|
Post by puretone on Aug 14, 2008 9:35:43 GMT -5
what you have to ask if oasis came out at the same time as the beatles with the songs they have now who would be bigger- or if they had come out before Thats fucking retarded. Slap yourself.
|
|
|
Post by Oasis39 on Aug 19, 2008 14:41:07 GMT -5
Noone here really thinks Oasis is bigger or better than The Beatles. Theres nothing Oasis did that the Beatles didnt do, and Nothing Oasis could do that The Beatles couldnt do. Two big things Oasis proved they could not do, 1. keep putting out consistenly great albums 2. become the unquestioned biggest band in the world during their whole existence.
The Beatles were universally popular, and there was NO question as to who the biggest band in the world was, everyone knew there was The Beatles...and then everyone else. The Beatles got better and better as they went on......Oasis if anything has gotten worse. But I still love Oasis, behind the beatles its Oasis for me. But come on people, Oasis is not by any means better than The Beatles. And to the person who said "Did The Beatles play Knebworth?" well if it werent for The Beatles NOOONE would be playing outdoor venues. The Beatles were the first to play outdoor stadium concerts, and at the time they were setting attendance records for concerts. The Beatles were the FIRST to do SO MUCH and theyre just as relevant of a band today as Oasis is, if not more
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker74 on Aug 19, 2008 14:45:21 GMT -5
iv nothing to add, totally agree.
|
|
|
Post by Cast on Aug 22, 2008 12:15:45 GMT -5
the beatles are far more creative but of course thats when Rock was relatively new but they had the balls to do stuff that has never been done before. They released stand out album after stand out album. Sure they have a couple of just OK ones but they have 5-6 definite classics. Oasis doesn't have that. Oasis are easily my favorite band but they can't touch what the beatles did. But I rank MG and DM over any beatles albums. I love all the albums but they haven't been a easily defined "classics". They haven't been able to create albums of that landscape back to back to back. but Noel for me the greatest songwriter. He might not be the most creative person but his tunes just connect with me the most. Both bands are top bands.
|
|
|
Post by Oasis39 on Aug 22, 2008 14:56:05 GMT -5
the beatles are far more creative but of course thats when Rock was relatively new but they had the balls to do stuff that has never been done before. They released stand out album after stand out album. Sure they have a couple of just OK ones but they have 5-6 definite classics. Oasis doesn't have that. Oasis are easily my favorite band but they can't touch what the beatles did. But I rank MG and DM over any beatles albums. I love all the albums but they haven't been a easily defined "classics". They haven't been able to create albums of that landscape back to back to back. but Noel for me the greatest songwriter. He might not be the most creative person but his tunes just connect with me the most. Both bands are top bands. Youre kidding right? You seriously think that DM and or WTSMG are better albums than Sgt Pepper, Revolver,Abbey Road,Magical Mystery Tour,Rubber Soul or The White Album? I would say that DM and MG are better than albums like Beatles for Sale, Please Please Me, A Hard Days Night and Help But definitley not the first 6 that I listed.
|
|