twice
Madferrit Fan
Posts: 61
|
Post by twice on Jun 20, 2005 6:37:54 GMT -5
Classic songs prove Oasis can live forever
June 20, 2005
BY BRIAN McCOLLUM FREE PRESS POP MUSIC CRITIC
Even in the thick of Oasis mania, amid the mid-'90s barrage of smash songs and glass-shattering hype, you couldn't help but wonder what sort of future awaited the British band leaders.
Oasis With Jet and Nic Armstrong & the Thieves Saturday
Meadow Brook Music Festival
THREE STARS out of four stars
With their jumbo egos, taunting of rock peers and super-sized boasts ("If the Beatles were here now, they'd be Oasis," went a typical proclamation), it seemed inevitable that fate, and the fickle trends of pop, would someday deliver a smackdown.
Saturday night was Detroit's chance to see just what a decade's worth of destiny has done with brothers Noel and Liam Gallagher. At a sold-out Meadow Brook Music Festival, what we learned was reassuring: A band that once appeared bent on self-destruction has found a way to survive and thrive, settling into a healthy, respectable place on the rock scene and allowing its music to do all the talking.
Good thing, too. As confirmed by Saturday's 95-minute performance, the older material has aged remarkably well, and it didn't hurt that it was given deserved respect by the Gallagher brothers, who were accompanied by four players including new drummer Zak Starkey. Songs like "Cigarettes and Alcohol," "Rock 'N' Roll Star" and "Wonderwall" -- perhaps as close to a "Stairway to Heaven" the '90s generation ever got -- were performed straight but with passion, featuring especially inspired guitar work by Noel Gallagher.
It was one in a series of considerate gestures to the crowd of 7,700, a high-spirited audience of 20- and 30-somethings who eagerly sang along. While Oasis' listless stage demeanor hasn't changed much -- Liam Gallagher, clad in all black and sunglasses, was reliably stock-still at the microphone -- it has a new vibe. Saturday night, it was a purposeful purposelessness, less of a cold shoulder than a good-natured nod to ritual. "Don't Look Back in Anger," one of the most perfectly constructed pop songs of the past two decades, highlighted a four-song encore that stood out if only because Oasis once brazenly spurned that concert tradition.
The band was particularly engaged with material from the recently released "Don't Believe the Truth," which provided seven of the show's 18 songs and comprised the entire opening stretch. The new music held its own in a well-paced set that picked up energy and emotional steam as it moved along, with the tense urgency of "Mucky Fingers" and the anthem-like "Lyla" atop the list.
Oasis has unquestionably matured -- Noel Gallagher was 21 when he wrote the soaring "Live Forever." But at Meadow Brook on Saturday night, the unabashed optimism of that song and many others remained intact. When it comes down to it, that's the trait in the band's arsenal that has allowed it to triumph over the bluster of its early days. The band's closing cover of "My Generation" was apt: Like its heroes the Who, it's clear that Oasis has found a way to hold on to youthful hope even as it grows up.
|
|
|
Post by Guess God Thinks I'm Cain on Jun 20, 2005 8:07:25 GMT -5
Detroit, I always knew you had it in you ;D
|
|
|
Post by zunoasis on Jun 20, 2005 8:15:24 GMT -5
great review, and not from some no-name independent newspaper either!
|
|
|
Post by giggergrl on Jun 20, 2005 8:19:02 GMT -5
This review get's Tam's "seal of approval !" Loved the comments about Liam's demeanor... F-ing A right ! BTW, I will play you oasis tunes in 20 years and they will not sound dated trust me - they are timeless !
|
|
|
Post by jimmypage on Jun 20, 2005 11:07:19 GMT -5
The gig was amazing, the best Oasis gig that I've been to! Every song was a classic, and the venue was superb, dont think I'll get a chance to see the band in such a small venue ever again at home. The crowd went wild for Gem's harmonica solo, and then again when Liam went over to Noel and hugged him as Noel played his solo in Love Forever. I'll try and post some pics when I get back to England.
My favs of the night were Lyla, Mucky Fingers, Cigarettes and Alcohol adn My Generation. And Zak Starkey was incredible, such an energetic performer.
|
|
|
Post by giggergrl on Jun 20, 2005 13:28:50 GMT -5
JP, hello What ? Liam hugged Noel on stage ? I never heard of this ? thanks for your post , be well, safe trip back my lad. Tam
|
|
|
Post by calioasis on Jun 20, 2005 21:19:31 GMT -5
You know that is true, the songs really do hold up. When they bust out rock and roll star or Live Forever it sounds as fresh as ever. Timeless. Just like the great acts of the 60s and 70s. I mean you hear Zeppelin on the radio and it sounds like it could have been recorded today. Standing on the Shoulder of Giants and maybe some of be here now are the only albums that haven't aged that well, in my opinion. Good review!
|
|
|
Post by jimmypage on Jun 21, 2005 12:31:33 GMT -5
yeah, i was just filming a bit on my digital camera, when my mate tells me to look to the stage, the crowd went wild and i see liam standing behind noel with his arm around him, whilst waving his tambourine at the crowd, great moment
|
|
|
Post by PolskaBro1824 on Jun 21, 2005 14:17:48 GMT -5
Since we're talking about the Detroit Free Press I guess I'll let you guys know that they have written a few articles praising the boys recently. Being from Detroit I read them so I will post them for you right now...
Cheers
|
|
|
Post by PolskaBro1824 on Jun 21, 2005 14:18:40 GMT -5
Their ALBUM REVIEW (06/12/05)
Oasis -- "Don't Believe the Truth" (Columbia) ***
If you believed the truth, based on the evidence of its past three discs, Oasis was a spent force, surviving on snarky publicity and fumes from the group's first two albums, released about a decade ago. But this is the fact: "Don't Believe the Truth" is the first completely successful collection since the band's glory days, featuring songs with actual melodies that can actually be heard, thanks to the considerable tear-down of that fuzz wall of sound. (Of course, it also means we can better hear the lyrics, which are only slightly less cringe-inducing than usual.)
Sure, the songs still sound on the shoulder of giants: The catchy "Lyla" has singer Liam Gallagher channeling "Street Fighting Man"-era Jagger, and "Mucky Fingers" should give a cowriting credit to Velvet Underground-era Lou Reed. Yet the brothers Gallagher get a real goose from the songwriting contributions of Gem Archer. The straight-ahead timekeeping of new drummer Zak Starkey may be the best Beatleism they've ever adopted. And with "Let There Be Love," the group finally has a ballad to equal "Wonderwall."
|
|
|
Post by PolskaBro1824 on Jun 21, 2005 14:21:57 GMT -5
Here's a rather lengthy article...
OASIS, ALL GROWN UP: Britpop superstars still conjure the magic, minus anger, drugs and hype
June 17, 2005
BY BRIAN McCOLLUM FREE PRESS POP MUSIC WRITER
A kinder, gentler Oasis? An Oasis without the tabloid sideshows? An Oasis minus the bratty interviews and cocky bombast?
Well, yes. Kind of.
No fears -- the British quartet hasn't become Up With People. But today's Oasis is certainly a tempered version of the band that one decade ago earned a reputation both noteworthy and notorious, thanks to a double whammy of exemplary rock and offstage raucousness. Those were the whirlwind years, a swirl of hype and hits whose personal impact, says leader Noel Gallagher, is only now being properly absorbed by the band.
Now, as Oasis traverses America on a tour that will bring it to Meadow Brook Music Festival on Saturday night, the vibe is different. Where the Oasis story once played out in a very public way, band members' lives have been steadily tucked behind the scenes. There are wives, kids, domestic comforts -- and a new album that has been resuscitating the musical reputation of Gallagher and his brother Liam.
On the new "Don't Believe the Truth," released in May, "the new songs are better than the last set of songs," says Noel Gallagher in requisitely wry fashion. "In that sense, we've grown."
The emphasis, in other words, is back on the music, a move that has pleased Gallagher and those fans who feared that the creative abilities of Oasis had become a mirage. While the heady days of "Definitely Maybe" and "(What's the Story) Morning Glory" came with all sorts of amusing tabloid fodder, Gallagher says, they were also full of distractions -- drugs and alcohol not the least among them -- that caused subsequent work to suffer.
There are countless examples of the combustible, old-style Oasis approach -- enough to fill a book or even, as it turns out, a whole shelf of them. But you just have to look back to the band's first arena show in Detroit, in August 1996 at the Palace of Auburn Hills, for a handy reminder.
On top of the world With "Wonderwall" everywhere on the radio and "Morning Glory" scaling the album charts, Oasis headed to Michigan with vocalist Liam barely in tow. At the peak of Oasis mania, he'd suddenly threatened to quit, disappearing in London while the band opened its tour in Chicago. The younger Gallagher emerged and met up with his bandmates the afternoon of their Detroit gig -- a show that turned out drama-free, with the famously contentious brothers amiable together onstage.
It was the sort of antic that stoked the continuous media frenzy in England while spurring onlookers to question just where the line sat between reality and PR. But whether genuine or forced, or some mix of both, it kept Oasis in the headlines, and kept records moving.
Noel Gallagher, Oasis' chief songwriter and frequent voice of reason, says it wasn't until years later that he was able to put the era into perspective.
"I'm only looking back on that period now. People are still talking about '95 and '96 -- two years," he says. "When I look back, I think, 'What an amazing time.' Back then, you're too close to it."
Gallagher concedes the dramas came with a price.
"At the time, I thought it was quite embarrassing," he says. "Now, looking back, I'm kind of relieved it didn't overshadow the music, which is kind of cool. If I have one regret, it's that we should have taken two years off after 'Morning Glory' instead of going right back into the studio and the madness."
The result was "Be Here Now," a mixed-bag album that launched an erratic creative stretch for Oasis and invited snickers from naysayers.
Older and wiser Gallagher, who used to unflinchingly proclaim Oasis to be the universe's best band, has adopted a stance more suited for the world of 2005. With the critical and commercial success of "Truth," which debuted at No. 12 on Billboard's U.S. chart, it's clear he feels grateful to have survived not only the public's volatile tastes, but his group's own high-profile follies.
The album is carried by some of the most accomplished songwriting of Gallagher's career. And though it's typically derivative -- with inevitable swipes from the Stones, Beatles and Kinks -- it's also refreshingly Oasis, at times evoking the ebullient, soaring feel that had been missing for several years.
Gallagher is proud that the record sounds relevant, recapturing the vibrance of earlier Oasis work while brimming with a sense of immediacy.
"I think that once a new generation comes along, it's difficult for bands like us from previous generations to carry on," says Gallagher, 38.
Music's tectonic plates have shifted considerably since Oasis stormed onto the British landscape in 1994, triumphed in America the next year, and inserted the term "Britpop" into the musical lexicon. Most significantly, rock has seen its position eroded, its cultural currency grabbed up by hip-hop and dance-pop music. In the U.K. press, the pages once dominated by the brothers Gallagher are now occupied by the likes of Kylie Minogue and Justin Timberlake.
"That's the challenge for us -- to keep a level of interest so that the albums aren't just advertisements for the tours," says Gallagher. "Our albums still matter. I don't mean that in the scheme of 'It's gonna change music.' I mean that when somebody buys a new Rolling Stones album, they don't give a (damn) -- they just want to see them on tour. When people buy our records, it still means something."
Onstage, where Gallagher says "it's all starting to come together," there have been some tweaks: "We've reintroduced 'Wonderwall,' which we never used to play, because we finally found the right speed and it sounds great. The older songs that we've ditched? There's lots of stuff we don't play, but we only have an hour and 40 minutes. Liam's not the kind of guy you can spring a song on before you go out, because he freaks out."
With the recent addition of drummer Zak Starkey -- son of Richard Starkey, also known as Ringo Starr -- the Gallaghers have secured a direct line to the band whose music, more than any other, has inspired Oasis over the years. Inspiration, some Beatles fans contend, that has often lapsed into a license to borrow and steal.
Noel Gallagher can still whip out the snark, dumping on modern hip-hop ("very sinister, should be stopped"), the White Stripes' live show ("OK, I get the point, now go get a bass player") and his brother ("he still doesn't know the words to 'Supersonic.' "). But he'll never dis the group that he readily admits fueled the Oasis fire.
"I don't listen to the Beatles as obsessively as I used to when I was a kid. Back then I knew every single note inside out," he says. "But I still, to this day, can put on 'I Am the Walrus' and go, 'How did they do that?!' It's still magic to me."
|
|
|
Post by britishlove on Jun 21, 2005 14:40:17 GMT -5
Detroit, I always knew you had it in you ;D Of course we do. Great gig...great review.
|
|