|
Post by DixonHill on Apr 29, 2005 10:44:08 GMT -5
from another forum
Q Review ****
Google for an oasis discography online and you'll find some website ediotrs can't be bothered displaying their albums after 1997's Be Here Now. Too many fans will know the feeling. In the wake of WTSMG, experiencing new oasis albums has been akin to having a one night stand with an old flame - seductive words, excitement and high hopes swiftly giving way to disillusionment, embarrassment and disappointment. In 2005 with guitar bads ruling the charts, there's a theory that we don't need the Gallaghers anymore. Consequently no oasis album has arrived with less fanfare, hype or expectation than DBTT.
It's no secret that DBTT has had a difficult birth. Three weeks of DIV recordings were scrapped, Noel candidly acknowledging they 'didn't have the songs'. Indeed 50 songs were scrapped and the quartet (with guest drummer Zak and producer Dave Sardy) resumed recording. Listening to the 11 songs that made the grade, the consequences of this are obvious: this is oasis' most focussed, reflective and relaxed album to date.
Though Noel Gallagher has penned less than half the tracks (for the first time all four members have contributed..WRONG FUCKERS) his songs - ringing with contentment with the world and his place in it - dominate the album. Track two, MF, written one imagines with memories of a particularly messy night at Supernova heights in mind, finds noel looking in the mirror and recoiling at the reflection. "Fed up with life in the city becuase all the phoneys have blown my mind" he sighs to a backing track like The velvet undergorudn's waiting for the man
Noel takes lead vocals twice more - Kink's inspired TIOBI and blissed out paean to big city anominity POTQ, the latter recalling both Liverpudlians Shack and The Stranglers' Golden Brown, one of the finest songs he's penned this decade. he also trades lyrics with Liam on album closer LTBL, which all orchestral swells and images of a world 'come undone at the seems' will doubtless accompany slow motion footage of Wayne Rooney trooping from a German football pitch at the point of England's early exit from the World Cup. The album's finest moment is Lyla which combines melodies borrowed from Street Fighting Man, piano and a humble lyric to a soulful, upbeat tune.
Optimism and humility also pervade Liam's contributions: LLAB and GGTIA call to mind lazy summer evenings spent with family members and an acoustic guitar, with TMOS sounds like a jam with friends in a pub backroom. None of the three threaten to eclipse big brother's contributions, but they're further indications of Liam's burgeoning compositional skills and his increasing unwillingness to play up to 'Wild Man' cliches. with the Gallagher boys mooching around happily then, it's left to Andy and Gem to supply the swagger - Andy chipping in with BRMC-flavoured opener TUTS and the psychedelic KTDA and Gem revisiting the Beatles' songbook for ABWR, debuted at Glasto.
If definitely maybe was the distillation of mid-90s lad culture, then DBTT can be viewed as oasis' new man album, a record where they're finally acting their ages. The gallaghers sound more comfortable then ever in their skins. Too often over the years, you'll have heard that OAsis have recaptured their muse. This time believe it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 29, 2005 10:51:56 GMT -5
wow,thats a good review
|
|
Berny
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 432
|
Post by Berny on Apr 29, 2005 11:06:48 GMT -5
Though Noel Gallagher has penned less than half the tracks (for the first time all four members have contributed..WRONG FUCKERS) Maybe it means it's the first time the whole badn has written a song for the album ie. Alan didn't last time.
|
|
steveo1980
Oasis Roadie
Growing old is inevitable...Growing up is Optional
Posts: 397
|
Post by steveo1980 on Apr 29, 2005 11:07:12 GMT -5
Hmmmm intresting you sure thats an offical Q review the above statement seems to contradict every other review ive seen like Still Another Good review all the same
|
|
|
Post by belfastdon on Apr 29, 2005 11:19:24 GMT -5
finest moment is Lyla
after hearing all the songs now(including the clips),i'd have to agree there. though mucky fingers is growing on me and i would like to hear the full version of turn up the sun.
now didnt noel say that lyla was about 5th best song? i suspose it's just down to taste really,but at this moment i dont really like what i heard bar about 3 songs,but hopefully the album will grow on me,all the others have and i fuckin love them
|
|
|
Post by Noel Westerberg on Apr 29, 2005 11:29:30 GMT -5
It's always great to see them getting really good reviews, but the whole "maturity" references always throw up some red flags to me. They said that about SOTSOG and although I think it was a great album, I really think "mature" in a lot of reviews is code for kind of boring. I hope not as I've really loved the clips to TUTS, TIOBI, and POTQ. I'm sure most of you have listened to most of the full tracks, and have a better idea, I"m trying to wait for the album to come out. I'm sure it'll be great
|
|
|
Post by antsan80 on Apr 29, 2005 11:34:39 GMT -5
IMHO Lyla is the worst song in the album by far.
|
|
|
Post by LIVERPUDLIAN on Apr 29, 2005 11:46:51 GMT -5
Excellent review, same number of stars as they gave HTDAAB and that magazine LOVES U2, looking promising!
|
|
|
Post by mattgoat on Apr 29, 2005 13:43:12 GMT -5
Is a good review. Pleased about that...although theyre not treated god-like enough for me.
|
|
IndianSummer
Oasis Roadie
"Music, it sticks around you until the day you die"
Posts: 142
|
Post by IndianSummer on Apr 29, 2005 13:57:44 GMT -5
It's a moderate review, it's kinda low, not full of enthousiasm. But ofcourse we are the once to be excited by Oasis, because we love them. And most of the people don't. This is by far the baddest review I read so far, and that's good. Why? Because even this 'low' review is kinda positive. Still, I'm taken it not to serious, let's judge the album by myself.
|
|
|
Post by Rock N' Roll Dad on Apr 29, 2005 14:13:23 GMT -5
It's a moderate review, it's kinda low, not full of enthousiasm. But ofcourse we are the once to be excited by Oasis, because we love them. And most of the people don't. This is by far the baddest review I read so far, and that's good. Why? Because even this 'low' review is kinda positive. Still, I'm taken it not to serious, let's judge the album by myself. The worst review was the one in the Times a few weeks back - and the critic ripped the album but it was clear they really hadn't heard it. I do agree though and while I don't rely on critics, it is nice to see our band recieveing recognition on a large scale - reenforcing what we all knew all along.
|
|
|
Post by belfastdon on Apr 29, 2005 14:27:47 GMT -5
Excellent review, same number of stars as they gave HTDAAB and that magazine LOVES U2, looking promising! and thats pretty shit by U2 standards
|
|