yes, he's fine...just a small strain it has been a long tour so far

the more you read fan reviews, the more you realize the subjectivity. where ppl were sitting, their state of mind, if they were drunk. if they were big fans or casual fans. who they had sitting around them. etc.

i was in the front row one night, and liam could've been shit and it wouldn't have mattered. but if you're sober sitting in the back, it's totally different.

bottom line - knowing that the band is playing about every night, ppl shouldn't expect artistic perfection, especially when it comes to liam's vox. it's more about the experience of seeing the band in person - and hearing the songs we've played so many times in our cars, homes, etc. having those songs comes alive. it's a surreal experience - for the real fans. for casual fans, it's not so impressive, but i don't really concern myself with them anymore. i stopped trying to convert ppl long ago.

getting caught up in critiquing the shows kind of takes away the magic of the experience, unless the band is blatantly unprofessional, which, besides i think imola italy (liam walking off - think his voice died), hasn't happened, amazingly, on this tour, which is a huge credit to the boys (especially considering the adverse conditions of the some of the shows, especially here in the u.s.).

5-10 years ago, in several cases in the u.s., they might've melted down. but they've grown up, and are making a great go of it. i hope the tour is encouraging them to carry on. more specifically, i hope it's encouraged noel, since we already know the other 3 want oasis to continue until they croak.

every greta rockstars voice has changed, yes his voice has gotten a little worse over the 11 years, but its also totally different and still the best in rock. I'd rather hear liam than jagger