|
|
Post by mape on Apr 18, 2005 21:15:03 GMT -5
what's up with all these 'fanboy' reviews here?
all i've been reading is how everyone is super happy after hearing them. And the others, those that have found a problem with the songs seem to get burned at the stake.
It's seems as though people here might be afraid to criticize the songs because they think that they might get flamed. Just cos you're a fan of something, doesn't mean you are not allowed to criticize it.
so everyone go on and speak your mind (but use intelligence!)
|
|
wash25
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 335
|
Post by wash25 on Apr 18, 2005 21:26:22 GMT -5
Alright. Um.........I hate the outros. Not enough verses (or choruses, as the case may be), TOO LONG OF POINTLESS OUTROS!!!!
It reminds me of ABBEY ROAD in the sense that, just when you're getting into a good song-- it's over! Like, you know how I guess McCartney was wanting some of the songs to sound like half of songs?
I hated that. And then on the other side, some songs just won't end.
|
|
|
|
Post by nyr401994 on Apr 18, 2005 21:33:06 GMT -5
what's up with all these 'fanboy' reviews here? all i've been reading is how everyone is super happy after hearing them. And the others, those that have found a problem with the songs seem to get burned at the stake. It's seems as though people here might be afraid to criticize the songs because they think that they might get flamed. Just cos you're a fan of something, doesn't mean you are not allowed to criticize it. so everyone go on and speak your mind (but use intelligence!) finally, a smart and well-thought argument |
|
|
|
Post by ingotheranchhand on Apr 18, 2005 22:04:09 GMT -5
Yeah. it's getting pretty ridiculous with all these "I would have done this differently" rubbish...
|
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Apr 18, 2005 23:28:12 GMT -5
that endy bell song is shit, sounds like a fuckin collegeband song about going on a roadtrip and gettin pissed of half a stella. let there be love is to me like the masterplans little ugly stepchild with alot of potential, meaning of soul is the put your money where your mouth is of this album just alot catchier and mucky fingers is noel writing a song after reading nme on the shitter.
|
|
jtmOBX
Oasis Roadie
"There we were... Now here we are."
Posts: 355
|
Post by jtmOBX on Apr 18, 2005 23:39:54 GMT -5
What erks me most is people constantly trying to compare everything to DM or WTS(MG). At points it seems like the only thing that would make people happy is if Oasis went back in and rerecorded DM, Jesus wouldnt that fly like a lead balloon if they tried that as a new cd.
While I have a few issues with some of their new stuff, and Ive made a few posts about it (got slammed plenty for it too), I think some people should wake up and realize DM already came out, so quit looking for it to come out again.
|
|
|
|
Post by StepOut on Apr 18, 2005 23:47:38 GMT -5
that endy bell song is shit, sounds like a fuckin collegeband song about going on a roadtrip and gettin pissed of half a stella. let there be love is to me like the masterplans little ugly stepchild with alot of potential, meaning of soul is the put your money where your mouth is of this album just alot catchier and mucky fingers is noel writing a song after reading nme on the shitter. once again, learn how to spell properly. |
|
|
|
Post by brumoscardo on Apr 18, 2005 23:49:18 GMT -5
What erks me most is people constantly trying to compare everything to DM or WTS(MG). At points it seems like the only thing that would make people happy is if Oasis went back in and rerecorded DM, Jesus wouldnt that fly like a lead balloon if they tried that as a new cd. While I have a few issues with some of their new stuff, and Ive made a few posts about it (got slammed plenty for it too), I think some people should wake up and realize DM already came out, so quit looking for it to come out again. That's a great point there mate cheers |
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Apr 18, 2005 23:54:16 GMT -5
once again, learn how to spell properly. sorry. forgot this was the grammar 101 messageboard. xxxxxxxxx |
|
|
|
Post by StepOut on Apr 18, 2005 23:58:37 GMT -5
sorry. forgot this was the grammar 101 messageboard. xxxxxx there's no need for name calling. You're right this isn't "grammar 101". However it doesn't take a rocket scientist to spell Andy. Well, in your case it's endy. |
|
wash25
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 335
|
Post by wash25 on Apr 19, 2005 0:31:13 GMT -5
Well what do you want to compare it to, Yanni? Ok, then it's rockin'!
|
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Apr 19, 2005 0:33:51 GMT -5
there's no need for name calling. You're right this isn't "grammar 101". However it doesn't take a rocket scientist to spell Andy. Well, in your case it's endy. fucks sake been drinkin for 6 hours, new album mad fer it soz i cant spell tho. however i stick to him being a vagina just cos he fuckin started |
|
jtmOBX
Oasis Roadie
"There we were... Now here we are."
Posts: 355
|
Post by jtmOBX on Apr 19, 2005 0:35:50 GMT -5
I was making a comment about the people who are never pleased with anything theyve done since WTS(MG). "Its alright, sounds like a b-side they turned down from DM" or "Noels lost the touch since WTS(MG)" That kind of bull shit.
Compare it to what ever you fuckin like, Yanni, Boy George or whatever. I was just stating my opinion.
|
|
|
|
Post by shakermaker00 on Apr 19, 2005 0:39:54 GMT -5
and you're right. you should fuckin post it on the rollingstone, sun and every other newspapers website instead of here. most of the people on this have only been listening to oasis for a year or two. this messageboard thing gets old after a while to most people
|
|
jtmOBX
Oasis Roadie
"There we were... Now here we are."
Posts: 355
|
Post by jtmOBX on Apr 19, 2005 0:43:02 GMT -5
Good damn point. Got myself a letter to the editor in the making.
|
|
|
|
Post by Black Rebel Motorcycle Pixie. on Apr 19, 2005 0:45:40 GMT -5
that endy bell song is shit, sounds like a fuckin collegeband song about going on a roadtrip and gettin pissed of half a stella. let there be love is to me like the masterplans little ugly stepchild with alot of potential, meaning of soul is the put your money where your mouth is of this album just alot catchier and mucky fingers is noel writing a song after reading nme on the shitter. Who the fuck is endy bell? |
|
|
|
Post by Moorish on Apr 19, 2005 3:54:43 GMT -5
What erks me most is people constantly trying to compare everything to DM or WTS(MG). At points it seems like the only thing that would make people happy is if Oasis went back in and rerecorded DM, Jesus wouldnt that fly like a lead balloon if they tried that as a new cd. While I have a few issues with some of their new stuff, and Ive made a few posts about it (got slammed plenty for it too), I think some people should wake up and realize DM already came out, so quit looking for it to come out again. Well said! Like everyone here there are things I would change about the new tunes, but not because I want to make them more like the OLD OAsis, just because I think certain chanegs would make the tunes better. After the pasting the band have taken over the years for refusing to try anything new, we should be CELEBRATING the fact that they finally are. |
|
|
|
Post by iamspacecase on Apr 19, 2005 4:30:10 GMT -5
We should also be glad that the boys set out to do something in particular with this album, and from the 4 tracks I've heard so far (haven't heard LTBL yet) they've succeeded. What I mean is, Noel said that he wanted the new album to be more psychedelic and have a notable Dylan Highway 61 sound--I'd say that Mucky Fingers is a total realization of that vision. We should be celebrating that at least the band has achieved what they wanted.
Since Be Here Now, Noel seems to have tried hard to distance himself from that style, and not write songs that are 6+ minutes long with huge solos. IMHO, after SOTSOG and HC, I think they may have finally pulled it off. Its different but its still Oasis, whether we love it as much as DM, we should love the successful progression.
|
|
jtmOBX
Oasis Roadie
"There we were... Now here we are."
Posts: 355
|
Post by jtmOBX on Apr 19, 2005 8:48:17 GMT -5
Not heard the new tracks yet, well besides Lyla of course, but am glad to hear its receiving some good critism.
Its pretty damn envitable, that Oasis would change over the years. Fuck, as much as people change how could we not expect a band full of people to change at least a little bit. As long as they write good rock n roll and keep their damn attitude and swagger Ill back the boys.
|
|
|
|
Post by lionsden® on Apr 19, 2005 8:58:03 GMT -5
sorry. forgot this was the grammar 101 messageboard. xxxxxxxxx This guy is still here???  |
|
|
|
Post by soquester on Apr 19, 2005 9:01:40 GMT -5
We should also be glad that the boys set out to do something in particular with this album, and from the 4 tracks I've heard so far (haven't heard LTBL yet) they've succeeded. What I mean is, Noel said that he wanted the new album to be more psychedelic and have a notable Dylan Highway 61 sound--I'd say that Mucky Fingers is a total realization of that vision. We should be celebrating that at least the band has achieved what they wanted. Since Be Here Now, Noel seems to have tried hard to distance himself from that style, and not write songs that are 6+ minutes long with huge solos. IMHO, after SOTSOG and HC, I think they may have finally pulled it off. Its different but its still Oasis, whether we love it as much as DM, we should love the successful progression. Dude, I don't think your 6 minute argument works too well... 3/5 tracks that we have are over 5 minutes, which is a big group considering we have only got 5 tracks... For reference: 2 off HC, 4 SOTSOG, 8 off BHN(!) 4 MG, 4 DM... Of course, it could be that Lyla, Keep The Dream Alive and Let There Be Love will be the only long tracks on the album, which would prove me wrong... But either way, it's not like they're shying away from the long songs at all... |
|
jtmOBX
Oasis Roadie
"There we were... Now here we are."
Posts: 355
|
Post by jtmOBX on Apr 19, 2005 9:04:21 GMT -5
These could be radio edits as well. I dont think we have to ever worry about Noel giving up his guitar bits, at least I hope not.
|
|
jtmOBX
Oasis Roadie
"There we were... Now here we are."
Posts: 355
|
Post by jtmOBX on Apr 19, 2005 9:06:44 GMT -5
Ah nevermind guess they are longer. All I have to work on is Lyla.
|
|
|
|
Post by globe on Apr 19, 2005 10:21:20 GMT -5
what's up with all these 'fanboy' reviews here? all i've been reading is how everyone is super happy after hearing them. And the others, those that have found a problem with the songs seem to get burned at the stake. It's seems as though people here might be afraid to criticize the songs because they think that they might get flamed. Just cos you're a fan of something, doesn't mean you are not allowed to criticize it. so everyone go on and speak your mind (but use intelligence!) Your right Mape, but its pretty annoying when the people who are saying they dont like the new songs are comparing them to DM or WTSMG. One guy yesterday was even saying that every song on BHN was better than Mucky Fingers. If its not a progression or a different sounding song than the likes of 'I Hope I Think I Know', or 'My Big Mouth', then they might aswell cancel all the summer gigs, pack up their Les Pauls and call it a day for good. I myself havent heard them yet so I cant comment. Just my 'tuppence worth. |
|
.jpg)
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5