i haven't heard the demo at all? can you send it over via aim or ftp...?

Noels' voice can do that though Even his awful Some Might Say electric demo grew on me after I listened to it enough!

file isn't available at that link...

I really don't like this version

It doesn't sound to good at all in my eyes, noel just doesn't sound right over this type of track.
He's more suited to acoustic sounding tracks(TIOBI) cos his voice is to soft for the more rocking tunes, It sounds so much better with liam singing it, Just listen to both versions choruses there ain't a comparison liams has far more edge to it.
Still a collectable though, any b'sides rarities etc...im gonna get.

Cheers

doggboy

Yeah Liams 'Lyla' sounds fucking boss. I was really disappointed about the demo 'cause apart from Noel singing it, sounds identical to the actual single , and while i'm on it why don't they put the Lyla video on the DVD, they put a video on 'Who Feels Love?' and that was just an ordinary single.

Like someone else said, I was most disapointed to hear that the only main difference between the demo and the recorded version was the fact that Noel was singing it.

I'd much rather have heard Noels original Acoustic demo, I imagine it would have sounded better, like the Stop Crying Your Heart Out demo. But whatever, maybe they did it so people would stop bitching about Liams voice for a change and realise that he is in fact better than Noel sometimes.