had grown up since and thinks the MG tour is a good idea. There's six mont between the two statements. Noel on the other hand, said a MG tour would have been great but Liam won't want him anyway. He talked about it first and now he's saying he won't do it. So if he didn't want to give a chance to Liam to say yes, why mention it ? Only to make Liam looks like the bad guy and make people forget that He's the one ended the band. There's two day between the "it would have been great" and the "it'll never happen", so ... And he did lie about the V festival. |
|
|
|
Post by ctmazin on Oct 27, 2011 11:55:29 GMT -5
He fumed: "Thinking about touring with Oasis again in 10 years makes me vomit. What would a reunion be good for? Why would you break up a band just to come back together and play old songs? Liam February 2011 Amazing how when it's Liam that contradicts himself it's all good. But Noel doesn't even need to contradict himself and people go on how Liam is the only one speaking truth. Liam doesn't spend even a second thinking. He is horribly unreliable and is even less consistent than Noel, which is saying something. Liam is more spontaneaous. He didn't want to reunite the band then, but he had grown up since and thinks the MG tour is a good idea. There's six mont between the two statements. Noel on the other hand, said a MG tour would have been great but Liam won't want him anyway. He talked about it first and now he's saying he won't do it. So if he didn't want to give a chance to Liam to say yes, why mention it ? Only to make Liam looks like the bad guy and make people forget that He's the one ended the band. There's two day between the "it would have been great" and the "it'll never happen", so ... And he did lie about the V festival. Liam has said some dumb shit throughout, as has Noel. Liam has said some contradictory shit, as has Noel. Why you insist on being a professional apologist for Liam Gallagher is beyond me. If Noel had said "the idea of Oasis reforming makes me want to vomit" rest assured you would be on here talking about how bad of a guy he is. If Liam had released his first single and Noel immediately tweeted "Di(l)do" I'm sure we would be hearing about how Noel is an asshole trying to undermine his little brother's release date. For fuck sake, get your head out of your ass. Quite pretending that you know who is the better person. Trust me, you don't. I worked for a professional sports franchise briefly a decade ago and the player all the fans loved and seemed like a great guy was a giant douchbag, and the one player who seemed like a dick on the surface turned out to be a great guy behind the scenes. The fact is you will never know Liam or Noel and what they are really like. What we do know is that they're both dicks to each other. End of story. |
|
|
|
Post by headshrinker84 on Oct 27, 2011 11:55:48 GMT -5
I hope Oasis don't get back together it's better now the way it is. We are getting more music now than we would have if Oasis didn't spilt up.
|
|
|
|
Post by howsoonisnow on Oct 27, 2011 12:00:02 GMT -5
They're both dicks to each other. End of story. Yes that's true, but Liam is more spontaneous. And Noel uses and twist the press a little bit more. That's all. |
|
|
|
Post by ctmazin on Oct 27, 2011 12:06:05 GMT -5
They're both dicks to each other. End of story. Yes that's true, but Liam is more spontaneous. And Noel uses and twist the press a little bit more. That's all. Speaking of "twisting" information, you've written countless posts about how being a spontaneous asshole is somehow far superior that being a slightly more sophisticated and well-spoken asshole. Which is untrue. They're both assholes. I've known plenty of spontaneous jerks who act like jackasses on the spur of the moment. They're no more pleasant to deal with than those who are bit more nuanced about it. |
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Oct 27, 2011 12:08:32 GMT -5
Liam's problem is that he speaks without thinking and comes out with irrational, heart-over-head statements that occasionally reflect badly on him.
Noel thinks too much before he speaks and comes across as a bit too calculated, over-rehearsed and dishonest.
Neither are perfect, but I cannot abide the OTT apologists on both sides. There does seem to be a hell of a lot more on Noel's side than Liam's however.
As much as I love Noel, I did enjoy watching him squirm on Jonathan Ross. It's the first time he's really been caught off guard about Liam since the split.
|
|
|
|
Post by Fiennes on Oct 28, 2011 15:42:22 GMT -5
When Noel started saying that he would like to reunite in 2015 I didn't expect it and joked, "Liam is going to go and see a psychologist when he hears this" In fact, things did go in that direction...
I don't think Liam was mad about it and then with time passing by changed his mind about reuniting. To me he just looks desperate by immediately saying yes like this, or just a bit silly for coming out publically after all the "vomit" statements. He should have stuck to his "never again" thing and Noel to his "good to be free" thing. They both miss each other and they know it. Liam should just be a bit stronger emotionally and not be so impulsive.
Liam did not outsmart Noel - Noel just didn't expect Liam to just take the bait.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2011 17:55:46 GMT -5
He says factually without actually knowing anything.
|
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Oct 28, 2011 19:17:50 GMT -5
Liam is more spontaneaous. He didn't want to reunite the band then, but he had grown up since and thinks the MG tour is a good idea. There's six mont between the two statements. Noel on the other hand, said a MG tour would have been great but Liam won't want him anyway. He talked about it first and now he's saying he won't do it. So if he didn't want to give a chance to Liam to say yes, why mention it ? Only to make Liam looks like the bad guy and make people forget that He's the one ended the band. There's two day between the "it would have been great" and the "it'll never happen", so ... And he did lie about the V festival. Liam has said some dumb shit throughout, as has Noel. Liam has said some contradictory shit, as has Noel. Why you insist on being a professional apologist for Liam Gallagher is beyond me. If Noel had said "the idea of Oasis reforming makes me want to vomit" rest assured you would be on here talking about how bad of a guy he is. If Liam had released his first single and Noel immediately tweeted "Di(l)do" I'm sure we would be hearing about how Noel is an asshole trying to undermine his little brother's release date. For fuck sake, get your head out of your ass. Quite pretending that you know who is the better person. Trust me, you don't. I worked for a professional sports franchise briefly a decade ago and the player all the fans loved and seemed like a great guy was a giant douchbag, and the one player who seemed like a dick on the surface turned out to be a great guy behind the scenes. The fact is you will never know Liam or Noel and what they are really like. What we do know is that they're both dicks to each other. End of story. If Noel did do that a lot of people on here would think it hilarious. I don't see what the big deal is with someone changing there mind, Liam thought one thing 8 months ago and thinks another now? So what, I thought being flexible enough to change your mind was a good thing. And no, no one knows them personally thats true, but from more or less all fan reports Liam is a genuine, decent fella who has a massive amount of time for his fans. |
|
|
|
Post by Fiennes on Oct 29, 2011 8:58:20 GMT -5
From what we can see, Liam is more irrational and passionate, Noel is more emotionally reserved and uses words for self-defence. So what, they are different, both with their own weaknesses.
The problem is they are not just brothers, they are public figures and Liam forgets that. That's endearing, at times, but most of the times he just embarasses himself.
|
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5