|
|
Post by SlideAway on Mar 4, 2005 0:38:47 GMT -5
Morning Glory's great. But just imagine if they'd switched some of what went onto the b-sides and what went onto the album. Just imagine that THIS was Morning Glory. There'd be no dispute as to what was their best album, IMO.
(What's the Story) Morning Glory
1. Acquiesce - an album opener almost as perfect as Rock n' Roll Star
2. Round Are Way - Should have at least made The Masterplan. I love Roll With It but Round Are Way is better. Had THIS gone up against Country House it would have won.
3. Wonderwall
4. Don't Look Back in Anger
5. Underneath the Sky - Nice change of pace, different sound, doesn't drag like Hey Now
6. [instrumental]
7. Some Might Say
8. The Masterplan - Epic #1. Maybe sung by Liam.
9. Rockin' Chair - Another nice change of pace. Minor key with one of Liam's best vocals. An understated almost all acoustic song.
10. Morning Glory
11. [instrumental]
12. Champagne Supernova
The songs I left off would be b-sides: Hello, Hey Now (maybe 2 minutes shorter), Cast No Shadow, Roll With It, She's Electric.
What do you guys think?
*NOTE: On Edit, switched the order of "Rockin' Chair" and "The Masterplan" on a second thought.
|
|
|
|
Post by flashbax812 on Mar 4, 2005 0:49:25 GMT -5
Yeah that would have been mind blowing.
---I would replace round are way with cast no shadow though.
|
|
|
|
Post by wanker80 on Mar 4, 2005 2:26:36 GMT -5
Where is She's Electric?
|
|
|
|
Post by LIVERPUDLIAN on Mar 4, 2005 2:43:57 GMT -5
I'm not a huge fan of the song, but you can't have WTSMG without She's Electric, its one of the defining tracks of the album IMO.
|
|
|
|
Post by holdonecho on Mar 4, 2005 2:46:22 GMT -5
hey if you figure that stand by me and don't go away were both written in the wtsmg era imagine if they had been included...
cd 1
hello
roll with it
stand by me
dlbia
hey now
swamp song fragment
cast no shadow
some might say
morning glory no 1 (acoustic-cause i always loved when noel did this one alone)
swamp song fragment
champagne supernova
cd 2
wonderwall fragment
acquiese
morning glory fragment
morning glory
wonderwall
don't go away
she's electric
round are way
talk tonight
underneath the sky
masterplan
b sides
boneheads holiday
rockin chair
head shrinker
step out
its better people
cum on feel the noise
swamp song full version
you've got to hide your love away
a serious contender for the greatest double album in the history of rock!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by SlideAway on Mar 4, 2005 2:46:42 GMT -5
Well, I suppose you could have another track on there  I mean - the album was originally supposed to have 11 songs not 10 but "Step Out" had to be cut. I still prefer my lineup with She's Electric as a b-side. But I guess if you prefer... 1. Acquiesce 2. Round Are Way 3. Wonderwall 4. Don't Look Back in Anger 5. Underneath the Sky 6. 7. Some Might Say 8. She's Electric 9. Rockin' Chair 10. The Masterplan 11. Morning Glory 12. 13. Champagne Supernova |
|
|
|
Post by RnRstar on Mar 4, 2005 5:05:41 GMT -5
I still prefer my lineup with She's Electric as a b-side. But I guess if you prefer... 1. Acquiesce 2. Round Are Way 3. Wonderwall 4. Don't Look Back in Anger 5. Underneath the Sky 6. 7. Some Might Say 8. She's Electric 9. Rockin' Chair 10. The Masterplan 11. Morning Glory 12. 13. Champagne Supernova Some might say is a good tune... but better than cast no shadow? now theres something  |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 4, 2005 6:47:35 GMT -5
it may sound a bit old but "if it aint broke dont fix it"
your version sounds good enough but the THE CHEIF i think had the right idea with the track list and songs on WTSMG and i aint about to disagree with his choices especially in that era when he could do know wrong...JMO
|
|
|
|
Post by maketradefair on Mar 4, 2005 8:52:12 GMT -5
you need to have CNS. its a brilliant song.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 4, 2005 10:28:23 GMT -5
you need to have CNS. its a brilliant song. absolutley... its a staple of the lp |
|
|
|
Post by thepicturesgeneration on Mar 4, 2005 16:34:49 GMT -5
I would actually do out with the swamp song (the untitled instrumental), completely. It basically serves no point IMO, and when I listen to the CD i always skip it, even if I'm in that "listen to the album completely through" mode.
here's mine...could be called what's the story masterplan.
1. Acquiesce
2. Roll With it
3. Round Are Way (EDITED VERSION)
4. Wonderwall
5. Don't look Back in Anger
(Morning glory acoustic segment)
6. Some might Say
7. Cast No Shadow
8. She's Electric
9. Morning Glory
10. Champagne Supernova (EDITED VERSION)
11. Masterplan
Maybe underneath the sky or whatever thrown in...I like my version because it's packed with ALL good songs. Weak link would be round are way, cast no shadow and some might say, but otherwise they are all singles/singles candidates, and a powerful album.
Not too long either. I have a very short attention span (not necessarily bad for a songwriter).
|
|
|
|
Post by Clint on Mar 4, 2005 17:57:32 GMT -5
Bonehead's Bank Holiday should have been on all versions. It's such a good tune.
|
|
|
|
Post by LIVERPUDLIAN on Mar 5, 2005 8:05:02 GMT -5
"10. Champagne Supernova (EDITED VERSION)"
No way, every second of the 7mins 27 seconds of that song is awesome for me, any shorter and it loses its effect for me, I've heard the radio edit a good few times and it loses something!
|
|
|
|
Post by iamthewalrus on Mar 5, 2005 12:40:11 GMT -5
you need to have CNS. its a brilliant song. Couldn't agree more...the only thing i'd change is adding aquiesce but not taking any songs out |
|
|
|
Post by Poshbird05 on Mar 5, 2005 17:44:58 GMT -5
you all have great ideas but I honestly think that if they had done everything you're saying we all would have died in an orgasmic state after hearing it. And that would be no good because we wouldn't be able to here any more of their later stuff.
All though I do like the idea of a double disk.
|
|
|
|
Post by jobero on Mar 6, 2005 14:39:56 GMT -5
Morning Glory's great. But just imagine if they'd switched some of what went onto the b-sides and what went onto the album. Just imagine that THIS was Morning Glory. There'd be no dispute as to what was their best album, IMO. (What's the Story) Morning Glory 1. Acquiesce - an album opener almost as perfect as Rock n' Roll Star 2. Round Are Way - Should have at least made The Masterplan. I love Roll With It but Round Are Way is better. Had THIS gone up against Country House it would have won. 3. Wonderwall4. Don't Look Back in Anger5. Underneath the Sky - Nice change of pace, different sound, doesn't drag like Hey Now 6. [instrumental] 7. Some Might Say8. The Masterplan - Epic #1. Maybe sung by Liam. 9. Rockin' Chair - Another nice change of pace. Minor key with one of Liam's best vocals. An understated almost all acoustic song. 10. Morning Glory11. [instrumental] 12. Champagne SupernovaThe songs I left off would be b-sides: Hello, Hey Now (maybe 2 minutes shorter), Cast No Shadow, Roll With It, She's Electric. What do you guys think? *NOTE: On Edit, switched the order of "Rockin' Chair" and "The Masterplan" on a second thought. Some intresting points Slideaway but....(and you knew that was coming, lol) although i really like 'Hello' and think it is the best gig opener, i have to agree 'Acquiesce' would have been an amazing start to the album, instead of replacing 'Round Are Way' with 'Roll With It' i would have them both and dispose of 'She's Electric', although i do like SE and it was nice to hear Noel sing it on the Heathen Chemistry tour i think having like others have said R.A.W against Country House for 'the brit pop battle' would have been amazing as it just symbolises the difference between the Oasis & Blur and imo 'She's Electric' would better suit 'The Masterplan/B-side' compilation/album. The only thing i would possibly change is swapping 'Hey Now' with 'The Masterplan' although i would have had it later in the album. I don't think you can even think about binning 'Cast No Shadow' as that song is a real 'un-sung hero' of that album. Don't worry i'm not trying to say Noel was wrong as the album is brilliant (although D.Maybe is my real fave) just in hindsight maybe these changes could have mad it even bigger, NOW IMAGINE THAT!  |
|
Abbott
Madferrit Fan
Beatles/Bob Dylan/Led Zep/neil Young/Kinks/Rolling Stones/Jam/Smiths/Birds/who/Clash/David Bowie
Posts: 92
|
Post by Abbott on Mar 6, 2005 17:39:46 GMT -5
Cast no shadow is one of the manny highlites on yhis album it need to stay, although it could do with being a little shorter. I love it on the there and then vid.
|
|
|
|
Post by USOasis86 on Mar 6, 2005 20:30:16 GMT -5
Morning Glory's great. But just imagine if they'd switched some of what went onto the b-sides and what went onto the album. Just imagine that THIS was Morning Glory. There'd be no dispute as to what was their best album, IMO. (What's the Story) Morning Glory 1. Acquiesce - an album opener almost as perfect as Rock n' Roll Star 2. Round Are Way - Should have at least made The Masterplan. I love Roll With It but Round Are Way is better. Had THIS gone up against Country House it would have won. 3. Wonderwall4. Don't Look Back in Anger5. Underneath the Sky - Nice change of pace, different sound, doesn't drag like Hey Now 6. [instrumental] 7. Some Might Say8. The Masterplan - Epic #1. Maybe sung by Liam. 9. Rockin' Chair - Another nice change of pace. Minor key with one of Liam's best vocals. An understated almost all acoustic song. 10. Morning Glory11. [instrumental] 12. Champagne SupernovaThe songs I left off would be b-sides: Hello, Hey Now (maybe 2 minutes shorter), Cast No Shadow, Roll With It, She's Electric. What do you guys think? *NOTE: On Edit, switched the order of "Rockin' Chair" and "The Masterplan" on a second thought. That sounds like it would be instense |
|
|
|
Post by jayg on Mar 7, 2005 5:48:31 GMT -5
Yeah that would have been mind blowing. ---I would replace round are way with cast no shadow though. I agree...........cast no shadow has to be on Morning Glory.....it kinda captures the essence of the band at that time......and im not a huge fan of round are way |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5