|
Post by webm@ster on Dec 11, 2008 15:22:11 GMT -5
Oasis emerged from industrial England in the mid-'90s fully formed, with a clutch of startlingly sharp songs written by guitarist Noel Gallagher and an impeccably cool leader in vocalist Liam Gallagher.
The group's March 1995 First Avenue gig stands as one of my favorite concerts ever, with the young, hungry band firing on all cylinders and Liam already acting bored by it all, standing motionless and staring during his brother Noel's solos.
Even then, 13 years ago, everyone knew it was just a shtick, but it was a great shtick. And it perfectly complemented Liam's uniquely rock 'n' roll voice that recalled both the raw power of John Lennon and the naked snarl of Johnny Rotten.
Alas, there's a fine line between acting bored and acting like a jerk, and Liam proved he has long since crossed it Wednesday night at the Target Center during a largely bloodless, dull concert that displayed very little of the spark that made Oasis so exciting in the first place.
Touring on the back of their fairly decent seventh album "Dig Out Your Soul," Noel and the rest of the band did the best they could considering the dead weight up front. Second guitarist Gem Archer's and bassist Andy Bell's membership in the group is as long a duration as the founding members they replaced nearly a decade ago, and their casual ease with Noel and each other was obvious. Meanwhile, new drummer Chris Sharrock seems a perfect fit for the group, even though he's filling some rather big shoes,
Advertisement namely Ringo Starr's son Zak, who left the group earlier this year after clashing with Noel. Yet it was Noel who provided the few thrills of the evening, when he stepped up to the microphone for a handful of tracks like "The Importance of Being Idle" and "Don't Look Back in Anger." Noel and his plain, somewhat unremarkable voice would never carry an entire show — that's why he's put up with Liam all these years.
But Noel brings an entirely different energy when he sings, and the fact that he can't quite hit those high notes in "Idle" gives the song an appealing fragility.
Liam, meanwhile, sang most of Oasis' biggest hits — "Rock and Roll Star," "Cigarettes and Alcohol" and "Supersonic" among them — while swaying back and forth, meaning the end of each line was cut short as his mouth moved away from the mic. It was truly maddening, but thankfully, he didn't do it all night.
The crowd of 5,143 seemed split between the drunken, up-for-anything louts that follow Oasis in their home country and the patient, if somewhat bored, 30-somethings with fond memories of the band's heyday, which feels only that much more in the past after Wednesday night.
Alt-country icon Ryan Adams was on his best behavior while opening with his band the Cardinals. Folks hoping for one of Adams' infamous freakouts left disappointed.
Adams barely spoke a word, instead focusing on his songs, most of which were drawn from his recent, often patchy, albums.
Pop Music Critic Ross Raihala can be reached at rraihala@pioneerpress.com or 651-228-5553.
|
|
|
Post by webm@ster on Dec 11, 2008 17:08:44 GMT -5
Noel Gallagher so lovingly posted a note on the OasisNet.com website yesterday that made its way around the city the day of their Target Center show, aptly titled "News From The Middle of Nowhere." My personal favorite quote from this entry was this:
We're on the way to Minneapolis. I'm expecting endless boredom.
Well, we can't wait to have you here, either, Sir Noel. Did you notice the attendance, by the way?
Opener Matt Costa was much nicer from the get-go, however. Sparsely accompanied by two guitars, his set was in no way suited for an arena show, but held its own as if a coffee shop had been briefly constructed on stage for his 23-minute set. The evening's crowds had barely started to roll in as he started his set at 7 p.m., but he still managed to have the folks that were already there wrapped around his finger understatedly.
The transition from Costa to Ryan Adams literally took three minutes. I've yet to see turnaround like that anywhere. Adams and The Cardinals worked from a set list almost entirely comprised of tracks from their last two albums, Cardinology and Easy Tiger. The only Adams standards that they played were "When The Stars Go Blue" and "Let It Ride," with it's gorgeous build, off of 2005's Cold Roses. The warmth and crisp production on those two records were, however, re-imagined into thumping rock and roll arena tracks last night, blasting through the speakers and attendee's eardrums. The set itself ended on an intense note, with the Cardinology track "Magick."
This set was integral in renewing my own personal love affair with Ryan Adams that has waivered more than slightly in the past years. However, his set could have greatly benefitted from selecting some of his perfect, older songs from that gigantic Ryan Adams catalog he has. Also, that tight-lipped, barely talking to the crowd jive that the Twin Cities also saw when Adams played the Cedar last year needs to stop. It's just plain ridiculous to go from talking incessantly to barely speaking at all. If only there was a balance.
Photo by Steve Cohen
All bitchy Gallagher-journaling aside, Oasis took the stage with the appropriate set-opener of "Rock and Roll Star," and they held on to that esteem into the rollicking foot-stomper "Lyla." As a whole the set ebbed and flowed through hits and misses, as it would amp up for a time and then come back down with tracks from this year's Dig Out Your Soul. While their eighth drummer pounded away fiercely for the entirety of the set, The Brothers Gallagher would stand coolly onstage, Noel the seemingly-effortless guitar man and Liam the immovable front man/singer. If one was taking a tally of his moves, the count would come in around four: stand in place and leer at crowd, maybe a rock back and forth here and there, shuffling of feet and an unorthodox one that involved holding the tambourine in his mouth. One real complaint is that he has the tendency to move away from the microphone before he's done singing. Irritating details aside, there was a fair amount of tracks that inspired. "Cigarettes and Alcohol" was a real crowd pleaser, and there was no denying its major T-Rex influence as it swam in the guitar; and the girls clutched their hearts while the crowd sang along to "Wonderwall."
The first song of their encore was a thoroughly underwhelming acoustic version of the usually rousing "Don't Look Back in Anger." For the sake of argument, Oasis played "Wonderwall," they played "Champagne Supernova" -- why turn one of your most perfect anthems into a lukewarm acoustic number? In all fairness, the crowd in attendance seemed genuinely responsive despite this fact, and also in the department of Oasis radio hits. Isn't it mildly perplexing that a band with so many great songs would end with "I Am The Walrus?" Then again, everybody's got their heroes, and after Oasis has spent their career taking detailed notes from theirs.
city pages
|
|
|
Post by forestfan on Dec 11, 2008 17:47:21 GMT -5
[quote
But Noel brings an entirely different energy when he sings, and the fact that he can't quite hit those high notes in "Idle" gives the song an appealing fragility.
.[/quote]
wtf
|
|
|
Post by oasisish on Dec 11, 2008 18:13:54 GMT -5
I got Liam's tambourine
|
|
|
Post by Cast on Dec 11, 2008 19:27:22 GMT -5
the first review was pretty bad for a review. I do agree with some points that he pointed out but just in general it wasn't a good review.
|
|
lorijo
Oasis Roadie
Yes Noel, it is fucking cold in the winter here.
Posts: 159
|
Post by lorijo on Dec 11, 2008 21:20:38 GMT -5
Damn it, I really wish I could have went to this. However, with them playing on a sodding Wednesday night a 14 hour drive away, would have had to take at least 3 days off work to get there and back. At the time they announced the gig I could have taken the time off work but those who would have joined me did not. And I'm not driving 14 hours across the prairie in the winter by myself...
I was pretty ripped about this back when they announced the date earlier, however it all worked out. I ended up in a training course from Nov 29-Dec 12 I've been waiting for for 4 years to take the next step in my career and would have screwed myself over for my forseeable future had I missed it. Now I'm going to be getting the job I've been wanting for years early in 2009 so that made it a bit easier to sit home last night and think about how I was not at the gig... sigh...
|
|
|
Post by writerwithwrywit on Dec 12, 2008 9:04:10 GMT -5
Nice, dude. I saw that. I was so jealous. I think it was a pretty good concert. I drove to Winnipeg in September with some friends to see them and while that concert was great, I think the Minneapolis crowd was into the concert more. Because of that, The Brothers Gallaghers responded better. They didn't really play with the crowd in Winnipeg. And even though Noel ripped Minnesota in two of his blog posts and at the show, he was the last to leave the stage and applauded the crowd at the end of the show. He didn't do that in Winnipeg. Regardless of the disrespect for the place I call home (to each their own), it was still a great show. I hope I get to see them play again live.
|
|
|
Post by Noel Westerberg on Dec 12, 2008 10:44:45 GMT -5
It never ceases to amaze me that all these so called 'music journalists', who should have a firm grasp of musicianship, never realize the reason for Liam having to cut his vocals short and step away from the mic.
Anyone who has even a small grasp of vocal mechanics, would know that's simply because he doesn't have the lung capacity anymore to hold notes....
If these journalists are experts in the field of music, why don't any of them realize that....
|
|
|
Post by webm@ster on Dec 12, 2008 11:23:49 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by bandontherun on Dec 13, 2008 14:21:36 GMT -5
I read that only 6000 people came to see the lads!!!They have to play the "Northrop" next time!!!A capacity of 4800,thats perfect for Oasis!!!!
|
|
|
Post by noeler10 on Dec 13, 2008 22:52:13 GMT -5
Went to the gig... thought Ryan Adams was alright. Super loud though!
Oasis walking on stage to FITB was badass! And then busting out of the gate with Rock n Roll Star was awesome. I thought Liam's voice at the start of the show sounded like shit. But then once he got warmed up, it sounded loads better. Noel's voice was, of course, perfect. Solid set full of hits
Highlights for me: Masterplan, Don't Look Back in Anger (acoustic), Slide Away ("for the ladies"), and Morning Glory.
Wish they would've played: My Big Mouth, Bag It Up, Live Forever, Roll With It.
Songs from the set I could live without: To Be Where There's Life, Songbird (though it sounded especially good live), I'm Outta Time.
Wish they played more stuff off of Be Here Now! But overall, a great show by an amazing band.
|
|
|
Post by MinneapolisSongbrd on Dec 14, 2008 14:34:47 GMT -5
Was at the show of course. Eighth time for me. I loved it as always. I'm used to Liam's voice and his inability to finish a phrase, so I don't mind. Just like watching him on stage. I have friends who have never seen them (they haven't been to MPLS for a 7 years), and they know many more songs than the big 3, and hated Liam pulling away from the mic. Ruined the show for them. I can't say I blame them really. It's about more than the quality of his voice for me. Anyway, crowd was decent, better than Winnipeg at least. I had a great time with the help of a lot of Summit Winter Ale. Ryan Adams was loud, hid behind his hair, and played a few great tunes. Went to the Black Crowes across the street at First Ave after the show. While trying to scalp tix outside Noel and The Shroud walked right by me and into the side door. Shroud said thanks after I told him great show. His beard was perfectly groomed. One last thing about Minneapolis weather. It does suck in the winter, but anyone who says it sucks in our brief summer has obviously never been here. However, our long winter is terrible once Christmas passes. No way around it. I don't get why my fellow minnesoootans get so upset when people bitch about our cold. They are 100% right! Anyway, I knew they would get bad reviews after his post about depressed cattle. People tend to take themselves too seriously here. That is all. See you at Wembley- -a few pics from my seat-
|
|