|
|
Post by djlen74 on Sept 26, 2005 5:39:52 GMT -5
Isn't it time that they insert a couple of "new" tunes just to try them out. Since the beginning of the tour, they have dumped Love Like A Bomb, A Bell Will Ring, Stop Crying Your Heart Out, Little By Little, Songbird....  I had a nice conversation with kalas last nite over the phone and he told me that THEY HAVE NO BUSINESS NOT playing SCYHO live, and I agree... even if Liam's voice has been showing some wear and tear every nite recently (and most understandably so), PUT IT BACK IN THERE... most fans will be singing along and will be so pissed up by that point that I'm sure few will notice he isn't hitting the high notes. Don't get me wrong- - - I AM STILL KEYED UP FOR SI, however wouldn't it BE GREAT if they put in ONE NEW SONG, a Stand By Me, or Stop Crying Your Heart Out, or Who Feels Love, or KEEP THE DREAM ALIVE ANYTHING, that would get us talking all nite instead of the same old same old, and they continue to drop tunes off the setlist left and right... the only one to my knowledge that they have added since the start of the tour is Guess God Thinks I'm Abel. Are we even gonna get 90 MINUTES anymore? As kalas said, with the band now SEVEN ALBUMS DEEP (counting masterplan), what's so hard about adding ONE NEW SONG and giving us something fresh... I don't get it?!?  |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2005 7:26:21 GMT -5
its the problem i have with OASIS live  ..i love them but to be considered a great live act they gotta get a bit daring...the fact that all of us here can tell the person next to him or her at the gig next week what song is coming next just aint right... |
|
|
|
Post by novascotialad on Sept 26, 2005 7:53:44 GMT -5
i think it's been well documented that the band are well up for trying some new material. the problem lies with liam... if he can't remember the words to Fade Away then what's the point to play it ?
and the boss also said that if he was a fan of a band and went to see them live, just to find out that they had played his fav song the night before but not that night, well he'd be pissed off.
i can see his point.... a lot of us have seen the band live multiple times. so we might not get too flustered if the show the night before had SCYHO. but there are many who only get one chance at it....
according to noel, on the oasisnet webcast that took place before the tour started, we were supposed to be getting some cracking b sides from 95/96.... (ie. fade away, headshrinker, etc) apparantly liam couldn't be arsed to learn the lyrics.... this is definately liam's band.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2005 7:57:24 GMT -5
i think it's been well documented that the band are well up for trying some new material. the problem lies with liam... if he can't remember the words to Fade Away then what's the point to play it ? and the boss also said that if he was a fan of a band and went to see them live, just to find out that they had played his fav song the night before but not that night, well he'd be pissed off. i can see his point.... a lot of us have seen the band live multiple times. so we might not get too flustered if the show the night before had SCYHO. but there are many who only get one chance at it.... according to noel, on the oasisnet webcast that took place before the tour started, we were supposed to be getting some cracking b sides from 95/96.... (ie. fade away, headshrinker, etc) apparantly liam couldn't be arsed to learn the lyrics.... this is definately liam's band. noels point is RUBBISH ANY PERSON IN A BAND WILL TELL YOU HOW BORING IT IS TO PLAY THE SAME SET OVER AND OVER if the reason they cant be changing up a bit is cause of LIAM not knowing words ,he is not the front man i thought he was ...plant ,jagger,daltrey,can all party yet still remember THERE SONGS ...thats just sad |
|
|
|
Post by novascotialad on Sept 26, 2005 9:17:56 GMT -5
as sad as it may be i think its true... noel has said liam's memory is absolutely horrible.
i know that you're right Kalas, no band would want to play the SAME set Every night.... it's gotta be liam.
|
|
|
|
Post by mancityblues on Sept 26, 2005 12:34:22 GMT -5
noel has also said that it's unfair to play different setlists on a tour for the fans who only see one show. but i think you guys are right about liam. but, liam's got the words taped to his monitor, so why should that be an issue?
|
|
|
|
Post by djlen74 on Sept 26, 2005 14:45:54 GMT -5
i think it's been well documented that the band are well up for trying some new material. the problem lies with liam... if he can't remember the words to Fade Away then what's the point to play it ? and the boss also said that if he was a fan of a band and went to see them live, just to find out that they had played his fav song the night before but not that night, well he'd be pissed off. i can see his point.... a lot of us have seen the band live multiple times. so we might not get too flustered if the show the night before had SCYHO. but there are many who only get one chance at it.... according to noel, on the oasisnet webcast that took place before the tour started, we were supposed to be getting some cracking b sides from 95/96.... (ie. fade away, headshrinker, etc) apparantly liam couldn't be arsed to learn the lyrics.... this is definately liam's band. Mhhhhh see you just made my point (and I do agree with you). Think of how shitty some poor 21 year old kid who has waited all his life to see Oasis stateside is gonna feel in five days at SI when he finds out that in 20-25 other markets they played LLAB, SB, LBL, ABWR for them but NOT FOR HIM, HOW'S HE GONNA FEEL |
|
|
|
Post by djlen74 on Sept 26, 2005 14:56:21 GMT -5
And BTW, MAKE NO MISTAKE, Oasis is the GREATEST BAND IN THE WORLD, they will always be #1 in my book... I'm just saying, even if Liam's voice is tired, his brain is FRIED, then so be it... Noel: ONE SONG, that's all I'm asking for is ONE SONG to make me shit my pants at SI... Step Out, Idler's Dream, Heart Of A Star, Where Did It All Go Wrong, ANYTHING... Idler's Dream would take only TWO MINUTES to play, but it would be the most powerful thing they could play all nite... in the crisp, chilly Autumn NY air, spotlight on Noel and The Shroud, Noel singing "And as I close my eyes and the sky turns red I realise just what you are"... CAN YOU JUST IMAGINE THAT MAN
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2005 14:56:58 GMT -5
i think it's been well documented that the band are well up for trying some new material. the problem lies with liam... if he can't remember the words to Fade Away then what's the point to play it ? and the boss also said that if he was a fan of a band and went to see them live, just to find out that they had played his fav song the night before but not that night, well he'd be pissed off. i can see his point.... a lot of us have seen the band live multiple times. so we might not get too flustered if the show the night before had SCYHO. but there are many who only get one chance at it.... according to noel, on the oasisnet webcast that took place before the tour started, we were supposed to be getting some cracking b sides from 95/96.... (ie. fade away, headshrinker, etc) apparantly liam couldn't be arsed to learn the lyrics.... this is definately liam's band. Mhhhhh then if that is correct (and I do agree with you) then think of how shitty some poor 21 year old kid who has waited all his life to see Oasis stateside is gonna feel in five days at SI when he finds out that in 20-25 other markets they played LLAB, SB, LBL, ABWR for them but NOT FOR HIM, HOW'S HE GONNA FEEL being in music industry len you know what i mean....you get bored playing the same tunes night in and night out..its why great live bands like BRUCE PEARL JAM DAVE MATHEWS THE DEAD . HAVE SUCH A GREAT FOLLOWING ON ANY GIVEN NIGHT U CAN HEAR SOMETHING DIFFERENT ..I HAVE SEEN OASIS OVER 20 TIMES ..I LOVE THEM ..BUT LIVE THEY DO NOT EVER SUPRISE ME AND WITH A CATALOUGE AS BIG AS THERES ITS A PITY |
|
|
|
Post by djlen74 on Sept 26, 2005 14:59:08 GMT -5
Mhhhhh then if that is correct (and I do agree with you) then think of how shitty some poor 21 year old kid who has waited all his life to see Oasis stateside is gonna feel in five days at SI when he finds out that in 20-25 other markets they played LLAB, SB, LBL, ABWR for them but NOT FOR HIM, HOW'S HE GONNA FEEL being in music industry len you know what i mean....you get bored playing the same tunes night in and night out..its why great live bands like BRUCE PEARL JAM DAVE MATHEWS THE DEAD . HAVE SUCH A GREAT FOLLOWING ON ANY GIVEN NIGHT U CAN HEAR SOMETHING DIFFERENT ..I HAVE SEEN OASIS OVER 20 TIMES ..I LOVE THEM ..BUT LIVE THEY DO NOT EVER SUPRISE ME AND WITH A CATALOUGE AS BIG AS THERES ITS A PITY TRUE THAT |
|
|
|
Post by calioasis on Sept 26, 2005 16:13:07 GMT -5
I was in Vegas and I kept telling a guy behind me what they were going to play next (he was asking) . When the encore was, etc. I would have gone NUTS if they played supersonic, step out, or something. They were playing headshrinker for a few gigs. Noel himself could sing a couple more. I mean he says he's bored playing meaning of soul and such, switch it up a bit!
|
|
|
|
Post by giggergrl on Sept 26, 2005 16:30:39 GMT -5
i think liam has pretty bad add (attn deficit disorder.) he needs predictability, organization and the song lyrics and front of him and all right ?
I think noel possibly wants a highly controlled environment.. for obvious reasons.. just a theory....
yeah all those bands dj listed above I fucking remember writing set lists and all at shows... not mentioning any band names ;D cos they were diff. each nite !!!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by Mogly on Sept 26, 2005 16:42:39 GMT -5
yeah I thought LTBL and KTDA were gonna be played. it seems like we might have to wait for the next tour which sucks cos it good be 2 or 3 years. If liam doesn't want to learn the words for different song then noel should step up and play some of his. Wouldn't it be great to hear HTWA or Talk Tonight? electric guitar versions for both songs are just massive. maybe he could play whatever like he did in barrowlands in 2001. Maybe the acoustic set should come back. it would also help liam a lot cos he could rest his voice more
|
|
|
|
Post by djlen74 on Sept 26, 2005 16:50:20 GMT -5
I stand by what I said before about how Part Of The Queue would be MEGA acoustic, just Noel and his guitar
|
|
|
|
Post by turnupthetruth on Sept 26, 2005 16:54:18 GMT -5
Keep the Dream Alive!!! We should all shout this inbetween every song at SI.
|
|
|
|
Post by brumoscardo on Sept 26, 2005 17:13:45 GMT -5
I've just seen an Avril Lavigne gig last night and she played an 18-song set and she's got only 3 records.. I just don't get it.. why don't they play at least 22 songs? are they just lazy? everybody thinks their best gig was in Glasgow 2001 know why? coz that's exactly how many songs they should play.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2005 17:28:40 GMT -5
I've just seen an Avril Lavigne gig last night and she played an 18-song set and she's got only 3 records.. I just don't get it.. why don't they play at least 22 songs? are they just lazy? everybody thinks their best gig was in Glasgow 2001 know why? coz that's exactly how many songs they should play. sad but true |
|
|
|
Post by Elias on Sept 26, 2005 17:50:34 GMT -5
I've just seen an Avril Lavigne gig last night and she played an 18-song set and she's got only 3 records.. I just don't get it.. why don't they play at least 22 songs? are they just lazy? everybody thinks their best gig was in Glasgow 2001 know why? coz that's exactly how many songs they should play. But when all 18 songs are crap who cares? I do see where you're coming from kalas, but for me, the power and intesity of a band live is what makes a great live band, not what they do with the set. Oasis will be a truly great live band no matter what songs they play - cos of the way they play em. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2005 17:57:27 GMT -5
I've just seen an Avril Lavigne gig last night and she played an 18-song set and she's got only 3 records.. I just don't get it.. why don't they play at least 22 songs? are they just lazy? everybody thinks their best gig was in Glasgow 2001 know why? coz that's exactly how many songs they should play. But when all 18 songs are crap who cares? I do see where you're coming from kalas, but for me, the power and intesity of a band live is what makes a great live band, not what they do with the set. Oasis will be a truly great live band no matter what songs they play - cos of the way they play em. i agree..BUT.... they can be EVEN BETTER ...THATS THE SAD PART ...THEY GOT ALL THIS MATERIAL YET THEY DONT USE IT ....PS ..DAMN THE GIRL IN YOUR SIG IS HOT! |
|
|
|
Post by Elias on Sept 26, 2005 18:02:05 GMT -5
But when all 18 songs are crap who cares? I do see where you're coming from kalas, but for me, the power and intesity of a band live is what makes a great live band, not what they do with the set. Oasis will be a truly great live band no matter what songs they play - cos of the way they play em. i agree..BUT.... they can be EVEN BETTER ...THATS THE SAD PART ...THEY GOT ALL THIS MATERIAL YET THEY DONT USE IT ....PS ..DAMN THE GIRL IN YOUR SIG IS HOT! I know ;D The band aint half bad either  I know what you mean about the set. I'd love them to dig into the catalogue more, it's almost un-rivalled, you'd think they'd want to show it off  |
|
|
|
Post by brumoscardo on Sept 26, 2005 19:15:38 GMT -5
I've just seen an Avril Lavigne gig last night and she played an 18-song set and she's got only 3 records.. I just don't get it.. why don't they play at least 22 songs? are they just lazy? everybody thinks their best gig was in Glasgow 2001 know why? coz that's exactly how many songs they should play. But when all 18 songs are crap who cares? You're missing the point there..  |
|
..i love them but to be considered a great live act they gotta get a bit daring...the fact that all of us here can tell the person next to him or her at the gig next week what song is coming next just aint right...
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5