|
|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Feb 18, 2008 0:23:16 GMT -5
Here's proof showing why Liams voice, even as bad as its gotten, is still much much needed
Noel's voice on this simply doesnt work as well
|
|
|
|
Post by addofreeze on Feb 18, 2008 1:02:28 GMT -5
Yeah. Don't get me wrong, Noel's one of the greatest songwriters and definitely my favourite rockstar AND his voice is very good, but Liam's voice has a rock and roll edge to it. I liked it better before the cigarettes had done their damage to his vocal chords - but I still think he's got a good voice.
|
|
|
|
Post by jlzoasis on Feb 18, 2008 13:44:19 GMT -5
Well to give NOel a break it is a demo love the "come and make my world stand tall" lol But compared with Liam verison...it really does not stand up, Liam just rips Lyla apart, takes it to other level really..
|
|
|
|
Post by flashbax812 on Feb 21, 2008 23:44:12 GMT -5
I think Noel was experimenting with the falsetto vocal on this demo. Liam makes it what all great Oasis songs are, ballads sung with raw power.
|
|
|
|
Post by inspiredcarpet on Feb 22, 2008 2:46:49 GMT -5
Here's proof showing why Liams voice, even as bad as its gotten, is still much much needed
Noel's voice on this simply doesnt work as well Jesus man, you manage to slag off Noel AND Liam in one post..... good one  I always preferred the Noel-sung demo version, actually   |
|
|
|
Post by boywiththeshoes on Feb 22, 2008 11:31:04 GMT -5
Jesus man, you manage to slag off Noel AND Liam in one post..... good one Inspiredcarpet, you really defend Noel to the hilt. You must be Noel's number 1 fan, I'm not taking the piss or anything, it's just unusual for someone to be that devoted. Are you the same Inspiredcarpet from inet??? |
|
|
|
Post by inspiredcarpet on Feb 22, 2008 13:13:24 GMT -5
Jesus man, you manage to slag off Noel AND Liam in one post..... good one Inspiredcarpet, you really defend Noel to the hilt. You must be Noel's number 1 fan, I'm not taking the piss or anything, it's just unusual for someone to be that devoted. Are you the same Inspiredcarpet from inet??? Yeah, I use the same username on there and yeah, I am a pretty big NoelG fan |
|
|
|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Feb 22, 2008 13:26:41 GMT -5
Here's proof showing why Liams voice, even as bad as its gotten, is still much much needed
Noel's voice on this simply doesnt work as well Jesus man, you manage to slag off Noel AND Liam in one post..... good one haha, didnt mean to slag either off. Noel sounds fine on the Lyla demo, but Liam sounds better. As people have already said, this tune is more rock and suites Liam, while Noel is best with the anthems. I always preferred the Noel-sung demo version, actually |
|
|
|
Post by inspiredcarpet on Feb 22, 2008 13:54:25 GMT -5
haha, didnt mean to slag either off. Noel sounds fine on the Lyla demo, but Liam sounds better. As people have already said, this tune is more rock and suites Liam, while Noel is best with the anthems. I love Liam's singing on Lyla, both the recorded and various live performances (in particular, this one: ) but I still prefer Noel's voice. To be honest, I have yet to hear a Noel-penned song that he DOESNT sing better, but that's to be expected- they are his words, his meanings and he is the only person in the world he knows how to sing them properly. |
|
|
|
Post by jlzoasis on Feb 22, 2008 14:00:33 GMT -5
haha, didnt mean to slag either off. Noel sounds fine on the Lyla demo, but Liam sounds better. As people have already said, this tune is more rock and suites Liam, while Noel is best with the anthems. I love Liam's singing on Lyla, both the recorded and various live performances (in particular, this one: ) but I still prefer Noel's voice. To be honest, I have yet to hear a Noel-penned song that he DOESNT sing better, but that's to be expected- they are his words, his meanings and he is the only person in the world he knows how to sing them properly. with all due respect for your love for Noel, but Noel is here because of Liam and Liam is here because Noel, there really isn't any question, if Peggy Gallagher stopped at two sons, Oasis would not be one of the biggest bands in the world. |
|
|
|
Post by inspiredcarpet on Feb 22, 2008 14:10:17 GMT -5
with all due respect for your love for Noel, but Noel is here because of Liam and Liam is here because Noel, there really isn't any question, if Peggy Gallagher stopped at two sons, Oasis would not be one of the biggest bands in the world. With all due respect back...... I never claimed anything different. I think Noel would have made it on his own, anyway, but it would have taken longer. I have massive, huge respect for Liam - he is fantastic and my second favourite artist of all-time. |
|
|
|
Post by jlzoasis on Feb 22, 2008 14:12:45 GMT -5
with all due respect for your love for Noel, but Noel is here because of Liam and Liam is here because Noel, there really isn't any question, if Peggy Gallagher stopped at two sons, Oasis would not be one of the biggest bands in the world. With all due respect back...... I never claimed anything different. I think Noel would have made it on his own, anyway, but it would have taken longer. I have massive, huge respect for Liam - he is fantastic and my second favourite artist of all-time. I understand, I just can't see one with out the other, they are jsut so good  |
|
|
|
Post by kenneth on Feb 22, 2008 19:00:38 GMT -5
To be honest, I have yet to hear a Noel-penned song that he DOESNT sing better, but that's to be expected- they are his words, his meanings and he is the only person in the world he knows how to sing them properly. Come on, mate. As much as I love Noel, I don't agree with that. You honestly think songs like Gas Panic!, Go Let It Out and Stop Crying Your Heart out sounds better with Noel on vox? |
|
|
|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Feb 22, 2008 19:06:02 GMT -5
Both Liam and Noel are equally important. Noel is the brains behind the band. And the best song writer, of course. And has the more conventional voice, which fits anthems and acoustic songs very well.
Liam is the image, attitude, and passion of the band. Along with his trademark sneering vocals that, as discussed above, fit perfectly with the songs he does sing.
I like Noel more because he's smarter and wittier. In his interviews he ALWAYS has something smart to say.
But for the sake of the band, both are needed.
|
|
|
|
Post by inspiredcarpet on Feb 22, 2008 19:33:35 GMT -5
To be honest, I have yet to hear a Noel-penned song that he DOESNT sing better, but that's to be expected- they are his words, his meanings and he is the only person in the world he knows how to sing them properly. Come on, mate. As much as I love Noel, I don't agree with that. You honestly think songs like Gas Panic!, Go Let It Out and Stop Crying Your Heart out sounds better with Noel on vox? Yeah, I prefer the Noel-sung versions of these songs, in particular Gas Panic & SCYHO. |
|
|
|
Post by caro on Feb 23, 2008 8:36:17 GMT -5
I agree with live4evr and jenny... Lyla is much better when Liam sings it! As i said in some other thread, I think there are songs for Liam to sing and others for Noel to sing And yeah both Liam and Noel are needed It wouldn't be Oasis without them, they are complementary and each brings something unique to the band |
|
|
|
Post by calioasis on Feb 27, 2008 18:08:49 GMT -5
Noel sung versions of the rock songs, they just sound so limp. He has zero snarl and zero edge in his voice. I mean I love the guy, but it is way more suited to a ballad like don't look back in anger. When he sings with the full band, it's just not there. NO EDGE
|
|
|
|
Post by inspiredcarpet on Feb 27, 2008 19:18:49 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by moonchild on Feb 28, 2008 6:25:42 GMT -5
Here's proof showing why Liams voice, even as bad as its gotten, is still much much needed Noel's voice on this simply doesnt work as well Yes, Liam can't sing DM songs anymore... Yes, it has been so for over a decade already (listen to live versions on BHN singles, and it's been over a decade ago). But he's still the MAN (one of them), and sings good on recent records. |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5