yes

its a good topic and one that should keep being talked about , my point is that i dont think it is they are always just playing to loud over him so he has to belt these songs out instead of singing them , it may have something to do with zaks intense drumming style it makes the rest of the band feel the need to play really loud hence liam struggles to sing over that volume

^what? they are one of the best bands that put up great shows...

I'm very sorry because I adore Liam, but he's finished.
His voice is destroyed.
The last album with beautiful voice of Our Kid is Be here now. After it, the emptiness.

By The way Liam sounded great in Atlanta in '05. Now this was after a 5 day break b/c of a cancelled concert a few days before in Houston b/c of a hurricane.

No.

I thought (and I still think) Liam souded great whey they played "Within You Without You" a couple of months ago. To me he's still one of the greatest singers and the frontmen in the world.

Don't forget guys, he was 20, 21 when they recorded DM and now it's 13 years later. Voice is a living thing. It grows through the years and he's got the voice like a good wine.
D'yer know what I mean?

there is a documentary about oasis on youtube called "there we were...now here we are" consisting of bits taken from the interviews which were done for the definitely maybe dvd. and i remember liam saying something like singing was more like shouting in tune. oasis is just a very very loud band... 14 years of singing at that high volume have taken their toll on liams voice. however, he still sounds great on acoustic versions like the one he and gem played of guess god thinks im abel on the late show in 2005.
liam has a great voice, he will never lose it. the ability to sing at very high volume is the only thing he'll ever lose... and i dont mind anyway. i actually like his 'new' voice, you just have to get used to it. he's not 20 anymore

Everybody are good in studio.
I spoke about concerts. Last good times for Liam's voice has been in Be Here Now tour.

I totally agree. For people who don't have to sing for a living, sure, maybe their voices don't change as much. But for someone like him, who makes a living on belting out loud rock and roll songs for months straight at a time, the voice can change drastically. And everyone has different vocal attributes, so some singers' voices might be able to hold up longer whereas other singers' voices will struggle sooner.
Personally, being in a band of my own, I can hear a natural change in my voice from the recordings we had in 2005 compared to a few days ago. That's only two years, so imagine what it will sound like after a few more years. And I'm not even doing nearly as much vocal work as Liam.

I was just listening to some old gigs from 97/98 and he's really not singing too great in those as well. LIsten to Gmex 97 and he shouts his way through a lot of songs on that too.

I agree that there is something wrong with his voice, but now that i go back and listen to older bootlegs I realize that a lot of it depends on how hard he's really trying. If he tries hard and gives a damn, then he's ok, otherwise he is horrid these days.

I've seen some concerts from 2002 where Liam's voice was even better than it was when SOTSOG came out...and I realized why. Like some have said, he needs to SING, not scream. When he sings, he still has that Liam magic for lack of a better word. When he doesn't, he just sounds like an idiot grunting along to the music, although he never loses his swagger. You know Liam is at his best when he's accentuating the end of words (ex: shine= shiiiiine)...now the only time you hear that is on the ballads, particularly his...Love Like A Bomb, Guess God Thinks I'm Abel, Keep the Dream Alive (though I know it's Andy's song).

SING Liam, don't scream