I already wrote an e-mail to the post kindly saying what a terrible job of objective reporting the person did and seemed to exclude quite a bit. Liam the jerk that goes in the crowd to hug fans, and tells us repeatedly what a great audience we are and how much the band appreciates us coming out. good lord..someone had an axe to grind.

I have never seen anything like that review. Liam was probably in the best mood he has ever been in. What was with the comment about Noel. He asked if the girl was crying because they were bad . Mean? Arrogant? WTF. It was a JOKE.

Tam don't hold back, tell us how you really feel lol

When you don't follow Oasis AT ALL and don't know anything about it, you write that kind of stuff. The writer is just flat ignorant. If you hate the band going in, DON'T REVIEW THE SHOW.

Oasis' real fans' "endured" what was great show I'm sure - and they were thrilled to be there, and knew what to expect. And anyone who knows anything about the band knows that RKid is, at least in my book, the nicer Gallagher (not that it matters). Noel is becoming a grumpy old man, by his own admission.

I still don't get tho why Noel is so obsessed with slagging his musical legacy, by ignoring BHN and recently mocking the lyrics of DLBIA, not to mention the Wonderwall thing in Balt (but Noel was apparently joking around on that one - much to the writer's bewilderment).

The only album Noel likes as a whole is DM (and DBTT at the moment of course), and the reason IMHO is because of the circumstances surrounding the recording of it. Once the boys got into the money, sex and drugs lifestyle, he decided everything else they did wasn't as good or important. When in actuality, you can certainly make a case that WTSMG was a better album than DM, and that there is plenty of great music on subsequent albums.

Noel now wants to be known as Bob Dylan, as an artist (although he denies that vehemently, but his actions speak volumes with DBTT). It reminds me a little of what Vedder did to Pearl Jam and what became of Radiohead - and they both quickly faded to anonymonity. They almost disdained their huge early commercial success, and retreated back into making "artistic" albums. For the record, I do really like DBTT. And it will endure, unlike HC and SOTSOG.

And to be fair, Oasis has many, many better songs than those bands ever had. Oasis is an irresistible force that no one, including Noel, can ever stop. And, shudder the thought, I could see them going on without him if it ever comes to that, which it might at some point. Hopefully I'm totally wrong, because most of my favorite Oasis songs are Noel's tunes.

I don't dislike Noel, I'm just getting tired of his negative attitude. Or maybe he seems more negative b/c Liam has been so cool on this tour, and seems to have become more positive on and off-stage.

I was at the show sitting left center row 3 , behind me in the left lodge about 3 rows up were about 20 deaf fans, Im not kidding ,there was a women standing in front of them, Signing the entire concert. she had a off blue light shining on her so it would not bother the other fans. A bell will ring was dedicated to them!

by the way,When Liam dedicated the song to them They went nuts!!!!!!!

That's the COOLEST thing I've heard the entire tour. Maybe eva.

If all the lazy, cynical journalists only knew about stuff like that. We know it, so why can't they?

Yeah !! I know someone who was there as well in the 3rd row, he was the guy with the sweater on if youy could recall. They had actually reserved the section for the deaf contingent of concert goers, and last minute they released the unsold portion to the general public, so he got a 3rd row seat the day before the concert. Is that what you did as well?

Mute people can feel the vibrations through their body too and thats why they love the music, they dont even need to hear it.

Good job on the interprator lady, if she could make out what Liam said for a full gig !!!

Especially if he goes mental and goes on one of his rants !!! Imagine signing what he says !!!

hey jenny S, yeah was gonna PM you luv !
maybe you shld type the moronic writer and tell him that he was totally misperceiving your beloved Noel ! he just does not get oasis.. that was mega when he said that to you about wonderwall !
is that gonna be a "special song " for you coming up ??

\

glad to see your drive from NYC was well worth the trip ! I have always wanted to make a sign, but never did.. next time defo !