|
|
Post by NoelandMeMay29 on Apr 1, 2005 13:26:09 GMT -5
Whys in the world is it ever a 'failure' if Oasis has an album 'not as good' as either of those?
MG is the #1 (I think its' passed Sgt. Peppers) cd all time in UK and has sold close to 22 million WW.
DM is the fastet debut ever and was recently voted best British cd ever.
One of those is either beating the other in every top album list almost 50/50.
How can one band beat its own album (and theres two) when a million other bands don't even have one album come close.
BHN would have been collosal for any other group. HC for another group would have been given 5 of 5 stars.
DBTT will be great.
You can't comapre ANYTHING to a debut when they we're young and raw. Also, how can you expect anyone including Oasis to 'top' MG.
Why should they have to?
I can't understand what people want. If you want DM or MG YOU ALREADY HAVE IT!!
Proud American Oasis Fan!
Lyla rocks!
Hope I can get single in US.
|
|
|
|
Post by davidennis67 on Apr 1, 2005 13:50:45 GMT -5
I actually rate Be Here Now and SOTSOG as being better than Morning Glory, but there you go.
|
|
|
|
Post by albertzz on Apr 1, 2005 14:28:07 GMT -5
I think the original poster's comments were very helpful as for david's comment - I don't understand at all - but to each their own
|
|
|
|
Post by holdonecho on Apr 1, 2005 16:01:26 GMT -5
What i really hope for is an album that is as consitant as the first two.
we have been disappointed by three fairly patchy albums in a row.
BHN, SOTSOG and HC aren't really a collection of steller songs.
they don't beg to be played as a collective whole.
i put sotsog on to hear gp and glio but i can't say that i anticipate upcoming songs...same goes with hc (which to me is one great song scyho, some good songs and a few too many bland forgetable tunes) and to a lesser extent bhn (which has quite a few good songs but has its share of clunkers and over-archers and was in the unfortuanate position of being the wtsmg follow up.
dbtt seems to identify with the eclectsism of wtsmg?
i hope it can match the uniform excellence of the first two.
|
|
|
|
Post by davidennis67 on Apr 1, 2005 16:24:00 GMT -5
I think the original poster's comments were very helpful as for david's comment - I don't understand at all - but to each their own I like a couple of songs from MG, but it seems to lack that punch. It's very mainstream (which isn't always a bad thing) and not enough proper rocking and rolling. |
|
|
|
Post by NoelandMeMay29 on Apr 1, 2005 16:37:39 GMT -5
I understand everyones own 'taste' to each album. I wasn't saying those two are my top 2 (although DM is my top).
I was just pointing out that collectively those two are regarded as the best with the most people.
If SOTSOG had Let's All Make Believe & One Way Road added, with Put Yer Money taken off
it would be my #3 after DM, HC, MG.
As I am typing this I am listening to the Scorpions so I realized everyone has an opinion.
I guess my weirdest quirk is that I don't like Roll With It that much at all compared to Hello and I'll take Rollit over over Gas Panic.
I know Oasis fans that don't like Champagne Supernova. Say the are silly.
To each their own.
I still like Lyla, but it's not my fave and most likely wont be my fave on DBTT. I think it's better than Hindu Times.
|
|
|
|
Post by lyla on Apr 2, 2005 5:33:28 GMT -5
Whys in the world is it ever a 'failure' if Oasis has an album 'not as good' as either of those? MG is the #1 (I think its' passed Sgt. Peppers) cd all time in UK and has sold close to 22 million WW. DM is the fastet debut ever and was recently voted best British cd ever. One of those is either beating the other in every top album list almost 50/50. How can one band beat its own album (and theres two) when a million other bands don't even have one album come close. BHN would have been collosal for any other group. HC for another group would have been given 5 of 5 stars. DBTT will be great. You can't comapre ANYTHING to a debut when they we're young and raw. Also, how can you expect anyone including Oasis to 'top' MG. Why should they have to? I can't understand what people want. If you want DM or MG YOU ALREADY HAVE IT!! Proud American Oasis Fan! Lyla rocks! Hope I can get single in US. i totally and entirely agree! we have so much from them already, amazing music...so yeah, i dotn see the point in looking for another record thats like DM (however fuckin great it is) to be released...cos we already have it! and it aint going anywhere. Trying to recreate the past would be stupid |
|
|
|
Post by Billy Davey ツ on Apr 2, 2005 6:50:41 GMT -5
What i really hope for is an album that is as consitant as the first two. we have been disappointed by three fairly patchy albums in a row. BHN, SOTSOG and HC aren't really a collection of steller songs. they don't beg to be played as a collective whole. i put sotsog on to hear gp and glio but i can't say that i anticipate upcoming songs...same goes with hc (which to me is one great song scyho, some good songs and a few too many bland forgetable tunes) and to a lesser extent bhn (which has quite a few good songs but has its share of clunkers and over-archers and was in the unfortuanate position of being the wtsmg follow up. dbtt seems to identify with the eclectsism of wtsmg? i hope it can match the uniform excellence of the first two. I totally agree. DM and MG are top albums, we all know the next won't be as good as them, but we hoped something better in SOTSOG and HC. I really hope DBTT is at least as good as BHN. I'm sure it will be  |
|
|
|
Post by Dominic on Apr 2, 2005 8:26:38 GMT -5
to be honest, MG is by far the best oasis CD, noel normally never discusses whish is the best but normally say "DM is my favourite" i think its because he is abit embarrest or knows he will never top it, ive only ever heard him say negitive things like "people never buy it for the other songs, its all for roll with it wonder,,,, and DLBIA", because really it is the best album ever realeased imo
|
|
|
|
Post by Wireless on Apr 2, 2005 8:56:46 GMT -5
to be honest, MG is by far the best oasis CD, noel normally never discusses whish is the best but normally say "DM is my favourite" i think its because he is abit embarrest or knows he will never top it, ive only ever heard him say negitive things like "people never buy it for the other songs, its all for roll with it wonder,,,, and DLBIA", because really it is the best album ever realeased imo I totaly agree mate, MG is my fave album EVER!! |
|
|
|
Post by iamthewalrus on Apr 2, 2005 13:10:28 GMT -5
i agree too, MG is their best album imo. I really do like be here now more than definately maybe though but i think thats the album where I got into oasis and saw them for the first time
|
|
|
|
Post by queenlyla on Apr 4, 2005 2:03:02 GMT -5
I believe DM beat MG by a long shot.
It just blow me mind off everytime, from the start (Rock and Roll star) and to the (Married with children (which is largely underated IMO)).
|
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5