exit1
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 58
|
Post by exit1 on Aug 31, 2011 13:52:25 GMT -5
IMO i think that most of the fans of OASIS ,including me ,prefer the alternative version of WFTR that the original one
It was more soulful and had a emotional vibe.
Noel and dave sardy should received the feedback of that critics and opinions.
Thats the same case with IIHAG
I beg that someday come out a proper"alternative version" of IIHAG that were so good like WFTR.second version.
just a wish,just a thought-
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 31, 2011 13:58:46 GMT -5
Does IIHAG really need re-recording...
|
|
|
|
Post by MacaRonic on Aug 31, 2011 14:04:38 GMT -5
I'm a huge Oasis fan and I prefer both official versions of WFTR and IIHAG.
Just sayin'... as a popular member would say
|
|
TheEyeballTickler
Oasis Roadie
"You can't give me a reason, I don't need one to shine!"
Posts: 428
|
Post by TheEyeballTickler on Aug 31, 2011 14:18:57 GMT -5
I prefer the official version of WFTR, not a fan of the alternate version at all. But I would like to hear IIHAG with just Noel, his guitar, strings and maybe some choir.
|
|
|
|
Post by thuperthonic on Aug 31, 2011 15:15:43 GMT -5
I dig both versions of WFTR, just as I dig both versions of IIHAG. Great tunes.
|
|
|
|
Post by letsallmakebelive on Aug 31, 2011 15:35:17 GMT -5
Why should Noel listen to the fans about how to write HIS songs ffs.
|
|
|
|
Post by XTRMNTRSCREAM on Aug 31, 2011 15:37:42 GMT -5
you haven't even heard a proper rip yet.
|
|
|
|
Post by Level 03 on Aug 31, 2011 16:01:29 GMT -5
you haven't even heard a proper rip yet. Exactly, please wait for the cd version. I was horrible with the good rebel after his first broadcast on Radio 1... now I just love this tune since the single released. |
|
crash
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 238
|
Post by crash on Aug 31, 2011 16:12:52 GMT -5
I'm convinced he rocked it up to avoid any resemblance to Sunday Morning Call. I like that tune but Noel doesn't and he really wants to get away from slow, strummed acoustic numbers, even if the melody is awesome like IIHAG. Personally I think it sounds great as recorded anyway, and while a more acoustic version with strings would be good, it may have also run the risk of being been a bit pedestrian.
|
|
|
|
Post by billslidesaway on Aug 31, 2011 17:07:46 GMT -5
You guys really need to stop listening to sound checks of half-finished songs that weren't yet meant for public consumption.
As an artist, I would be livid if this happened to me. And then when my art is finished in the way that I want it to be finished, someone then wants to critique it against the half-finished version that wasn't even supposed to be seen/heard by the masses in the first place.
|
|
|
|
Post by His Royal Noelness on Aug 31, 2011 17:16:22 GMT -5
Well, that's your opinion man.
|
|
CF83
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 400
|
Post by CF83 on Aug 31, 2011 17:27:16 GMT -5
What alternate version? It's a soundcheck recorded on a mobile phone. It goes without saying the official release is better. I don't understand how people can even debate that.
|
|
|
|
Post by worldsoutro on Aug 31, 2011 18:28:39 GMT -5
Oh.... I just herd Waiting for the Rapture Alt. Its soo much better than the original. More emotion and engrossing as a song.
This is def what IIHAG needs. The heavy guitars ruin the song..
|
|
Lester
Oasis Roadie
Standing in the sunshine, tanning in the moonlight
Posts: 104
|
Post by Lester on Aug 31, 2011 18:45:13 GMT -5
After the hype wearing off, I have some actual criticism for IIHAG.
The melody is spot on, but why the hell did he drop the second part of the chorus melody? The closing one I mean.
Also, there's a genuine lack of drumming skill on the song. It's almost as if Tony was the drummer. There's like 2 transitions, and no fills of any kind whatsoever. If Noel is indeed as great a drummer as he claims to be, the song could've been much better. Imagine DLBIA without Alan's drumming. It just isn't the same.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lennon2217 on Aug 31, 2011 19:52:43 GMT -5
Waiting For The Rapture (Album Version) > alternate acoustic version.
|
|
|
|
Post by worldsoutro on Aug 31, 2011 20:15:06 GMT -5
no
Waiting For The Rapture (Album Version) <<<< alternate acoustic version.
|
|
|
|
Post by Silence Dogood on Aug 31, 2011 20:16:36 GMT -5
the alternative version is cool but i love the wall of sound on those last 45 seconds of the album version.
|
|
exit1
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 58
|
Post by exit1 on Aug 31, 2011 20:34:39 GMT -5
Why should Noel listen to the fans about how to write HIS songs ffs. dude, im not talkink about his compositions or way to write his songs,, im tallking about the post-production and arrangements of "this" song |
|
exit1
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 58
|
Post by exit1 on Aug 31, 2011 20:39:01 GMT -5
you haven't even heard a proper rip yet. Exactly, please wait for the cd version. I was horrible with the good rebel after his first broadcast on Radio 1... now I just love this tune since the single released. my post doesntrefer to the "quality" of the `sound of the song, i`don like the "rocky and noisy" style of IIHAG that resemble forces of nature and falling down., i prefer that would sound like a ballad ,with violins,strings , piano and acoustic guitar.thats it. |
|
exit1
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 58
|
Post by exit1 on Aug 31, 2011 20:41:38 GMT -5
Oh.... I just herd Waiting for the Rapture Alt. Its soo much better than the original. More emotion and engrossing as a song. This is def what IIHAG needs. The heavy guitars ruin the song.. This. see? yo make my point! |
|
|
|
Post by Headmaster on Aug 31, 2011 20:54:42 GMT -5
I like more WFTR album version, the alt version sounds a lot like WPTWOTWOMS?
|
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Sept 1, 2011 1:25:39 GMT -5
WFTR album version is way better, the alt version belongs to a future anthology or something.
|
|
|
|
Post by GIMH on Sept 1, 2011 1:57:50 GMT -5
The alt. Version was a bonus track for a reason. It's worth having but inferior to the original.
Same goes for The Turning alt version. And Fade Away. And Cast No Shadow. And Up In The Sky. Etc etc
|
|
|
|
Post by songbirdsally on Sept 1, 2011 1:59:25 GMT -5
Also, there's a genuine lack of drumming skill on the song. It's almost as if Tony was the drummer. There's like 2 transitions, and no fills of any kind whatsoever. If Noel is indeed as great a drummer as he claims to be, the song could've been much better. Imagine DLBIA without Alan's drumming. It just isn't the same. You have a very good point here, the drums are very repetitive.. Drums really can take a song to another level. He missed out on that here.. |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5